Home Journals Progress in Chemistry
Progress in Chemistry

Abbreviation (ISO4): Prog Chem      Editor in chief: Jincai ZHAO

About  /  Aim & scope  /  Editorial board  /  Indexed  /  Contact  / 
Review

Synthesis of Low-Symmetry 2D Transition Metal Dichalcogenides by Chemical Vapor Deposition

  • Chen Yun 1 ,
  • Zhang Hui 2 ,
  • Luo Zheng 2 ,
  • Mao Weiguo 3 ,
  • Pan Jun'an , 1, * ,
  • Wang Shanshan , 2, *
Expand
  • 1 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Xiangtan University, Xiangtan 411105, China
  • 2 Science and Technology on Advanced Ceramic Fibers and Composites Laboratory, College of Aerospace Science and Engineering, National University of Defense Technology, Changsha 410073, China
  • 3 College of Materials Science and Engineering, Changsha University of Science and Technology, Changsha 410114, China
*e-mail: (Jun'an Pan);
(Shanshan Wang)

Received date: 2023-08-15

  Revised date: 2024-02-08

  Online published: 2024-03-15

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52172032)

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52222201)

Young Elite Scientists Sponsorship Program by CAST(YESS20200222)

National University of Defense Technology(ZZCX-ZZGC-01-07)

Hunan Natural Science Foundation(2022JJ20044)

Abstract

Low-symmetry two-dimensional materials are a new type of nanomaterials with few lattice symmetry operations and only atomic-level thickness in the longitudinal direction.In the two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides(TMDs)system,1T'-MoTe2,1T'-WTe2,1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2are typical low-symmetry members.The unique lattice symmetry brings them rich anisotropic physical and chemical properties,so they have special application prospects in the fields of micro-nano photonics,tactile sensors,and anisotropic logic devices.The basic research and application development of low-symmetry two-dimensional TMD materials relies on the high-quality,large-size,and stable preparation of such materials.Therefore,this paper takes these four types of materials as typical materials,first classifies them according to metal precursors,and reviews the chemical vapor deposition(CVD)preparation methods of low-symmetry two-dimensional TMD materials in recent years.According to the characteristics of 1T′-MoTe2easy to undergo phase transition and weak interaction between 1T'-ReS2,1T'-ReSe2and the substrate during the preparation process,the phase regulation mechanism in the preparation process of 1T'-MoTe2and the substrate engineering research in the preparation process of 1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2were introduced.Finally,this paper looks forward to the future challenges and opportunities of low-symmetry 2D TMDs materials 。

Contents

1 Introduction

2 1T'-MTe2(M=Mo,W )

2.1 CVD preparation of 1T'-MTe2

2.2 Phase regulation of MTe2

3 1T'-ReX2(X=S,Se )

3.1 Precursor of rhenium

3.2 Precursor of rhenium trioxide

3.3 Precursor of ammonium perrhenate

4 Conclusions and outlook

Cite this article

Chen Yun , Zhang Hui , Luo Zheng , Mao Weiguo , Pan Jun'an , Wang Shanshan . Synthesis of Low-Symmetry 2D Transition Metal Dichalcogenides by Chemical Vapor Deposition[J]. Progress in Chemistry, 2024 , 36(4) : 537 -555 . DOI: 10.7536/PC230810

1 Introduction

Since the discovery of graphene in 2004,the research on two-dimensional materials has undergone a rapid development process[1]。 Two-dimensional materials have a unique structure,in which atoms can be arranged periodically in the plane to form a specific crystal structure,while in the longitudinal direction,they are only atomically thick.This brings novel physical and chemical properties such as mechanical flexibility,optical transparency and special electronic structure.Transition metal dichalcogenides(TMDs)are typical representatives of Two-dimensional materials,which are composed of Transition metal elements and chalcogen nonmetal elements.Two-dimensional TMDs are rich in composition and structure,so they have diverse properties,covering a wide range of properties from insulators,semiconductors,metals to superconductors in terms of electrical properties,so they have broad application prospects in the fields of highly integrated chips,nanoelectronic and optoelectronic devices,sensing,catalysis and energy[2][3,4][5][6][7][8][9][10]
The crystal structure of two-dimensional TMDs has a profound impact on its properties and functions.Newman's theorem shows that the symmetry of any macroscopic physical property of a crystal must have all the symmetry elements of the corresponding point group of the crystal.Therefore,understanding the structure of two-dimensional crystals from the perspective of symmetry is the basis and key to the design,development and application of these new nanomaterials.According to the level of structural symmetry(or the number of symmetry elements),crystals can be divided into seven major crystal systems and three major crystal groups(high,medium and low crystal groups).2D materials such as 2H,1T,and 3R phases MoS2,WS2,which are common in TMDs,belong to the hexagonal,tetragonal,and trigonal crystal systems,respectively,corresponding to the intermediate class with higher symmetry[11,12]。 Orthorhombic,monoclinic,and triclinic systems belonging to the lower group have lower symmetry and fewer symmetry elements(no rotation axis or antiaxis higher than 2),and typical materials in two-dimensional TMDs include 1T'-WTe2(with orthorhombic multilayer and monoclinic monolayer),1T'-MoTe2,ReS2,and ReSe2(Fig.1A )[13]。 from the point of view of coordination mode,these low symmetry TMDs all have distorted octahedral coordination structure in the layer,which is significantly different From the triangular prism and octahedral coordination form of 1 H and 1 T phase TMDs[14][5,15]。 This is due to the second order splitting of the d orbital caused by the Jahn-Teller effect,which leads to the rearrangement of electrons.Taking ReS2as an example(Figure 1b),after the first order splitting of the 5d3orbital,the three valence electrons occupy the three degenerate orbitals of t2grespectively.This electron arrangement is energetically unfavorable,so the Jahn-Teller effect further splits the t2genergy levels in the octahedral field,thus breaking the degeneracy and causing the ReS2to become a distorted octahedral(1T')structure[16]
图1 (a) 1T'-MoTe2、1T'-WTe2、1T'-ReS2和1T'-ReSe2原子结构示意图; (b) 1T'-ReS2和1T'-ReSe2中Re的价电子结构

Fig. 1 (a) Schematic atomic structure of 1T'-MoTe2, 1T'-WTe2, 1T'-ReS2 and 1T'-ReSe2; (b) valence electron structures of Re in 1T'-ReS2 and 1T'-ReSe2

The low lattice symmetry brings significant anisotropic physicochemical properties to this class of two-dimensional materials.Taking triclinic ReS2as an example,Xing et al.Fabricated field-effect transistors using mechanically exfoliated two-dimensional ReS2,which not only showed a large current switching ratio of~107,but also a switching ratio difference of up to 3.1 times along the two principal axes,which is the most significant degree of in-plane anisotropy among all known semiconducting two-dimensional materials[17]。 Hone et al.Found that monolayer and few-layer ReS2have strong anisotropy in Raman scattering response to linearly polarized excitation,and demonstrated that polarized Raman scattering can determine the crystal orientation of ReS2[18]。 Zhao et al.Measured that the absorption coefficient of ReS2for polarized light along the b-axis is 2.5 times that of the a-axis[19]。 Liu et al.Found that when a thin ReS2is stretched along two different principal axes,it shows opposite piezoresistive coefficients[20]。 The anisotropic behavior of low-symmetry materials has potential applications in sensors,photodetectors,logic devices,and electrocatalytic reactions。
However,at present,the realization of the above unique functions is mainly based on the mechanical exfoliation method,which has high crystallinity,but the size is small and the thickness is difficult to control,so it can not be produced in batches.Chemical vapor deposition(CVD)is currently the most promising method to achieve high-quality,large-scale and controllable preparation of two-dimensional materials[21]。 Compared with the mechanical exfoliation method,it has many significant advantages,such as the control of the nanostructure and surface morphology of the product by adjusting the process parameters,the high quality of the product with few defects,the repeatability of the synthesis process,and the reasonable cost[22]。 At present,many representative achievements have been made in the CVD preparation of two-dimensional TMDs with high symmetry.Wang et al.Obtained centimeter-scale,uniform,double-layer MoS2on sapphire substrate,and the field-effect transistor prepared by this method has 122.6 cm2·V-1·s-1high carrier mobility,and the device performance exceeds the goal of high-performance field-effect transistor in 2028[23]。 Loh et al.Fabricated large size hexagonal WSe2on SiO2substrates,and the photodetectors fabricated from them have 1100 mA·W-1and high responsivity[24]。 Compared with high-symmetry two-dimensional TMDs,the CVD preparation of low-symmetry two-dimensional TMDs still has challenges such as small grain size,low thickness uniformity,and difficulty in obtaining single crystals.the first two common problems in the synthesis of two-dimensional materials will affect the general performance of devices.However,the difficulty of obtaining single crystals will lead to the loss of the unique anisotropic physical and chemical properties of low-symmetry two-dimensional materials macroscopically due to the averaging effect brought by different orientations of grains[25]。 Therefore,a systematic summary and in-depth understanding of low-symmetry two-dimensional materials and synthetic methods and mechanisms are essential for the development of more efficient synthetic pathways for such materials。
In this paper,we focus on the preparation of two-dimensional 1T'-MX2(M(transition metal element,X is chalcogen non-metal element)by CVD.Firstly,the CVD methods of 1T'-MX2in recent years are systematically summarized according to the classification of precursors.Subsequently,in order to solve the problems of phase transformation of 1T'-MoTe2and weak interaction between 1T'-ReS2,1T'-ReSe2and substrate in the preparation process.The phase control mechanism of 1T'-MoTe2and the basement engineering of 1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2are introduced respectively.Finally,the CVD fabrication of 2D TMDs with low symmetry is prospected 。

2 1T'-MTe2(M=Mo 、W)

High quality transition metal sulfides and selenides can be prepared controllably by bottom-up chemical vapor deposition(CVD).However,for the CVD preparation of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2,there are the following difficulties:(1)The electronegativity difference between Mo,W and Te is small(~0.4 eV),which leads to the small bond energy of Mo-Te and W-Te and the low chemical stability of the products[26,27][28][29~31]; There are 2H phase and 1T'phase with similar thermodynamic energy in the(2)MoTe2,which are easy to transform and difficult to obtain a single phase product[32]。 In recent years,researchers have made many efforts to solve these difficulties。

2.1 CVD preparation of 1T'-MTe2.

Precursor species is a key factor affecting the growth of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2.By changing the precursor species,the efficiency and uniformity of the gas-phase mass transfer process can be improved[33]。 Therefore,the CVD-controlled synthesis of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2is reviewed from the following aspects:metal precursors(Mo,W),oxide precursors(MoOx,WO3),and ammonium salt precursors 。

2.1.1 Metal precursor

The use of elemental substances(Mo,W)as precursors has a simple chemical reaction process,so it has been used to prepare 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2earlier,and the preparation method is usually to Te Mo,W films(Fig.2a,B )[30,34,35]。 In 2015,Lee et al.Deposited a 50 nm amorphous Mo film on a 300 nm SiO2/Si substrate by electron beam evaporation or sputtering[34]。 Centimeter-scale multilayer 1T'-MoTe2films were obtained by annealing the Te-treated Mo films at low Te vapor pressure(Figure 2A).In the same year,Dresselhaus et al.Reduced the thickness of the Mo film to 1 nm and inverted it on a boat containing Te powder,thus obtaining a thinner and more uniform 1T'-MoTe2film[30]。 In 2017,Cha et al.Used a similar method to prepare centimeter-scale 1T'-WTe2((Fig.2b )[35]。 Different from before,Cha et al.Studied the effect of W film thickness on the product thickness,and they prepared W films with different thicknesses(1–30 nm)by sputtering method,and the results showed that the 1T'-WTe2films of 10,31 and 54 nm could be obtained from W films of 2.3,4.2 and 7.1 nm thickness,respectively.From the statistical results,the thickness of 1T'-WTe2film is about 6–7 times of that of W film.In addition,they analyzed two chemical reactions in the growth process:
$\mathrm{H}_{2 \text { (gas) }}+\mathrm{Te}_{\text {(rapor) }} \leftrightarrow \mathrm{H}_{2} \mathrm{Te}_{\text {(gas) }}$
$\mathrm{H}_{2} \mathrm{Te}+\mathrm{W} \rightarrow \mathrm{WTe}_{2}+\mathrm{H}_{2}$
图2 (a) 用Mo膜合成1T'-MoTe2薄膜的实验装置示意图,插图是在SiO2/Si衬底上的1T'-MoTe2薄膜的示意图[34]; (b) 用W膜合成1T'-WTe2薄膜的实验装置示意图[35]; (c) 用2 nm的W种子层生长的1T'-WTe2的AFM图像[35]; (d) 以Mo和MoO3为前驱体制备1T'-MoTe2的过程示意图[45]; (e,f) 以Mo和MoO3为前驱体生长的1T'-MoTe2的AFM图像[45]

Fig. 2 (a) Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for the synthesis of the 1T'-MoTe2 film by Mo film. Inset is a schematic diagram of the 1T'-MoTe2 film on a SiO2/Si substrate[34], Copyright 2015, American Chemistry Society; (b) Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for the synthesis of the 1T'-WTe2 film by W film[35]; (c) AFM images of as-grown 1T'-WTe2 from a 2 nm W seed layer[35], Copyright 2017, John Wiley & Sons, Inc; (d) Schematic diagram of the growth process for 1T'-MoTe2 using Mo and MoO3 as precursors[45]; (e, f) AFM image of the 1T'-MoTe2 film grown from MoO3 and Mo, respectively[45], Copyright 2016, John Wiley & Sons, Inc

Te is reduced by H2to hydrogen telluride(H2Te)as an intermediate product,which then reacts with the W film to produce 1T'-WTe2(Fig.2 C).Atomic force microscope(AFM)characterization showed that the product was rough(Fig.2C),on the one hand,due to the uneven deposition of particles during the sputtering process of W film;On the other hand,because the step(1)is a reversible reaction and the H2Te is unstable,Te is not sufficient 。
Large area products with the same size as the substrate can be obtained by using elemental 1T'-MTe2,but the thickness of the products is often more than 10 nm due to the thickness of Mo and W films,and the thickness is not uniform.It is worth noting that the reaction temperature of CVD system is mostly not more than 1100℃,while the melting point of Mo is 2620℃,and the melting point of W is as high as 3400℃.Therefore,the direct use of elemental Mo and W powders as precursors has the problems of difficult volatilization,low concentration and instability of gaseous precursors,and it is difficult to achieve the controllable synthesis of high-quality,large-area 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2[36]

2.1.2 Metal oxide precursor

In order to overcome the problem of high melting point of single substance,researchers began to consider using oxides with relatively low melting point as precursors to improve the concentration and controllability of gaseous precursor supply.The specific strategies include:(1)directly using MOx(x=2,3)as the precursor(the melting point of(MoO2is about 1100°C,that of MoO3is about 800°C,and that of WO3is about 1470°C);(2)on the basis of the MOx,salt and other substances are introduced as a fluxing agent or a sleeve method is used,the fluxing agent can further improve the gaseous concentration of the precursor,and the sleeve method can prevent two gaseous precursors from reacting in the carrier gas transportation process,thereby ensuring the continuous and stable supply of the precursor at the downstream substrate position[36][29,37~42][43,44]; And(3)adding molecular sieves and reagents(OIs)for controlling the volatilization of oxides into the MOx,so that the supply of the precursor is more stable 。
In 2016,Dresselhaus et al.Found that centimeter-scale,uniform-thickness,multilayer 1T'-MoTe2single crystals could be obtained by oxidizing 1 nm Mo films into MoO3films in air and then Te-oxidizing them in Te-poor atmosphere at 700°C(Figure 2D )[45]。 The melting point of MoO3is only 800℃,which can obtain more sufficient gas concentration in the temperature range of CVD equipment.Moreover,by comparing the AFM characterization results,it can be found that the 1T'-MoTe2(prepared with MoO3(Fig.2e)is smoother and denser than that prepared with elemental Mo(Fig.2F).The researchers tested the electrical properties of the 1T'-MoTe2film,and the resistance value was about 1120Ω·sq-1,which was much smaller than that of the 1T'-MoTe2grown with Mo.The improvement of film quality greatly promotes the electrical properties of materials,and also makes MoOxbecome the mainstream precursor for the preparation of 1T'-MoTe2by CVD 。
The concentration of the gaseous precursor can be further increased by adding salts and other substances to the oxide as a flux.Liu et al.added Te powder and MoCl5(WCl6)powder into MoO3(WO3)powder(Fig.3A),on the one hand,Te powder can form a low melting point eutectic with MoO3(WO3))powder,which can reduce the melting point of the precursor to below 450°C,thereby increasing the precursor concentration[29]; On the other hand,MoCl5(WCl6)itself has a low melting point,with a MoCl5of about 190°C and a WCl6of about 270°C,which is easy to evaporate and contributes to rapid nucleation[36]。 Liu et al.Placed the boat containing the mixed powder in the center of the quartz tube,another boat containing Te powder in the upstream,and the SiO2/Si substrate in the downstream,and reacted at 820°C for 5 min to obtain monolayer 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2single crystals with sizes of∼350 and∼150μm,respectively.Few-layer 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2can also be obtained by prolonging the growth time or changing the Te source concentration.In the Scanning transmission electron microscopy(STEM)images of few-layer Scanning transmission electron microscopy and 1T'-WTe2(Fig.3 B,C),no obvious vacancy defects were observed,indicating that the crystallinity of Scanning transmission electron microscopy and 1T'-WTe2is good.The researchers further studied the electrical properties of the two materials.Interestingly,at low temperature and zero magnetic field,the bilayer 1T'-WTe2showed insulating behavior,while the 1T'-MoTe2showed superconducting properties.It is worth noting that although this method can prepare 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2with large area,controllable number of layers and uniform thickness,it has not been widely used in subsequent studies because of the high reaction speed of MoCl5(WCl6),which is dangerous.In addition to the addition of Te powder and MoCl5(WCl6)to the oxide,the addition of alkali metal salts can also improve the volatility of the precursor.On the one hand,alkali metal salts(NaCl,KCl,KI,etc.)Can also reduce the melting point of metal oxides and react with metal oxides to form volatile intermediates;On the other hand,alkali metals(Na,K,Li,etc.)can reduce the reaction barrier and thus increase the reaction rate[46]。 KI can react with MoO2to produce volatile intermediates such as MoO2I2,which can greatly increase the concentration of Mo in the gaseous state.Fu et al.Placed a mixture of MoO2powder and KI powder in a boat,and inverted the substrate on the boat,which could increase the Mo source concentration on the surface of the substrate[37]。 The mixture was heated to 700°C for 80 min,and high coverage 1T'-MoTe2single crystal flakes with thickness of 1.0–5.1 nm were obtained.In addition,KI can volatilize at high temperature,thus reducing impurity residues.The relationship between the conductivity of 1T'-MoTe2and temperature is analyzed,and the results show that 1T'-MoTe2has a smaller relative localization length than MoSe2[47]。 Intermediates such as gaseous MoO2Cl2and MoOCl4can also be produced by the reaction of NaCl and MoO3,thus increasing the concentration of precursors.Jo et al.Heated the mixture of MoO3powder and NaCl powder to 710°C for 30 min,and obtained 1T'-MoTe2flakes with thickness varying from 3.5 nm(5 layers)to 7.7 nm(11 layers)on the surface of SiO2/Si substrate[38]。 Subsequently,they utilized the same method and fabricated few-layer 1T'-MoTe2flakes on various substrates(sapphire,silicon nitride,and mica).The amount of NaCl can greatly affect the morphology of the product(Fig.3D).Appropriate use can increase the nucleation density,while excessive use can lead to the formation of thick nuclei.In the preparation of 1T'-WTe2,water can also be used as a growth adjuvant to form a volatile WO2(OH)2with WO3,thereby increasing the concentration of W source and optimizing the quality of the product.Hao et al.Oxidized W foil into a WO3film,vertically stacked with c-plane sapphire,and placed in the center of a quartz tube[42]; Add 0.05 mL of water to the Te powder and place it upstream of the quartz tube(Fig.3e).The stacking of the WO3film and the substrate realizes the spatial confinement,which can improve the stability of the Te process.Based on this method,Hao et al.Prepared 1T'-WTe2flakes with a thickness of 1.8 nm at 720°C.By changing the flow rate of H2,the morphology of the product changed from rectangular(10~25 sccm)to triangular(30~40 sccm)to irregular(45 sccm).Compared with the alkali metal salt auxiliary agent,the water auxiliary agent better avoids the problem of doping.It should be noted that excessive water will lead to the etching of 1T'-WTe2,which will inhibit the nucleation and growth of 1T'-WTe2.Previous studies have shown that the substrate symmetry can modulate the activation energy barrier of different crystal phases of the domain,and then affect the morphology of the domain[48,49]。 Hao et al.Counted the growth orientation of 1T'-WTe2on different substrates.On the c-plane sapphire substrate with threefold symmetry,1T'-WTe2showed three growth orientations with an angular spacing of 60°(Fig.3F);While on the a-plane sapphire substrate with dual symmetry,1T'-WTe2exhibits a single orientation(Figure 3G),and this result well confirms the influence of substrate symmetry on the product morphology 。
图3 (a) 低熔点共晶法辅助生长1T'-MoTe2和1T'-WTe2原子层的实验装置示意图[29]; (b, c) 少层1T'-MoTe2和1T'-WTe2的STEM实验图像[29]; (d) 不同比值的MoO3和NaCl混合物反应产物的光学显微镜图像[38]; (e) 水辅助法生长1T'-WTe2原子层的实验装置示意图[42]; (f, g) 1T'-WTe2在c面和a面蓝宝石衬底上的生长取向统计分布直方图[42]; (h, i) 650和800 ℃合成的1T'-MoTe2的光学显微图像[40]; (j) 生长温度升高过程中形貌变化和沿两个方向生长速率(υa和υb)变化的示意图,插图为1T'-MoTe2纳米带的球棒模型[40]

Fig. 3 (a) Schematic diagram of experimental setup for the assisted growth of the 1T'-MoTe2 and 1T'-WTe2 atomic layers by low melting point eutectic method[29]. (b, c) Experimental STEM image of 1T'-MoTe2 and 1T'-WTe2 few layer[29], Copyright 2017, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (d) Optical microscope images of the reaction products with different molar ratios of MoO3 and NaCl mixtures[38], Copyright 2017, Springer Nature. (e) Schematic diagram of experimental setup for the growth of the 1T'-WTe2 atomic layers by water-assisted methods[42]. (f, g) Histogram of growth orientation statistical distribution of 1T'-WTe2 on the c-plane and a-plane sapphire substrate[42], Copyright 2022, IOP Publishing. (h, i) Optical microscopic images of 1T'-MoTe2 synthesized at 650 and 800 ℃[40]. (j) Schematic diagram of morphology and growth rate in two direction evolution (υa and υb) during the growth temperature increasing[40] (the inset is the ball-and-stick model of 1T'-MoTe2 nanoribbon), Copyright 2020, RSC Publishing

In the CVD growth process,the unstable supply of gaseous precursors can also affect the uniformity and size of the product,which can be avoided to some extent by the addition of molecular sieves and reagents(OIs)to control the volatilization of oxides.Feng et al.Placed a mixture of MoO3and NaCl in a small boat and completely covered the powder with a molecular sieve with a pore size of about 44Å[40]。 Molecular sieves can not only act as a physical barrier to prevent the transfer of MoO3powder to the substrate surface(contributing to the cleanliness of the substrate);It can also be used as a microcontainer to control the stable release of Mo source precursor,thus realizing the large-scale and uniform nucleation of MoO3on the SiO2/Si substrate,and the domain size of single crystal 1T'-MoTe2can reach almost 100μm.This study also found that temperature had a significant effect on the product morphology(Figure 3H,I).The calculation results show that the formation energy of the B(100)orientation of MoTe2increases greatly with the increase of the growth temperature,which leads to the faster growth rate of the a(010)orientation than that of the B(100)orientation(Fig.3j),and finally the ribbon morphology is obtained.This achievement further explains the growth mechanism of 1T'-MoTe2.Cheng et al.Used OIs to cover the MoO3to optimize the release of Mo vapor in the CVD reaction,and finally obtained a monolayer 1T'-MoTe2sheet on the SiO2/Si substrate[50]。 They found that higher Mo∶Te favored the in-plane fast growth of MoTe2monolayer,while lower Mo∶X favored the out-of-plane fast growth,resulting in the formation of multilayer structure 。

2.1.3 Metal ammonium salt precursor

Ammonium heptamolybdate((NH4)6Mo7O24,AHM)and ammonium metatungstate((NH4)10W12O41)can decompose to produce gaseous oxides of Mo and W at about 300 and 400°C,respectively.The decomposition temperature of these two compounds is much lower than the melting point of simple substances and oxides,so they can significantly increase the concentration of gaseous precursors[51,52]。 This summary will be further summarized according to the supply mode of ammonium salt precursor,including:(1)heating ammonium salt powder;(2)depositing droplets of ammonium salt aqueous solution;(3)spin coat ammonium salt aqueous solution.Compared with the ammonium salt powder,the concentration of the metal precursor can be controlled more finely by using the ammonium salt aqueous solution,and the uniformity of the precursor on the surface of the substrate can be improved by using the spin coating method,so that the preparation of a large-area thin film is realized.In addition,the substrate is pretreated by plasma or acidic solution before spin coating to enhance the hydrophilicity of the substrate,which helps the precursor solution to be distributed more uniformly。
Xu et al.Dissolved(NH4)6Mo7O24or(NH4)10W12O41powder and KCl in deionized water(DI)and obtained a uniform mixture of(NH4)6Mo7O24and KCl((NH4)10W12O41and KCl)after drying[53]。 The mixture was placed in the middle of the quartz tube as the Mo(W)source,and the Te powder was placed in the upstream as the Te source.High-quality and large-area single-layer and multilayer 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2single crystals(Fig.4 B,C)were grown by using both the inversion method and the sleeve method(Fig.4A),and the maximum size of the products could reach 1 mm and 350µm,respectively.Since the MoO3produced by precursor decomposition is more active than WO3,the growth size of MoTe2is larger than that of WTe2.It is found that K(Na)Cl is the trigger factor for the growth of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2in the CVD process,and the flow rate of H2and Ar can greatly affect the size of crystal domains.The researchers found some crystal cracks in the Raman scanning images,which are caused by the difference between the thermal expansion coefficients of the 1T'-MoTe2and the 1T'-WTe2and the substrate during the cooling process.Overcoming these cracks can further improve the quality of large-size crystal domains.The electrical property test results of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2flakes show that the thermal activation energy(Schottky barrier)of the bilayer 1T'-MoTe2device is about 35 meV,and that of the trilayer 1T'-WTe2device is about 5 meV,which is close to the value of the mechanically exfoliated sample in the literature,further demonstrating the high quality of the sample[54,55]。 Although the direct use of ammonium salt powder as metal precursor is simple,it is easy to form a large concentration gradient on the substrate surface during the mass transfer process of gaseous precursor,which leads to uneven nucleation and limited size.This problem can be optimized to some extent by using an aqueous solution of an ammonium salt as the precursor。
图4 (a) 用铵盐粉末合成1T'-MoTe2和1T'-WTe2原子层的实验装置示意图[53]; (b, c) 大面积1T'-MoTe2(长≈200 µm,宽≈50 µm)和1T'-WTe2 (长≈320 µm,宽≈80 µm)晶体的光学显微镜图像[53]; (d) 通过液滴法生长的1T'-MoTe2薄片的光学显微图像,比例尺分别为200、40和10 μm[56]; (e) 完全覆盖的1T'-MoTe2的光学显微图像,白色箭头表示薄片的一小块多层区域[59]; (f, g) 氧等离子体处理前后SiO2/Si基底上生长的1T'-MoTe2的光学显微图像[60]

Fig. 4 (a) Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for the synthesis of the 1T'-MoTe2 and 1T'-WTe2 atomic layers by ammonium salt powder[53]. (b, c) Optical microscope images of large-area 1T'-MoTe2 (length ≈ 200 µm and width ≈ 50 µm) and 1T'-WTe2 (length ≈ 320 µm and width ≈ 80 µm) crystals[53], Copyright 2017, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (d) Optical micrograph images of 1T'-MoTe2 flakes grown by the droplet method. Scale bars are 200, 40, and 10 μm, respectively[56], Copyright 2016, American Chemistry Society. (e) Optical micrograph image of fully covered 1T'-MoTe2, white arrow indicates a small portion of multilayer flakes[59], Copyright 2016, IOP Publishing. (f, g) Optical microscopic image of 1T'-MoTe2 grown on SiO2/Si substrate before and after oxygen plasma treatment[60], Copyright 2021, American Chemistry Society

When(NH4)6Mo7O24((NH4)10W12O41))aqueous solution is used as the Mo(W)source precursor,the precursor can be applied by depositing droplets or spin-coating the solution on the substrate surface.In 2016,Johnson et al.First spin-coated a layer of sodium cholate solution on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate at a speed of 4000 R/min as a growth promoter,and then deposited(NH4)6Mo7O24saturated aqueous solution droplets on the substrate as a Mo source to prepare 1T'-MoTe2flakes with different morphologies[56]。 Due to the lack of uniform spin coating,there is a difference in Mo flux in different regions of the substrate during the growth process,resulting in a significant nucleation density gradient(Figure 4D).In the region with high Mo flux,dendritic polycrystalline 1T'-MoTe2flakes will grow compactly,while in the region with relatively low Mo flux,the nucleation density is small,and rectangular monocrystalline 1T'-MoTe2flakes will grow.In the STEM images,the atomic structures of 1T'-MoTe2with different layer numbers show good agreement with the ball-and-stick model,indicating the high quality of 1T'-MoTe2,which is also the first report on the atomic resolution images of 1T'-MoTe2monolayer.Shortly thereafter,Johnson et al.Prepared 1T'-WTe2flakes by a similar method[57]。 It is worth mentioning that this study is the first to report the decay of monolayer 1T'-WTe2in air,and graphene was used to encapsulate 1T'-WTe2sheets to delay its degradation in air.The results show that the stability of 1T'-WTe2encapsulated by graphene can be improved from tens of minutes to several days,which is of historic significance for the related applications of 1T'-WTe2.In the electrical tests of 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2,the resistance of 1T'-MoTe2showed a clear temperature dependence,while 1T'-WTe2showed a clear metallic behavior.Monolayer 1T'-MoTe2and 1T'-WTe2both have antilocalization(WAL)cusps in low-temperature magnetoconductance measurements,which is crucial for the study of their potential topological insulator properties and their applications in new switching and sensing devices 。
Spinning(NH4)6Mo7O24and(NH4)10W12O41solution on the substrate surface can significantly reduce the effect of gas concentration gradient on the morphology of the product compared with the deposition of droplets[58]。 Lee et al.Mixed AHM,NaOH,OPTI(density gradient medium)aqueous solution at a ratio of 0.3:3:3.5 and spin-coated them uniformly on a SiO2/Si substrate,and obtained a rectangular 1T'-MoTe2sheet with uniform thickness and consistent morphology in the whole domain after the reaction[59]。 By increasing the relative content of(NH4)6Mo7O24aqueous solution in the mixed solution,the size of the crystalline domain can be adjusted,and when the ratio of AHM to NaOH reaches 1:3,a large-area monolayer 1T'-MoTe2film covering the whole substrate is obtained(Fig.4E).In the optical test,the absorption of 1T'-MoTe2to light shows obvious anisotropy in the visible range,which provides a good idea for the visualization of the boundary 。
In order to further improve the uniformity of Mo source precursor distribution on the substrate surface,Coletti et al.Used oxygen plasma to pretreat the surface of SiO2/Si substrate,which effectively increased the free energy of the substrate surface,thus realizing the uniform distribution of reactants on the substrate surface[60]。 Coletti et al.Mixed AHM,NaOH,and OPTI solutions at a ratio of 1∶1∶5.5,and uniformly spin-coated them on the pretreated substrate at a rotation speed of 2900 R/min.After growth at 730°C,single-layer 1T'-MoTe2single crystal flakes with an average size of 250μm×30μm(maximum size of 480μm×65μm)were obtained.Comparing the growth results before and after substrate pretreatment(Fig.4F,G),the advantages of oxygen plasma treatment can be clearly reflected.Encapsulation of 1T'-MoTe2with hexagonal boron nitride(hBN)can extend the lifetime of monolayer 1T'-MoTe2to more than one month without compromising performance.The researchers believe that this packaging method can be widely applied to other two-dimensional materials that are easy to decompose.Zou et al.used 15 mL of 30%hydrogen peroxide and 35 mL of concentrated sulfuric acid to prepare an etching solvent to etch the substrate,which not only cleaned the substrate surface,but also improved the hydrophilicity of the substrate,so as to promote the uniform distribution of the precursor solution on the substrate surface[61]。 Subsequently,Zou et al.Spin-coated a 1:1 mixed solution of sodium molybdate(Na2MoO4)and NaOH on the pretreated substrate at a rotation speed of 8000 R/min,and obtained a centimeter-scale 1T'-MoTe2monolayer at 700°C.The electrical measurement results show that the average resistance of the whole monolayer is 3409Ωand the average conductivity is 1.5×10-5S/m,which indicates the good uniformity of the monolayer 1T'-MoTe2.The temperature dependence test also reveals the typical semiconductor characteristics of the monolayer 1T'-MoTe2

2.2 Phase regulation of MTe2

The existence of 2H phase and 1T'phase with similar thermodynamic energy(energy difference is about 40 meV)in MoTe2,both of which are stable at room temperature and easy to transform,poses a challenge to obtain single-phase MoTe2in CVD preparation[32,62,63]。 How to precisely control the phase state of MoTe2,and then controllably synthesize high-purity 1T'-MoTe2,is a hot research topic in the current academic circles.At present,there are many methods of phase regulation,which can be divided into strain regulation and temperature regulation according to the mechanism 。

2.2.1 Strain control

During the transformation of Mo,MoO3to MoTe2,severe lattice distortion will occur,resulting in a large strain in the lattice structure[30,32,39,64,65]。 Theoretical and experimental results show that 1T'-MoTe2is more stable than 2H-MoTe2under strain conditions.Based on this principle,researchers can control the 1T'-MoTe2by changing the precursor type and adjusting the Te concentration[30,65][34,43,45,66]
Dresselhaus et al.Found that during the transformation to MoTe2,the lattice distortion of Mo is more serious than that of MoO3(about 3 times),and more strain will be generated in the lattice,which will promote the generation of 1T'-MoTe2[30]。 Thus,Dresselhaus et al.Prepared centimeter-scale 1T'-MoTe2thin films using Mo thin films.In 2022,Hu et al.Used this principle to deposit a 5-nm-thick elemental Mo film on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate,and then used photolithography and oxygen plasma treatment to form a Mo/MoO3assembly,which was Te-treated to obtain a polycrystalline 1T'/2H-MoTe2heterojunction(Figure 5A )[65]
The gaseous partial pressure of Te will affect the concentration of Te vacancies in the product MoTe2,and then change the lattice strain of MoTe2.Density functional theory(DFT)calculation shows that when the vacancy concentration of Te exceeds 2%,1T'is more stable than 2H phase[67]。 Johns et al.used Mo as a metal precursor,placed it in the middle of the quartz tube,placed Te powder in the upstream as a Te source,and adjusted the temperature of the Te source by adjusting the position of the Te powder,thereby changing the gaseous partial pressure of Te(Fig.5B)[66]。 The results show that the content of 1T'-MoTe2in the product increases with the decrease of Te vapor pressure,but when the Te powder moves to site D,the complete structure of 1T'-MoTe2can not be formed due to the serious lack of Te atoms.Based on the same principle,Dresselhaus et al.Prepared 1T'-MoTe2thin films by Te-impregnation of MoO3thin films in Te-poor atmosphere[45]。 It should be noted that this defect-induced phase transformation will greatly reduce the relevant properties of 1T'-MoTe2and is not conducive to the practical application of 1T'-MoTe2.Therefore,researchers often use the sleeve method or put Te powder in a small neck container to ensure the stable supply of Te source and avoid the phase transformation caused by the lack of Te[43,44,53][41]。 When the concentration of Te source is sufficient,the gaseous partial pressure of Te is proportional to the rate of Te formation.The higher Te-doping rate will make the strain in the lattice unable to release in time,which is more conducive to the growth of 1T'-MoTe2.Xu et al.Used a two-zone furnace to prepare 1T'-MoTe2,and adjusted the partial pressure of Te by adjusting the temperature of Te source,thereby changing the rate of Te addition[43]。 With the increase of Te source temperature,the product changed from 2H-MoTe2to 1T'-MoTe2(Figure 5C),and finally the 1T'-MoTe2single crystal flake was obtained at about 700°C.Chang et al.Used the flow rate of carrier gas to regulate the rate of Te formation,and the faster the flow rate of carrier gas,the faster the rate of Te formation[68]。 High-purity 1T'-MoTe2films can be obtained at 750°C when the N2flow rate reaches 100 sccm 。

2.2.2 Temperature control

at room temperature,2H phase is a thermodynamically stable phase and 1T'phase is a metastable phase.In 2016,Bartels et al.Found through calculation that 1T'is more stable than 2H phase At high temperature[69]。 the results of this study provide theoretical guidance for The subsequent phase control by temperature。
In 2017,Jo et al.Used MoO3and Te powder as precursors to controllably synthesize high-purity 1T'-MoTe2on a variety of substrates by precisely controlling the growth temperature[38]。 The researchers found that when the growth temperature was higher than 710℃,the uniform 1T'-MoTe2sheet could be obtained.With the decrease of the growth temperature,the product began to transform to the 2 H phase,and when it was reduced to 670℃,it was completely transformed into 2H-MoTe2((Fig.5d).Using this research result,Jo et al.Prepared 1T'/2H-MoTe2hetero-identical junctions,and the interface between the two phases was atomically sharp and seamless.It is found that the contact barrier is only 25 meV,which directly leads to the advantage of coplanar contact FET over the traditional top contact FET in terms of current and gate tunability.Yan et al.Also controllably synthesized 1T'-MoTe2sheets and films by precisely controlling the growth temperature[39]。 In addition,they calculated the Gibbs free energy of each component in the reaction mixture at different temperatures to deduce the thermodynamic equilibrium product of the final state of the reaction.This study is helpful to deeply understand the growth mechanism of 1T'-MoTe2from the perspective of thermodynamics 。
Cooling temperature and speed are also the key factors affecting the phase state of the product.In the process of slow cooling,the energy of 2H phase is gradually lower than that of 1T'phase,which makes the 1T'-MoTe2grown at high temperature relax and gradually transform into 2H phase,and finally the stable 1T'-MoTe2can not be obtained at room temperature[69]。 To solve this problem,Bartels et al.Prepared a 1–1.5 nm thick Mo film on a Si/SiO2substrate by magnetron sputtering,and then Te-treated the Mo film at 620°C,and the Mo film was completely tellurized after 5 min.At this time,due to the short Te-treatment time and the lack of Te source,the product was a 1T'-MoTe2film(Figure 5G )[69]。 After that,with the extension of the Te annealing time,the Te source was continuously supplied,and the MoTe2began to transform from the 1 T′phase to the 2 H phase(Fig.5 H),and it was completely transformed into the 2H-MoTe2film after 180 min of Te annealing.On this basis,a dense 30-nm-thick Atomic layer deposition layer was deposited on the wafer surface by Y(Atomic layer deposition,ALD),and a small hole was introduced in the seed region by a tungsten probe as the only channel for the supply of Te atoms,so as to avoid the spontaneous nucleation of randomly oriented 2H-MoTe2and make the phase transition extend outward from the seed region,which is essential for the growth of wafer-scale single-crystal thin films 。
In a word,in order to prepare high-quality 1T'-MTe2,researchers have successively used elemental substances(Mo,W),oxides(MoOX,WO3),ammonium salts[((NH4)6Mo7O24,(NH4)10W12O41)]as precursors.The growth process and product structure of 1T'-MTe2were studied.In order to further optimize the growth process and improve the product quality,the researchers also developed optimized growth measures such as salt-assisted method,sleeve method,space confinement method and substrate engineering,and obtained large-area,uniform,single-layer and few-layer 1T'-MTe2sheets and films.For the controllable preparation of 1T'-MoTe2,it is necessary to precisely control the phase state of the product by strain and temperature.The phase state of MoTe2is affected by thermodynamics and kinetics.From the thermodynamic point of view,the phase state with the lowest energy under the corresponding conditions can be obtained by adjusting the lattice strain or growth temperature.For example,the lower the gaseous partial pressure of Te and the higher the growth temperature,the more favorable it is to grow 1T'-MoTe2.From the kinetic point of view,the mutual transformation between different phase States needs to cross the energy barrier.The room temperature metastable product can be maintained during cooling to room temperature on the basis of the thermodynamically advantageous 1T'-MoTe2product prepared at high temperature by shortening the relaxation time through a rapid cooling strategy(Fig.5e,f )[43,69]

3 1T'-ReX2(X=S,Se )

The controllable preparation of two-dimensional 1T'-ReX2with high crystal quality,large size and uniform thickness is an important prerequisite for the study of their excellent anisotropic properties and the realization of their large-scale applications[71,72]。 At present,there are the following difficulties in the preparation of 1T'-ReX2by CVD:(1)The melting point of elemental rhenium is too high to volatilize,while the melting point of oxides and ammonium salts is too low to achieve a stable supply of precursors in the growth process;(2)out-of-plane growth is easy to occur in the preparation process of the low-symmetry 1T'-ReX2,and a thick layer product is obtained;(3)Polycrystalline products can be easily obtained by random deflection of Re4 chains.In this section,we divide the preparation of 1T'-ReX2into three parts according to the different kinds of rhenium-containing precursors in CVD preparation:rhenium(Re),rhenium trioxide(ReO3),and ammonium perrhenate(NH4ReO4).The important effects of precursor gas concentration,growth temperature,substrate type and other preparation parameters on the morphology,structure and defect concentration of the product were discussed,and the different structures of the 1T'-ReX2and the corresponding growth mechanism were introduced 。

3.1 Rhenium precursor

As an elemental rhenium-containing precursor,the melting point of metal rhenium(Re)is as high as 3180℃,but Re as a rhenium source has the advantages of simple preparation reaction,less reaction by-products and relatively low cost.The reaction equation for the preparation of 1T'-ReX2is as follows:
Re + 2S → ReS 2
In 2015,Liu et al.First selected Re and S powder as precursors,and after growth at 750℃for 10 min,a thick layer of hexagonal flaky two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2(was prepared on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate(Fig.6a),and its electrical properties were equivalent to the 1T'-ReS2of mechanical exfoliation[73]。 Interestingly,it was found that the morphology of the product could be controlled by adjusting the growth time,that is,the morphology of the 1T'-ReS2gradually changed from flake to nanobelt with the increase of growth time 。
图6 (a) 生长时间为10 min时二维1T'-ReS2产物的典型OM图像[73]; (b) 1T'-ReS2薄膜的光学显微镜图像[74]; (c) CVD制备二维1T'-ReS2的装置示意图[75]; (d) Te辅助CVD生长方法的装置示意图[76]; (e) 转移至SiO2/Si基底表面的单层1T'-ReS2光镜图像[76]; (f) 厚度为1 nm的单层1T'-ReS2的光学显微图像[77]; (g,h) 在SiO2/Si基底表面生长的1T'-ReS2、1T'-ReSe2的光学图像; (i) 对应图(h)中虚线框的放大图[78]; (j) VRe-1T'-ReS2的STEM图像,插图为对应的FFT图像[79]

Fig. 6 (a) Typical OM images of 2D 1T'-ReS2 at a growth period of 10 min[73], Copyright 2015, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (b) Optical microscopy images of 1T'-ReS2 films[74], Copyright 2020, IOP Publishing. (c) Schematic of growth approach of 2D 1T'-ReS2 by CVD[75], Copyright 2017, RSC Publishing. (d) Schematic of apparatus for the growth of 2D 1T'-ReS2 by Te-assisted CVD[76]. (e) Optical images of monolayer 1T'-ReS2 transferred to SiO2/Si[76], Copyright 2016, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (f) Optical microscopic image of monolayer 1T'-ReS2 with thickness of 1 nm[77], Copyright 2019, AIP Publishing. (g, h) Optical images of 1T'-ReS2 and 1T'-ReSe2 grown on the surface of SiO2/Si substrate. (i) Enlargement of the dashed box in figure (h)[78], Copyright 2020, RSC Publishing. (j) STEM image of VRe-1T'-ReS2 with inset corresponding FFT image[79], Copyright 2018, American Chemistry Society

However,the metal Re with high melting point is difficult to volatilize and has low gaseous concentration in the growth system,which leads to sparse 1T'-ReS2products on the substrate surface and low growth efficiency.To solve this problem,researchers have improved the preparation process of 1T'-ReS2by introducing nucleation sites and increasing the concentration of rhenium-containing precursors in the system.Lee et al.Grown two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2on a SiO2/Si substrate coated with perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic acid tetrapotassium salt(PTAS )[74]。 Among them,PTAS can enhance the force between the material and the substrate,and act as a nucleation site in the growth system with low rhenium source concentration to promote nucleation,and then a multilayer polycrystalline thin film product with a thickness of 3.28 nm is obtained after reduction by S powder(Fig.6B).The prepared 1T'-ReS2has a rise time of 0.03 s and a decay time of 0.025 s,which further promotes the application of 1T'-ReS2in optoelectronic devices.As shown in Figure 6C,Zhen et al.Chose Re2O7with a melting point of 220°C as the"catalyst",and at the initial growth stage,Re2O7would be rapidly volatilized into the gas phase,reduced to Re2O7−xby sulfur vapor,and then adsorbed on the mica substrate surface as an active nucleation site[75]。 With the increase of growth temperature,the volatilized Re powder provides a stable source for the growth of 1T'-ReS2,and a single layer of 1T'-ReS2film with a thickness of 0.8 nm can be obtained after 10 min of growth,and a thick layer can be obtained by further prolonging the growth time 。
In addition to introducing nucleation sites in advance to improve the preparation quality,Xu et al.Realized large-scale and high-quality two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2preparation on the surface of fluorophlogopite substrate by tellurium(Te)-assisted CVD method(Fig.6d )[76]。 The Te powder introduced in the system can form Re-Te binary eutectic with Re powder,which greatly reduces the melting point of the precursor and increases the vapor pressure of Re in the system.It can be seen from Fig.6e that this method can prepare monolayer 1T'-ReS2with large area and uniform thickness,and in the S-rich atmosphere,the weakly oxidizing Te vapor will leave the reaction system with the carrier gas without destroying the crystal structure,and the characteristic peak of Te is not observed in the Raman spectrum.On the basis of Te-assisted CVD,Li et al.Uniformly grew 1T'-ReS2films with continuous atomic thickness on the surface of mica substrate through a growth device with limited substrate space(Fig.6f )[77]
Another way to reduce the melting point of the precursor is to mix the salt with Re to form a low melting point intermediate to accelerate the reaction rate.Liu et al.Mixed KI salt with Re powder to reduce the melting point of the reactants,so that the precursor concentration was higher at the same growth temperature.After S/Se reduction for 5~10 min,monolayer 1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2products could be obtained,in which H2should be introduced to grow 1T'-ReSe2[14]。 Zhou et al.Prepared monolayer 1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2on the surface of SiO2/Si substrate by KI salt-assisted CVD method,as shown in Fig.6G~I,the angles between the edges of 1T'-ReX2grains are 60°and 120°,indicating that the crystals preferentially grow along the a and B axes[78]。 The contrast in the STEM image is proportional to the atomic number,so only Re and Se atoms can be observed in the STEM image of the 1T'-ReX2.Because of the similarity of their atomic structures,1T'-ReSe2can be chosen as the object of study.It was found that the monolayer 1T'-ReSe2has three edge-ordered structures:Se atoms are completely retained,50%retained,or all lost.Interestingly,the edge oriented along the a axis with the Se atoms fully preserved exhibits ferromagnetism,while the edge parallel to the B axis exhibits an intermediate state with no significant spin polarization.Liu et al.Also obtained a monolayer 1T'-ReS2film containing Re vacancy by KI-assisted CVD method,and the dotted circle in Fig.6j indicates the Re atom vacancy,that is,there is a Re vacancy(VRe )[79]。 The authors obtained products with different concentrations of VReby controlling the volume ratio of H2/Ar during the growth process,and the presence of vacancies in the products changed the electronic structure of 1T'-ReS2,making the free energy of hydrogen adsorption(ΔGH*)close to 0,showing excellent hydrogen evolution activity 。

3.2 Rhenium trioxide precursor

Rhenium trioxide(ReO3)is a stable oxide of rhenium with a melting point of 400°C.Compared with Re metal with high melting point and NH4ReO4which is easy to produce impurity gas,it is more widely used in chemical vapor deposition preparation of 1T'-ReX2,and the chemical reaction equation is shown in(4 )。
2ReO3+ 7S → 2ReS 2+ 3SO2
In this summary,we further classify the preparation methods according to the substrate species on the basis of the ReO3.The reasons are as follows:First,one of the most critical problems in the preparation of two-dimensional 1T'-ReX2is how to obtain single crystal products.At present,most of the 1T'-ReX2prepared by CVD are polycrystalline due to the weak coupling between layers,while the two-dimensional products of low-symmetry 1T'-MTe2(M=Mo,W)are easy to obtain monocrystalline products.The preparation of single crystals of low-symmetry two-dimensional materials is the key to their macroscopic anisotropy of physical and chemical properties such as optics,electronics and mechanics.Substrate engineering is the most important strategy to improve the monocrystallinity of products,that is,to improve the interfacial interaction between two-dimensional 1T'-ReX2and substrate and optimize the epitaxial orientation effect of substrate on surface 1T'-ReX2by regulating the material,monocrystallinity and surface microstructure of substrate.Therefore,we take the substrate as the key variable in the preparation of 1T'-ReX2.In addition,the reason why the effect of substrate is only discussed under the subcategory of ReO3as precursor,but not extended to elemental rhenium and ammonium perrhenate precursors,is that there are few literatures on the preparation of 1T'-ReX2with the latter two precursors,and it is difficult to carry out a systematic discussion on substrate engineering because SiO2/Si substrates are basically used 。

3.2.1 Insulating substrate

The acting force between an insulating substrate such as SiO2/Si,sapphire,mica and the like and a surface material is relatively weak,the prepared product is easy to transfer,and the price of the substrate is relatively low,so that the insulating substrate has significant advantages in device manufacturing,and is widely applied to large-area preparation of two-dimensional materials.In recent years,in addition to controlling the morphology of the product by changing the basic growth parameters,such as temperature and substrate type,researchers have chosen to improve the experimental device and introduce salt auxiliaries to improve the surface material quality and structural inhomogeneity of the insulating substrate 。
Zhai et al.Selected ReO3as the rhenium-containing precursor to synthesize a uniform double-layer polycrystalline 1T'-ReS2film on the surface of a c-plane sapphire substrate(Fig.7 a),and a large-area thick-layer 1T'-ReS2product with a hexagonal grain shape could be obtained on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate under the same growth conditions[80]。 Meanwhile,as shown in Fig.7 B,Zhai et al.Synthesized a hexagonal thick layer 1T'-ReSe2product on the surface of the SiO2/Si substrate after the reduction of ReO3by Se powder,with a lateral size of about 5μm[81]。 Lee et al.Used the same growth method to prepare triangular and rhombic 1T'-ReSe2grains with thickness varying from 1.5 nm to 30 nm on the surface of SiO2/Si substrate[82]。 Xiu et al.Synthesized a thick-layer 1T'-ReSe2single crystal product on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate by an inversion method,which showed excellent electrical properties at room temperature,with an on/off ratio exceeding that of a 107[83]。 Wang et al.Obtained monolayer 1T'-ReS2with different morphologies on the surface of sapphire substrate by adjusting the growth temperature.With the increase of growth temperature,the products gradually changed from circular(700℃)to triangular(800℃),and the growth mechanism was revealed by diffusion-limited mechanism[84]。 Wang et al.Found that the thickness of 1T'-ReS2also has a great dependence on the growth temperature,and they compared the HER performance of 1T'-ReS2with different thicknesses,revealing various stacking structures in 1T'-ReS2from the atomic level 。
图7 (a) 蓝宝石基底表面生长双层1T'-ReS2薄膜的光学显微图像[80]; (b) SiO2/Si基底表面生长的1T'-ReSe2薄片的光学显微图像[81]; (c) 空间限域法在云母基底表面制备1T'-ReS2的装置示意图[85]; (d) 生长在SiO2/Si基底表面的向日葵形状1T'-ReSe2的光学显微图像[87]; (e) 生长在SiO2/Si基底表面的截断三角形状1T'-ReSe2 的光学显微图像[87]; (f) 通过钠盐辅助CVD法在蓝宝石基底表面合成单层1T'-ReSe2产物[88]; (g) 多晶晶界处的高分辨ADF-STEM图像[25]; (h) 两个平行晶粒间沿b轴方向延伸形成重叠晶界ADF-STEM图像[90]; (i) 裂纹行进的ADF-STEM图像[91]

Fig. 7 (a) Optical micrographs of bilayer 1T'-ReS2 films grown on sapphire[80], Copyright 2016, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (b) OM image of 1T'-ReSe2 flakes grown on SiO2/Si[81], Copyright 2016, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (c) Schematic diagram of the device for the Growth of 1T'-ReS2 on mica by the space-limited method[85], Copyright 2016, RSC Publishing. (d) Sunflower-shaped 1T'-ReSe2 grown on SiO2/Si substrates[87]. (e) Optical microscopy of truncated triangular-shaped 1T'-ReSe2 grown on SiO2/Si[87], Copyright 2018, Springer Nature. (f) Synthesis of monolayer 1T'-ReSe2 products on the surface of sapphire by sodium salt-assisted CVD[88], Copyright 2020, Springer Nature. (g) High-resolution ADF- STEM images at polycrystalline grain boundaries[25], Copyright 2019, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (h) ADF-STEM images of overlapping GB formed by two parallel grains extending along the b-axis[90], Copyright 2020, Elsevier; (i) ADF-STEM images of crack marching[91], Copyright 2021, John Wiley & Sons, Inc

In order to further improve the controllability of the crystal quality,domain size and morphology of the product,Xu et al.Ingeniously stacked two identical mica substrates together to form a narrow space,and limited the precursor concentration in the reaction process by space confinement(Fig.7C).Ffectively reduces the nucleation density and the growth rate of the 1T'-ReX2,can realize large-area epitaxial growth,obtains a single-layer 1T'-ReX2product,and has excellent anisotropic physical and chemical properties[85,86]。 In addition,the vapor pressure of the rhenium source can be controlled by adjusting the valence state of the rhenium source during the growth process by introducing an appropriate amount of H2into the 1T'-ReSe2preparation process[86]。 Zhang et al.Achieved the regulation of the vapor pressure of the rhenium-containing precursor in the CVD system by changing the position of the ReO3precursor[87]。 When the ReO3is located upstream,the precursor is transported to the reaction zone along the carrier gas,at which time the rhenium source concentration is high,and a sunflower-shaped product is obtained at a reaction temperature of 650℃(Fig.7d);However,when the ReO3is located downstream of the reaction zone,the vapor pressure of the rhenium source in the system is small,and the compact truncated triangular products are easy to grow on the surface of the SiO2/Si substrate(Fig.7e).The sunflower-shaped product has more marginal active sites,lower Tafel slope(~76 mV/dec),and higher exchange current density(10.5μA/cm2) 。
In the above study,the CVD growth apparatus was improved and the concentration of rhenium-containing precursor in the preparation process was controlled to achieve the preparation of 1T'-ReX2with controllable morphology.As shown in Fig.7 f,Zhang et al.Selected the method of sodium salt assisted CVD growth to obtain hexagonal(650°C),triangular(700°C)and zigzag(750℃)1T'-ReSe2sheets on the surface of sapphire substrate by controlling the growth temperature,with the domain size of∼106,∼86 and∼97μm,respectively,and the 1T'-ReSe2film can be obtained by extending the growth time(from 10 min to 20 min )[88]。 Among them,the introduction of NaCl can form volatile intermediate products,inhibit nucleation and reduce the nucleation density.Wang et al.Spin-coated an aqueous solution of an alkali metal salt on the surface of a SiO2/Si substrate and then performed 1T'-ReS2growth,so that the original acidic substrate was modified to be alkaline,and the matching between the alkaline substrate and the acidic ReO3was realized,thereby increasing the amount of precursor adsorbed on the substrate surface and promoting the lateral growth of the product to obtain a monolayer product with a larger size[89]。 the results of STEM characterization show that The product prepared by this method has rich grain boundary structure and is polycrystalline。
Interestingly,1T'-ReX2with low symmetry atomic structure are more likely to produce macroscopic products with high symmetry shapes,such as hexagons,triangles and so on.Xu et al.Studied the structure of polycrystalline 1T'-ReS2at atomic scale and proposed a nano-assembly growth model[25]。 The in-plane orientation angle between the daughter domains of the polycrystal is 60°,and the angle in the vertical direction is 0°and 180°.During the growth process,the Re4 chain is randomly deflected to form seven grain boundaries with different structures(Fig.7G),and finally the polycrystal product with high macroscopic shape symmetry is formed.Among them,GB with different structures have different effects on the electrical transport properties.By controlling the preparation temperature of 1T'-ReS2,the grain boundary structure and density are controlled from the thermodynamic point of view,and the coherent twin superlattice structure with carrier mobility of 3.4 cm2V-1·s-1and switching ratio of 106is constructed.The grain boundary structure can affect the physical and chemical properties of materials,such as electrical and optical properties,but it is difficult to achieve rapid retrieval of grain boundary and high-resolution imaging of structure at the same time in the atomic-level study of GB.Wang et al.Used the high chemical activity of GB to selectively adsorb platinum(Pt)nanoparticles,selected ReO3and S powder as precursors,and prepared high-quality monolayer 1T'-ReS2on the surface of mica substrate[90]。 As shown in Fig.7h,overlapping grain boundaries formed between grains parallel to each other in 1T'-ReS2due to the presence of horizontal displacement were observed.Then,Wang et al.Used electron beam irradiation in STEM to study the fracture mechanics properties at the grain boundary of monolayer 1T'-ReS2.When the orientation of Re chain is parallel to the grain boundary direction,the grain boundary is fragile and easy to break[91]。 On the contrary,the strength of GB increases,and the crack can be blocked.Therefore,as shown in fig.7i,in the complex polycrystalline region with different structures,the direction of crack propagation can be observed to change continuously。

3.2.2 Metal substrate

At present,most of the 1T'-ReX2prepared by CVD are polycrystalline products.The diversity of grain boundary structure makes it difficult to control the mechanical,electrical and optical properties of the products,and the existence of different oriented daughter domains reduces the anisotropy of the properties of 1T'-ReX2,so the controllable preparation of single crystal products is an important link to realize the large-scale device application of 1T'-ReX2.In 2018,Zhang et al.Chose Au substrate,ReO3and Se powder,which have strong coupling effect with 1T'-ReSe2,as precursors to synthesize products(Fig.8A )[92]。 The Au foil substrate has a catalytic effect in the CVD preparation process,which catalyzes the decomposition of S and Se polymers in the system into a single active chalcogen atom,and the Re atom has a low solubility on the surface of the Au foil substrate,so that the uniform growth of a monolayer 1T'-ReX2can be realized[26][93][94]。 Trapezoidal and banded Selected area electron diffraction sheets can be obtained after 15–30 min of growth,and completely coincident diffraction spots can be obtained by randomly selecting four different areas for Selected area electron diffraction(SAED),which proves that the product is a single crystal.The intensity of Raman active vibration mode changes with the rotation angle of the sample and the change period is 180°,which shows the polarization dependence of Raman,and further verifies that the synthesized 1T'-ReSe2product is a single crystal.As shown in Fig.8B,Zhang et al.prepared a strip-shaped single crystal Scanning tunneling microscope on an Au substrate by the same growth method,and identified four different Se atoms(Fig.8C)and defect structures such as grain boundaries(Fig.8d,e)in the unit cell of the anisotropic monolayer Scanning tunneling microscope with the help of in-situ Scanning tunneling microscope(STM)and Scan tunnel spectroscopy(STS )[95,96]
图8 (a) 在Au箔基底的表面生长1T'-ReSe2的示意图[92]; (b) 金箔基底表面生长平1T'-ReSe2薄片的SEM图像[95]; (c) Vsample 值为20 mV时单晶1T'-ReSe2的STM图像[95]; (d) 两个相邻1T'-ReSe2晶畴之间的平行位错组成的晶界图像[96]; (e) 孪晶界的STM图像[96]; (f~h) 在Au(111)、Au(001)及Au(101)晶面表面生长的单层1T'-ReS2的SEM图像[97]; (i) 在柔性玻璃表面生长的从2层到8层的1T'-ReS2薄膜图像[98]

Fig. 8 (a) Schematic diagram of growth of 1T'-ReSe2 on Au foil substrates[92], Copyright 2018, IOP Publishing. (b) SEM image of 1T'-ReSe2 sheet on a gold foil substrate[95]. (c) STM image of single-crystal 1T'-ReSe2 at a Vsample value of 20 mV[95], Copyright 2018, American Chemistry Society. (d) Two adjacent ReSe2 domains between GB images consisting of parallel dislocations[96]. (e) STM images of twinned GB[96], Copyright 2018, Springer Nature. (f-h) SEM images of 1T'-ReS2 grown on Au(111), Au(001) and Au(101) crystalline surfaces[97], Copyright 2021, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (i) Optical images of 1T'-ReS2 films grown on a flexible glass surface from 2 to 8 layers[98], Copyright 2017, IOP Publishing

In addition to suppressing the deflection of Re4 chains due to the strong coupling interaction between Au substrate and 1T'-ReX2,it is found that the atomic arrangement of different crystal planes of Au substrate has an important influence on the growth of materials.Xu et al.Annealed the gold foil to obtain Au substrates with different low-index crystal faces,and then selected ReO3and S powder for CVD growth,and grew crystal domains with regular shapes on the surface of the Au(111)substrate with six-fold symmetry(Fig.8f),and the grain boundaries induced by Re4 chain reconstruction could be clearly observed[97]。 The orientation control of 1T'-ReS2preparation was realized on the surface of the four-fold symmetric Au(001)substrate and the two-fold symmetric Au(101)substrate,and single crystal grains with two orientations and a single orientation were obtained,respectively(Fig.8g,H),and the orientation distribution decreased with the decrease of substrate symmetry 。

3.2.3 Other kinds of substrates

In order to better meet the actual application scenarios of 1T'-ReX2,Lee et al.Directly prepared two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2on the surface of flexible glass substrate by reducing ReO3with H2S.By controlling the concentration of H2S gas flow,films from 2 to 8 layers could be obtained(Figure 8 I).Randomly selecting multiple places for testing,multiple results were obtained with the same position and intensity,which proved that the obtained films were uniform everywhere[98]。 The growth of 1T'-ReS2directly on the surface of a flexible exfoliated substrate not only avoids damage or pollution in the transfer process,but also lays a foundation for its application in transparent electronic and flexible optoelectronic devices.Liu et al.Selected ReO3and S powder as precursors to synthesize ultra-high density 1T'-ReSe2sheets on the surface of porous carbon cloth(PCC),with a thickness of about 2.5–4 nm[99]。 X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy(ray photo electron spectroscopy,XPS)characterization showed that the characteristic peak of C-Se bond appeared at 286.4 eV,and the interfacial interaction between the product and the substrate promoted the electron transport between the material and the electrode,which enhanced the HER performance(overpotential of 140 mV,Tafel slope of 64 mV/dec)。

3.3 Ammonium perrhenate precursor

Ammonium perrhenate m.P.Is a common rhenium-containing precursor for the preparation of 1T'-ReX2,which has a low melting point(M.P.=365℃)and is volatile,so a high gaseous concentration of precursor can be obtained at a low reaction temperature.In 2015,Ajayan et al.Selected NH4ReO4as the rhenium source,and two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2materials with sizes ranging from 2 to 60μm were obtained for the first time on the surface of amorphous SiO2/Si substrate under Ar atmosphere(Figure 9 a),and the reaction process is shown in Equation(5 )[100]
4NH4ReO4+ 15S→4ReS2+ 7SO2 + 4NH3+2H2O
图9 (a, b) 二维1T'-ReS2的SEM图像及原子序数衬度像[100]; (c,d) (截断)三角形及六边形1T'-ReS2晶畴的光学显微图像[101]; (e) 单层1T'-ReSe2的光学显微图像,比例尺为10 μm; (f) 对应图(e)中1T'-ReSe2的TEM高角环形暗场( HAADF )图像,比例尺为10 μm[102]; (g) 转移至SiO2/Si基底表面单层1T'-ReS2晶粒的OM图像,比例尺为5 μm[103]; (h) 六边形单层1T'-ReS2晶畴的光学图像;(i)六边形晶畴动力学生长过程示意图[104]; (j) 1T'-ReS2片的生长过程示意图[105]

Fig. 9 (a, b) SEM images and Z-contrast STEM images of two-dimensional 1T'-ReS2[100], Copyright 2015, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (c, d) Optical microscopy images of (truncated) triangular and hexagonal 1T'-ReS2 crystal domains[101], Copyright 2016, American Chemistry Society. (e) Optical microscopy images of monolayer 1T'-ReSe2, scale bar is 10 μm. (f) High-angle annular dark field ( HAADF) TEM image of 1T'-ReSe2 corresponding to Figure (e), scale bar is 10 μm[102], Copyright 2021, American Chemistry Society. (g) OM image of a monolayer of 1T'-ReS2 grains transferred to SiO2/Si at a scale of 5 μm[103], Copyright 2020, American Association for the Advancement of Science. (h) Optical image of a hexagonal monolayer of 1T'-ReS2 crystal domains. (i) Schematic kinetic growth process of hexagonal crystal domains[104], Copyright 2020, American Chemistry Society. (j) Schematic of the growth process of 1T'-ReS2 sheets[105], Copyright 2018, John Wiley & Sons, Inc

Then,by increasing the growth temperature,the researchers realized the transformation of the product shape from hexagonal(400~450℃)to circular(450~500℃).It is worth noting that the 1T'-ReS2products with different shapes are rough dendritic edges due to the asymmetric growth of low-symmetry 1T'-ReS2.The Re4 chain in the product structure can be clearly observed in Fig.9b,which proves that the product is a 1T'-ReS2.There are many vacancy defects in the STEM image,which may be attributed to the destruction of the product structure by the gaseous by-products such as SO2and NH3produced in the process.Tongay et al.Used NH4ReO4as a precursor to study the effect of multiple preparation parameters on the product quality[101]。 Different shapes of 1T'-ReS2domains were obtained on crystalline c-plane sapphire substrate by changing the growth parameters such as growth temperature,carrier gas flow rate and precursor concentration.As shown in fig.9c,the(truncated)triangular product is easily obtained at higher growth temperature,while the mass transfer process changes with the decrease of growth temperature,precursor concentration and carrier gas flow rate,resulting in hexagonal domains(fig.9d).Similarly,the products were characterized by STEM,and it was found that the 1T'-ReS2products had defects such as vacancies.In order to further reveal the growth process of 1T'-ReX2,Ly et al.Studied the preparation process of two-dimensional 1T'-ReSe2chemical vapor deposition by STEM,and obtained Re6Se8clusters by reducing NH4ReO4with selenium powder(Se)and Ar/H2at 700℃[102]。 The Re6Se8is attached to the edge of the crystal nucleus and then further reduced,and a 1T'-ReSe2(with a thickness of one to two atomic layers is obtained on the surface of the c-plane sapphire substrate.Fig.9 e).From the TEM image in Fig.9 f,it can be seen that the prepared two-dimensional 1T'-ReSe2is polycrystalline,in which the white arrows indicate the Re chain directions of different grains.Zhao et al.Selected NH4ReO4and S powder as precursors to synthesize monolayer 1T'-ReS2(on the surface of c-plane sapphire substrate Fig.9 G),and this work then studied the atomic reconstruction process of the fracture process through STEM,analyzed three fracture modes corresponding to tensile stress,in-plane shear and out-of-plane shear,and further understood the fracture mechanism of low-symmetry two-dimensional materials[103]
The crystal structure of 1T'-ReX2has low symmetry,complex growth behavior and mechanism,and the preparation process is easy to form defects,which reduces the anisotropic physical and chemical properties,so it is urgent to further understand and regulate the growth process to improve the crystal quality of the product.Through angle-resolved Raman characterization,Kang et al.Found that the hexagonal 1T'-ReS2domain prepared with NH4ReO4as the rhenium source was composed of six sub-grains(Fig.9 H )[104]。 Transmission electron microscope(TEM)and Density Functional Theory(DFT)were used to study the domain growth kinetics of Transmission electron microscope.The results show that at the initial stage of Transmission electron microscope growth,single crystal nuclei grow along two B axes and four a axes,and the bond energy of a axis is smaller than that of B axis.With the continuous growth process,dislocations are introduced into the crystal domain,which makes the original four directions along the a axis grow along the B axis,thus forming six different lattice directions.The(010)plane,which corresponds to the larger interfacial energy in each grain,grows faster than the(110)plane,so the diagonal direction of the hexagonal domain corresponds to the b-axis direction(fig.9i).In order to reduce the defect concentration and optimize the size of single crystal products,the growth rate difference between(010)and(110)crystal planes was reduced by increasing the growth temperature,which delayed the elimination of(010)crystal plane and effectively increased the domain size.In addition,the effect of spatial confinement can be achieved by placing multiple substrates stacked together downstream of the NH4ReO4precursor,and the adjustment of nucleation density and coverage can be achieved by optimizing the speed of carrier gas and changing the amount of S powder,so as to obtain millimeter-sized 1T'-ReS2products.The FET array fabricated from the 1T'-ReS2prepared by the above method has excellent electrical properties,with electron mobility up to 1.2 cm2·V-1·s-1and current on-off ratio of 105at room temperature 。
In addition to improving the product quality by directly regulating the preparation parameters in the growth process,as shown in fig.9j,Wang et al.Provided the design of forward NH4ReO4precursor and reverse S vapor.Triangular as well as quadrilateral thick layer single crystals of 1T'-ReS2were synthesized on the surface of SiO2/Si substrate,and the prepared 1T'-ReS2field effect transistor has a mobility of 8.16 cm2·V-1·s-1and an on-off ratio up to 105[105]
In summary,the above work is based on the CVD growth process and defect structure of two-dimensional 1T'-ReX2with three different rhenium-containing precursors of NH4ReO4,Re and ReO3.At present,1T'-ReX2products with different defect concentrations have been synthesized by precise control of rhenium source concentration and substrate engineering,among which the growth of single crystals on Au substrate surface with strong coupling effect with 1T'-ReX2provides an important opportunity to explore its excellent anisotropic physical and chemical properties.In order to further promote its application,the CVD preparation methods of 1T'-ReX2still need to be optimized and developed to achieve high-quality,low-cost and large-scale controllable preparation of two-dimensional single crystals 。

4 Summary and Prospect

Low symmetry two-dimensional TMDs not only have the characteristics of ultra-thin,transparent and flexible,but also have unique anisotropic physical and chemical properties due to their low lattice symmetry,so they have broad application prospects in micro-nano photonics,tactile sensors,anisotropic electronic devices and other fields.However,the basic research and practical application of these materials depend on the preparation of high-quality,large-size and stable,and chemical vapor deposition is currently considered to be the most promising method to achieve high-quality,large-scale and controllable preparation of two-dimensional materials.Therefore,we take four typical low-symmetry two-dimensional TMDs,1T'-MoTe2,1T'-WTe2,1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2,as examples,and classify them according to the types of precursors.According to the melting point of the precursors from high to low,the existing CVD preparation methods of these four materials are reviewed in detail.At the same time,two key problems in the CVD preparation of these four materials are summarized in detail:(1)Considering that 1T'-MoTe2is metastable at room temperature,the phase control mechanism of 1T'-MoTe2is discussed in depth in order to control the preparation of 1T'-MoTe2;(2)CVD products are usually polycrystalline due to the weak interlayer coupling of 1T'-ReX2,and substrate engineering is regarded as an important strategy to improve the monocrystalline properties of two-dimensional materials.Therefore,we further discuss the CVD preparation methods of 1T'-ReX2according to the substrate types 。
Although significant progress has been made in the study of 1T'-MX2,a number of challenges remain.For example,in the CVD process of 1T'-MX2,small changes in growth temperature,precursor concentration,and the amount of auxiliary agent will affect the morphology and quality of the product,resulting in poor repeatability of the experiment.It is a high-dimensional analytical problem to deeply understand the regulation mechanism of each factor and analyze the optimal growth parameters under the coupling of multiple factors,which is a great challenge for human beings.At present,machine learning has shown significant advantages in solving such high-dimensional problems.It can not only analyze the influence of different experimental parameters on the morphology of products,but also recommend the optimal experimental scheme according to the existing data.On the basis of machine learning,improving the automation of the experimental device can further accelerate the iteration speed of the optimization process,which has epoch-making significance for improving the product quality of 1T'-MX2and the repeatability of the growth process.In the preparation process of 1T'-ReX2,the orientation of Re quadrilateral chain is easy to change,so most of the current studies can only obtain polycrystalline products.Although single crystal 1T'-ReX2can be prepared by using Au with specific crystal plane as a substrate,the cost of Au substrate is too expensive,and the interface between Au and 1T'-ReX2is too strong,which is not conducive to the transfer of materials in subsequent applications.Therefore,reducing the preparation cost on the premise of ensuring the product quality is a prerequisite for the application of 1T'-ReX2in the field of anisotropic devices.At present,substrate engineering is considered to be an important strategy to improve the monocrystallinity of two-dimensional materials products.By searching for non-noble metal substrates and designing the microstructure of the substrate surface to control the epitaxial growth process of materials,it is expected to achieve controllable and efficient preparation of monocrystalline 1T'-ReX2at a lower cost.In a word,there are still many unknowns in the research of low-symmetry two-dimensional TMDs materials,but as the typical representatives of low-symmetry materials,the related research of 1T'-WTe2,1T'-MoTe2,1T'-ReS2and 1T'-ReSe2provides a good platform for the further development of low-symmetry materials 。
[1]
Zhang G Y, Long G, Lin S H, Xian L D, Jiang Y, Wu H, Wang P S L N. Bull. Chinese Acad. Sci., 2022, 37: 368.

[2]
Jiang H J, Zheng L, Liu Z, Wang X W. InfoMat, 2020, 2(6): 1077.

[3]
Kim H, Gilmore C M, Piqué A, Horwitz J S, Mattoussi H, Murata H, Kafafi Z H, Chrisey D B. J. Appl. Phys., 1999, 86(11): 6451.

[4]
Nair R R, Blake P, Grigorenko A N, Novoselov K S, Booth T J, Stauber T, Peres N M R, Geim A K. Science, 2008, 320(5881): 1308.

[5]
Voiry D, Mohite A, Chhowalla M. Chem. Soc. Rev., 2015, 44(9): 2702.

[6]
Das S, Sebastian A, Pop E, McClellan C J, Franklin A D, Grasser T, Knobloch T, Illarionov Y, Penumatcha A V, Appenzeller J, Chen Z H, Zhu W J, Asselberghs I, Li L J, Avci U E, Bhat N, Anthopoulos T D, Singh R. Nat. Electron., 2021, 4(11): 786.

[7]
Xia F N, Wang H, Xiao D, Dubey M, Ramasubramaniam A. Nat. Photonics, 2014, 8(12): 899.

[8]
Li B L, Wang J P, Zou H L, Garaj S, Lim C T, Xie J P, Li N B, Leong D T. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2016, 26(39): 7034.

[9]
Deng D H, Novoselov K S, Fu Q, Zheng N F, Tian Z Q, Bao X H. Nat. Nanotechnol., 2016, 11(3): 218.

[10]
Wang T Y, Chen S Q, Pang H, Xue H G, Yu Y. Adv. Sci., 2017, 4(2): 1600289.

[11]
Zhao W, Pan J, Fang Y Q, Che X L, Wang D, Bu K J, Huang F Q. Chem., 2018, 24(60): 15942.

[12]
Chen Y C, Sun M T. Nanoscale, 2021, 13(11): 5594.

[13]
Li L, Han W, Pi L J, Niu P, Han J B, Wang C L, Su B, Li H Q, Xiong J, Bando Y, Zhai T Y. InfoMat, 2019, 1(1): 54.

[14]
Zhou J D, Lin J H, Huang X W, Zhou Y, Chen Y, Xia J, Wang H, Xie Y, Yu H M, Lei J C, Wu D, Liu F C, Fu Q D, Zeng Q S, Hsu C H, Yang C L, Lu L, Yu T, Shen Z X, Lin H, Yakobson B I, Liu Q, Suenaga K, Liu G T, Liu Z. Nature, 2018, 556(7701): 355.

[15]
Zeng M Q, Xiao Y, Liu J X, Yang K N, Fu L. Chem. Rev., 2018, 118(13): 6236.

[16]
Li X, Chen C, Yang Y, Lei Z, Xu H. Adv. Sci., 2020, 7: 2002320.

[17]
Liu E F, Fu Y J, Wang Y J, Feng Y Q, Liu H M, Wan X G, Zhou W, Wang B G, Shao L B, Ho C H, Huang Y S, Cao Z Y, Wang L G, Li A D, Zeng J W, Song F Q, Wang X R, Shi Y, Yuan H T, Hwang H Y, Cui Y, Miao F, Xing D Y. Nat. Commun., 2015, 6: 6991.

[18]
Chenet D A, Aslan B, Huang P Y, Fan C, van der Zande A M, Heinz T F, Hone J C. Nano Lett., 2015, 15(9): 5667.

[19]
Cui Q N, He J Q, Bellus M Z, Mirzokarimov M, Hofmann T, Chiu H Y, Antonik M, He D W, Wang Y S, Zhao H. Small, 2015, 11(41): 5565.

[20]
An C H, Xu Z H, Shen W F, Zhang R J, Sun Z Y, Tang S J, Xiao Y F, Zhang D H, Sun D, Hu X D, Hu C G, Yang L, Liu J. ACS Nano, 2019, 13(3): 3310.

[21]
Zhang Y, Yao Y Y, Sendeku M G, Yin L, Zhan X Y, Wang F, Wang Z X, He J. Adv. Mater., 2019, 31(41): 1901694.

[22]
Abid N, Khan A M, Shujait S, Chaudhary K, Ikram M, Imran M, Haider J, Khan M, Khan Q, Maqbool M. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci., 2022, 300: 102597.

[23]
Liu L, Li T T, Ma L, Li W S, Gao S, Sun W J, Dong R K, Zou X L, Fan D X, Shao L W, Gu C Y, Dai N X, Yu Z H, Chen X Q, Tu X C, Nie Y F, Wang P, Wang J L, Shi Y, Wang X R. Nature, 2022, 605(7908): 69.

[24]
Chen J Y, Liu B, Liu Y P, Tang W, Nai C T, Li L J, Zheng J, Gao L B, Zheng Y, Shin H S, Jeong H Y, Loh K P. Adv. Mater., 2015, 27(42): 6722.

[25]
Li X, Wang X, Hong J, Liu D, Feng Q, Lei Z, Liu K, Ding F, Xu H. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2019, 29: 1906385.

[26]
Gao Y, Liu Z B, Sun D M, Huang L, Ma L P, Yin L C, Ma T, Zhang Z Y, Ma X L, Peng L M, Cheng H M, Ren W C. Nat. Commun., 2015, 6: 8569.

[27]
Wan X, Chen K, Xie W G, Wen J X, Chen H J, Xu J B. Small, 2016, 12(4): 438.

[28]
Gong Y J, Ye G L, Lei S D, Shi G, He Y M, Lin J H, Zhang X, Vajtai R, Pantelides S T, Zhou W, Li B, Ajayan P M. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2016, 26(12): 2009.

[29]
Zhou J, Liu F, Lin J, Huang X, Xia J, Zhang B, Zeng Q, Wang H, Zhu C, Niu L, Wang X, Fu W, Yu P, Chang T R, Hsu C H, Wu D, Jeng H T, Huang Y, Lin H, Shen Z, Yang C, Lu L, Suenaga K, Zhou W, Pantelides S T, Liu G, Liu Z. Adv. Mater., 2017, 29: 1603471.

[30]
Zhou L, Xu K, Zubair A, Liao A D, Fang W J, Ouyang F, Lee Y H, Ueno K, Saito R, Palacios T, Kong J, Dresselhaus M S. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2015, 137(37): 11892.

[31]
Callanan J E, Hope G A, Weir R D, Westrum E F Jr. J. Chem. Thermodyn., 1992, 24(6): 627.

[32]
Duerloo K A N, Li Y, Reed E J. Nat. Commun., 2014, 5: 4214.

[33]
Zhang H, Wang S, Yu J. Prog. Chem., 2021, 34: 1440.

[34]
Park J C, Yun S J, Kim H, Park J H, Chae S H, An S J, Kim J G, Kim S M, Kim K K, Lee Y H. ACS Nano, 2015, 9(6): 6548.

[35]
Zhou Y, Jang H, Woods J M, Xie Y J, Kumaravadivel P, Pan G A, Liu J B, Liu Y H, Cahill D G, Cha J J. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2017, 27(8): 1605928.

[36]
CRC handbook of chemistry and physics.Eds.: Lide, D. R. CRC press, 2014.

[37]
Zhang Q Q, Xiao Y, Zhang T, Weng Z, Zeng M Q, Yue S L, Mendes R G, Wang L X, Chen S L, Rümmeli M H, Peng L M, Fu L. Chem. Mater., 2017, 29(11): 4641.

[38]
Sung J H, Heo H, Si S, Kim Y H, Noh H R, Song K, Kim J, Lee C S, Seo S Y, Kim D H, Kim H K, Yeom H W, Kim T H, Choi S Y, Kim J S, Jo M H. Nat. Nanotechnol., 2017, 12(11): 1064.

[39]
Limbu T B, Adhikari B, Song S K, Chitara B, Tang Y A, Parsons G N, Yan F. RSC Adv., 2021, 11(61): 38839.

[40]
Wang X J, Shang J, Zhu M J, Zhou X, Hao R, Sun L N, Xu H, Zheng J B, Lei X F, Li C, Kou L Z, Feng Q L. Nanoscale Horiz., 2020, 5(6): 954.

[41]
Adhikari B, Limbu T B, Vinodgopal K, Yan F. Nanotechnology, 2021, 32(33): 335701.

[42]
Zhou G L, Gao H, Li J, He X Y, He Y B, Li Y, Hao G L. Nanotechnology, 2022, 33(17): 175602.

[43]
Xu X S, Li X B, Liu K Q, Li J, Feng Q L, Zhou L, Cui F F, Liang X, Lei Z B, Liu Z H, Xu H. Cryst. Growth Des., 2018, 18(5): 2844.

[44]
Fraser J P, Masaityte L, Zhang J Y, Laing S, Moreno-López J C, McKenzie A F, McGlynn J C, Panchal V, Graham D, Kazakova O, Pichler T, MacLaren D A, Moran D A J, Ganin A Y. Commun. Mater., 2020, 1: 48.

[45]
Zhou L, Zubair A, Wang Z Q, Zhang X, Ouyang F, Xu K, Fang W J, Ueno K, Li J, Palacios T, Kong J, Dresselhaus M S. Adv. Mater., 2016, 28(43): 9526.

[46]
Zhou R, Wu J X, Chen Y S, Xie L M. Chin. J. Chem., 2022, 40(8): 989.

[47]
Roy A, Movva H C P, Satpati B, Kim K, Dey R, Rai A, Pramanik T, Guchhait S, Tutuc E, Banerjee S K. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2016, 8(11): 7396.

[48]
Artyukhov V I, Hao Y F, Ruoff R S, Yakobson B I. Phys. Rev. Lett., 2015, 114(11): 115502.

[49]
Dong J, Zhang L, Ding F. Adv. Mater., 2019, 31: 1801583.

[50]
Shi R, He P G, Cai X B, Zhang Z Q, Wang W J, Wang J W, Feng X M, Wu Z F, Amini A, Wang N, Cheng C. ACS Nano, 2020, 14(6): 7593.

[51]
Kalpakli A O, Arabaci A, Kahruman C, Yusufoglu I. Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater., 2013, 37: 106.

[52]
Kovács T N, Hunyadi D, de Lucena A L A, Szilágyi I M. J. Therm. Anal. Calorim., 2016, 124(2): 1013.

[53]
Chen K, Chen Z F, Wan X, Zheng Z B, Xie F Y, Chen W J, Gui X C, Chen H J, Xie W G, Xu J B. Adv. Mater., 2017, 29(38): 1700704.

[54]
Keum D H, Cho S, Kim J H, Choe D H, Sung H J, Kan M, Kang H, Hwang J Y, Kim S W, Yang H, Chang K J, Lee Y H. Nat. Phys., 2015, 11(6): 482.

[55]
Zheng F P, Cai C Y, Ge S F, Zhang X F, Liu X, Lu H, Zhang Y D, Qiu J, Taniguchi T, Watanabe K, Jia S, Qi J S, Chen J H, Sun D, Feng J. Adv. Mater., 2016, 28(24): 4845.

[56]
Naylor C H, Parkin W M, Ping J L, Gao Z L, Zhou Y R, Kim Y, Streller F, Carpick R W, Rappe A M, Drndić M, Kikkawa J M, Johnson A T C. Nano Lett., 2016, 16(7): 4297.

[57]
Naylor C H, Parkin W M, Gao Z L, Kang H, Noyan M, Wexler R B, Tan L Z, Kim Y, Kehayias C E, Streller F, Zhou Y R, Carpick R, Luo Z T, Park Y W, Rappe A M, Drndić M, Kikkawa J M, Johnson A T C.2D Mater., 2017, 4(2): 021008.

[58]
Wang S S, Rong Y M, Fan Y, Pacios M, Bhaskaran H, He K, Warner J H. Chem. Mater., 2014, 26(22): 6371.

[59]
Han G H, Keum D H, Zhao J, Shin B G, Song S, Bae J J, Lee J, Kim J H, Kim H, Moon B H, Lee Y H.2D Mater., 2016, 3(3): 031010.

[60]
Pace S, Martini L, Convertino D, Keum D H, Forti S, Pezzini S, Fabbri F, Mišeikis V, Coletti C. ACS Nano, 2021, 15(3): 4213.

[61]
Ma L, Zhu J T, Li W, Huang R, Wang X Y, Guo J, Choi J H, Lou Y H, Wang D, Zou G F. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2021, 143(33): 13314.

[62]
Xu X L, Han B, Liu S, Yang S Q, Jia X H, Xu W J, Gao P, Ye Y, Dai L. Adv. Mater., 2020, 32(23): 2000236.

[63]
Yang S Q, Xu X L, Xu W J, Han B, Ding Z P, Gu P F, Gao P, Ye Y. ACS Appl. Nano Mater., 2020, 3(10): 10411.

[64]
Song S, Keum D H, Cho S, Perello D, Kim Y, Lee Y H. Nano Lett., 2016, 16(1): 188.

[65]
Zhang S, Wu Y, Gao F, Shang H, Zhang J, Li Z, Fu Y Q, Hu P A. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32: 2205299.

[66]
Yoo Y, DeGregorio Z P, Su Y, Koester S J, Johns J E. Adv. Mater., 2017, 29(16): 1605461.

[67]
Xu X L, Chen S L, Liu S, Cheng X, Xu W J, Li P, Wan Y, Yang S Q, Gong W T, Yuan K, Gao P, Ye Y, Dai L. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2019, 141(5): 2128.

[68]
Yang L, Zhang W F, Li J, Cheng S, Xie Z J, Chang H X. ACS Nano, 2017, 11(2): 1964.

[69]
Empante T A, Zhou Y, Klee V, Nguyen A E, Lu I H, Valentin M D, Naghibi Alvillar S A, Preciado E, Berges A J, Merida C S, Gomez M, Bobek S, Isarraraz M, Reed E J, Bartels L. ACS Nano, 2017, 11(1): 900.

[70]
Xu X L, Pan Y, Liu S, Han B, Gu P F, Li S H, Xu W J, Peng Y X, Han Z, Chen J, Gao P, Ye Y. Science, 2021, 372(6538): 195.

[71]
Xiong Y, Chen H W, Zhang D W, Zhou P. Phys. Status Solidi RRL, 2019, 13(6): 1800658.

[72]
Liu C, Wang L, Qi J, Liu K. Adv. Mater., 2020, 32: 2000046.

[73]
He X X, Liu F C, Hu P, Fu W, Wang X L, Zeng Q S, Zhao W, Liu Z. Small, 2015, 11(40): 5423.

[74]
Lim J, Jeon D, Lee S, Yu J S, Lee S. Nanotechnology, 2020, 31(11): 115603.

[75]
Qin J K, Shao W Z, Li Y, Xu C Y, Ren D D, Song X G, Zhen L. RSC Adv., 2017, 7(39): 24188.

[76]
Cui F, Wang C, Li X, Wang G, Liu K, Yang Z, Feng Q, Liang X, Zhang Z, Liu S, Lei Z, Liu Z, Xu H, Zhang J. Adv. Mater., 2016, 28: 5019.

[77]
Guo Z L, Wei A X, Zhao Y, Tao L L, Yang Y B, Zheng Z Q, Luo D X, Liu J, Li J B. Appl. Phys. Lett., 2019, 114(15): 153102.

[78]
Chen X Y, Lei B, Zhu Y, Zhou J D, Liu Z, Ji W, Zhou W. Nanoscale, 2020, 12(32): 17005.

[79]
Zhou Y, Song E H, Zhou J D, Lin J H, Ma R G, Wang Y W, Qiu W J, Shen R X, Suenaga K, Liu Q, Wang J C, Liu Z, Liu J J. ACS Nano, 2018, 12(5): 4486.

[80]
Hafeez M, Gan L, Li H Q, Ma Y, Zhai T Y. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2016, 26(25): 4551.

[81]
Hafeez M, Gan L, Li H Q, Ma Y, Zhai T Y. Adv. Mater., 2016, 28(37): 8296.

[82]
Kang B, Kim Y, Cho J H, Lee C G.2D Mater., 2017, 4(2): 025014.

[83]
Zhang E Z, Wang P, Li Z, Wang H F, Song C Y, Huang C, Chen Z G, Yang L, Zhang K T, Lu S H, Wang W Y, Liu S S, Fang H H, Zhou X H, Yan H G, Zou J, Wan X G, Zhou P, Hu W D, Xiu F X. ACS Nano, 2016, 10(8): 8067.

[84]
Hu P, Zhang H, Li A L, Sheng L P, Jiang J J, Yu Y, Huang W Q, Li S H, Huang H, Yu J S, Cheng H F, Mao L Q, Wang S S, Ouyang F P, Zhang J. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2023, 33(13): 2210502.

[85]
Li X B, Cui F F, Feng Q L, Wang G, Xu X S, Wu J X, Mao N N, Liang X, Zhang Z Y, Zhang J, Xu H. Nanoscale, 2016, 8(45): 18956.

[86]
Cui F F, Li X B, Feng Q L, Yin J B, Zhou L, Liu D Y, Liu K Q, He X X, Liang X, Liu S Z, Lei Z B, Liu Z H, Peng H L, Zhang J, Kong J, Xu H. Nano Res., 2017, 10(8): 2732.

[87]
Jiang S, Zhang Z, Zhang N, Huan Y, Gong Y, Sun M, Shi J. Nano Res., 2018, 11: 1787.

[88]
Jiang S L, Yang J, Shi Y P, Zhao J, Xie C Y, Zhao L Y, Fu J T, Yang P F, Huan Y H, Xie Q, Jiang H C, Zhang Q, Wang X L, Su F H, Zhang Y F. Nano Res., 2020, 13(3): 667.

[89]
Li S H, Wang S S, Xu T, Zhang H, Tang Y X, Liu S, Jiang T, Zhou S, Cheng H F. Nanoscale, 2021, 13(30): 13030.

[90]
Wang S S, Yu Y, Zhang S Q, Zhang S S, Xu H, Zou X L, Zhang J. Matter, 2020, 3(6): 2108.

[91]
Zhang H, Yu Y, Dai X, Yu J, Xu H, Wang S, Ding F, Zhang J. Small, 2021, 17: 2102739.

[92]
Jiang S L, Zhao L Y, Shi Y P, Xie C Y, Zhang N, Zhang Z P, Huan Y H, Yang P F, Hong M, Zhou X B, Shi J P, Zhang Q, Zhang Y F. Nanotechnology, 2018, 29(20): 204003.

[93]
Gao Y, Liu Y, Liu Z. iScience, 2021, 24(12): 103432.

[94]
Knook B, Star W M, Van Rongen H J M, Van den Berg G J. Physica, 1964, 30(6): 1124.

[95]
Hong M, Zhou X B, Gao N, Jiang S L, Xie C Y, Zhao L Y, Gao Y, Zhang Z P, Yang P F, Shi Y P, Zhang Q, Liu Z F, Zhao J J, Zhang Y F. ACS Nano, 2018, 12(10): 10095.

[96]
Jiang S L, Hong M, Wei W, Zhao L Y, Zhang N, Zhang Z P, Yang P F, Gao N, Zhou X B, Xie C Y, Shi J P, Huan Y H, Tong L M, Zhao J J, Zhang Q, Fu Q, Zhang Y F. Commun. Chem., 2018, 1: 17.

[97]
Li X B, Dai X Y, Tang D Q, Wang X, Hong J H, Chen C, Yang Y, Lu J B, Zhu J G, Lei Z B, Suenaga K, Ding F, Xu H. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2021, 31(28): 2102138.

[98]
Kim Y, Kang B, Choi Y, Cho J H, Lee C G.2D Mater., 2017, 4(2): 025057.

[99]
Li J, Liu Y W, Liu C, Huang W T, Zhang Y, Wang M J, Hou Z P, Wang X, Jin M L, Zhou G F, Gao X S, Zhang Z, Liu J M. Chem. Commun., 2020, 56(2): 305.

[100]
Keyshar K, Gong Y J, Ye G L, Brunetto G, Zhou W, Cole D P, Hackenberg K, He Y M, Machado L, Kabbani M, Hart A H C, Li B, Galvao D S, George A, Vajtai R, Tiwary C S, Ajayan P M. Adv. Mater., 2015, 27(31): 4640.

[101]
Wu K D, Chen B, Yang S J, Wang G, Kong W, Cai H, Aoki T, Soignard E, Marie X, Yano A, Suslu A, Urbaszek B, Tongay S. Nano Lett., 2016, 16(9): 5888.

[102]
Chen X, Wong L W, Huang L L, Zheng F Y, Huang R, Lau S P, Lee C S, Zhao J, Deng Q M, Ly T H. Chem. Mater., 2021, 33(17): 7039.

[103]
Huang L, Zheng F, Deng Q, Thi Q H, Wong L W, Cai Y, Wang N, Lee C S, Lau S P, Ly T H, Zhao J. Sci. Adv., 2020, 6: 2282.

[104]
He Q M, Zhou J P, Tang W Q, Hao Y F, Sun L T, Zhu C Y, Xu F, Chen J J, Wu Y P, Wu Z M, Xu B B, Liu G H, Li X, Zhang C M, Kang J Y. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(2): 2862.

[105]
Chen P, Wang J Y, Lu Y, Zhang S H, Wang Z D, Wang L. Phys. Status Solidi B, 2018, 255(8): 1800142.

Outlines

/