Home Journals Progress in Chemistry
Progress in Chemistry

Abbreviation (ISO4): Prog Chem      Editor in chief: Jincai ZHAO

About  /  Aim & scope  /  Editorial board  /  Indexed  /  Contact  / 
Review

Research Progress on Self-Healing Polyurethane and Its Applications in the Field of Flexible Sensors

  • Chao Chen 1, 2 ,
  • Guyue Wang 1, 3 ,
  • Ying Tian 1, 2 ,
  • Zhengyang Kong 4 ,
  • Fenglong Li 1, 2 ,
  • Jin Zhu , 1, * ,
  • Wu Bin Ying , 1, 5, *
Expand
  • 1 Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology and Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences,Ningbo 315201, China
  • 2 University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Bejing 100049, China
  • 3 University of Science and Technology Beijing,Beijing 100083, China
  • 4 Hanyang University, Seoul 04763, Korea
  • 5 Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon 34101, Korea
*e-mail: (Wu Bin Ying);
(Jin Zhu)

Received date: 2023-05-30

  Revised date: 2023-07-12

  Online published: 2023-08-07

Supported by

The National Natural Science Foundation of China(52003278)

The National Natural Science Foundation of China(52211540393)

Abstract

Polyurethane, a prevalent polymer, has garnered considerable attention owing to its exceptional overall performance within various applications. However, even minor damages can significantly curtail the service life of polyurethane. Consequently, a promising approach to address this challenge involves conferring self-healing properties upon polyurethane. Among the various healing mechanisms found in self-healing polyurethane, the intrinsic driving force stands out as the most common. This mechanism entails the spontaneous re-entanglement of polyurethane molecular chains through meticulous molecular structure design, obviating the necessity for external healing agents. Intrinsic driving force encompasses reversible covalent bonds (e.g., disulfide bonds, Diels-Alder reactions, and boronic ester bonds) as well as dynamic non-covalent interactions (e.g., hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, metal coordination bonds, and host-guest interactions). The polyurethane main chain can possess a single intrinsic driving force or multiple intrinsic driving forces concurrently. Nevertheless, while self-healing polyurethane alone presents advantages in terms of extending service life and reducing maintenance costs through damage repair, it still falls short of meeting the usage requirements in certain specialized applications. To further enable the versatile application of self-healing polyurethane while preserving its self-healing properties, the incorporation of new functional groups becomes an enticing prospect. These functional groups can bestow specific properties upon polyurethane, such as shape memory, degradability, antibacterial properties and biocompatibility, thereby achieving functional integration within self-healing polyurethane. Importantly, these functionalized self-healing polyurethanes possess the potential to supplant traditional materials as dielectric materials, substrate materials, or encapsulation materials in the realm of flexible sensors. Consequently, they contribute to enhancing the reliability and durability of flexible sensors. Therefore, this article primarily focuses on elucidating the self-healing mechanism of self-healing polyurethane. Subsequently, it delves into the integration of functionality within self-healing polyurethane and its application within the field of flexible sensors. Lastly, based on these insights, the paper provides a glimpse into the future prospects for the development of self-healing polyurethane.

Contents

1 Introduction

2 Self-healing mechanism of polyurethane(PU)

2.1 Reversible covalent bonds

2.2 Dynamic noncovalent interactions

2.3 Combination of covalent bonds and noncovalent interactions

3 Functionalization of self-healing polyurethane

3.1 Shape memory

3.2 Degradability

3.3 Antibacterial performance

3.4 Biocompatibility

4 Application of self-healing PU in flexible sensors

4.1 Self-healing PU based dielectric layer

4.2 Self-healing PU based flexible electrode

4.3 Self-healing PU based encapsulated layer

5 Conclusion and outlook

Cite this article

Chao Chen , Guyue Wang , Ying Tian , Zhengyang Kong , Fenglong Li , Jin Zhu , Wu Bin Ying . Research Progress on Self-Healing Polyurethane and Its Applications in the Field of Flexible Sensors[J]. Progress in Chemistry, 2023 , 35(9) : 1275 -1293 . DOI: 10.7536/PC230530

1 Introduction

Since the first polymer was developed by human beings, various polymers have penetrated into all aspects of life. Among them, polyurethane (PU) has received extensive attention due to its excellent comprehensive properties. Polyurethane (PU) is a general term for a class of polymers containing repeated carbamate bonds in the molecular backbone, which is mainly composed of alternating flexible chain segments (commonly known as soft segments) with glass transition temperature (Tg) lower than room temperature and rigid chain segments (commonly known as hard segments) with Tg higher than room temperature, which are connected by carbamate bonds[1,2][3]. These two kinds of chain segments are thermodynamically incompatible. In the condensed state, the hard segments will spontaneously aggregate together and embed in the soft segment phase region, resulting in microphase separation. The lower Tg of the soft phase region endows the polyurethane with reversible deformation function, while the hard phase region provides the polyurethane with shape fixing function through a large number of hydrogen bonds to produce strong association[4]. Because of this special structure, polyurethane has more excellent toughness and tear resistance than other materials[5]. At the same time, different degrees of microphase separation caused by different ratios of soft and hard segments will also affect the basic properties of polyurethane. In addition, there are many kinds of soft segments and hard segments of polyurethane, and a large number of hydroxyl-terminated macromolecular diols can be used as soft segments of polyurethane. Different small molecular diols can be used as chain extenders of polyurethane, and isocyanate with different molecular structures can be used as hard segments of polyurethane. We can introduce different functional groups into the main chain of polyurethane by changing the types of macromolecular diols, isocyanates and chain extenders, so as to achieve the purpose of functional modification of polyurethane[6~10]. This unique chemical structure can endow polyurethane with excellent hydrophobic properties, degradability and biocompatibility, which has great prospects for application in packaging, coating, biomedical engineering, flexible sensors and many other fields.
The only fly in the ointment is that no matter how widely polyurethane is used, minor damage will greatly shorten its service life. For this reason, self-healing polyurethane came into being. At the same time, it has attracted more and more attention because it can prolong the service life of materials and reduce the waste of resources. Similar to human skin, self-healing polyurethanes can repair damage spontaneously without external stimuli. However, for different application scenarios, such as endowing flexible sensors with flexible properties to adapt to complex curved surfaces and deformation environments, it is necessary to make self-healing polyurethane multifunctional to meet its use needs in specific scenarios. In this review, we will first focus on the healing mechanism of self-healing polyurethane, and then further understand the functional integration of self-healing polyurethane and its application in the field of flexible sensing (Figure 1).
图1 自愈合机理和功能化自愈合聚氨酯以及以自愈合聚氨酯为基底制备的柔性传感器

Fig.1 Self-healing mechanism and functionalization of the self-healing polyurethane and the flexible sensor based on self-healing polyurethane

2 Healing mechanism of self-healing polyurethane

Polyurethane has been widely used as an excellent polymer material in furniture, clothing, automotive and other fields. The disadvantage is that in the process of its use, it can not avoid some damage, and even produce large cracks and fractures in serious cases, which greatly shortens the service life of polyurethane. If polyurethane can heal itself at the beginning of damage, it can effectively avoid a series of subsequent problems. Therefore, inspired by the self-healing phenomenon in biology, people began to study and design self-healing polyurethane. According to the different healing mechanisms, self-healing polyurethane can be divided into externally driven healing polyurethane and internally driven healing polyurethane[11~13]. External driving refers to the release of pre-embedded external healing agent in the damaged area of polyurethane, and the self-repair of polyurethane is realized by external healing agent[11,14,15]. The advantage of this method is that it is simple and convenient, and does not require complex molecular structure design to achieve self-healing, but the disadvantage is also obvious: there is no way to repair the damage spontaneously for a long time and many times[16,17]. This self-healing approach has been gradually replaced by intrinsic drive. Intrinsic drive refers to the spontaneous movement of polyurethane molecular chains to re-entangle together through molecular structure design without additional healing agent, so as to achieve healing effect. Intrinsic driving is usually divided into two categories: reversible covalent bonds (such as disulfide bonds, Diels-Alder reactions, borate bonds, etc.) and dynamic non-covalent interactions (such as hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, metal coordination bonds, host-guest structures, etc.). In this section, we will introduce the intrinsic healing mechanism and self-healing efficiency of polyurethane in detail.

2.1 Reversible covalent bond

A reversible covalent bond is a dynamic bond that can be broken under certain conditions and then recombined. When it is introduced into the molecular chain segment of polyurethane, it not only has little effect on the mechanical properties of polyurethane, but also can realize the self-healing functionalization of polyurethane. Common reversible covalent bonds include Diels-Alder reaction, disulfide bond, diselenide bond, borate bond, etc.
Diels-Alder reaction (DA reaction) was discovered by German scientists in 1928. It was first used as an organic synthetic reagent and first applied to polyurethane synthesis in 1992[18]. This reaction refers to the 1,4-addition of a conjugated diene to an unsaturated compound with a carbon-carbon double bond to form a six-membered cyclic compound. The Diels-Alder reaction has been used many times to prepare self-healing urethanes because of its thermal reversibility, mild reaction conditions, and low degree of side reactions[19~21]. When the polyurethane molecular chain is broken due to damage, the conjugated dienes and unsaturated carbon-carbon double bonds in the molecular chain at both ends of the broken chain will be recombined through the DA reaction, thus realizing the macroscopic self-healing of polyurethane. Moreover, under the thermal drive, the polyurethane chain containing the DA bond will be broken into short molecular chains due to the reverse reaction of the DA reaction. The resulting short molecular chains move faster than conventional polyurethane molecular chains and easily move from one side of the crack to the other, filling the entire crack (Figure 2). When the temperature drops slightly, the short polyurethane chain can react with DA again, and the long polyurethane chain can be reconstituted to realize the self-healing of polyurethane cracks. Therefore, with the increase of time, the number of molecular chains that can fill the cracks also increases, thus improving the efficiency and strength of polyurethane self-healing. However, if the self-healing time is too long, the resulting short polyurethane chains and small molecules will undergo side reactions such as the decomposition of maleimide groups or the polymerization of their double bonds, which will prevent the DA reaction from continuing, resulting in more loss of mechanical properties of polyurethane after self-healing[19,22,23]. Therefore, it can be considered to graft the DA bond onto PCL, and use the DA bond as a dynamic crosslinking point to combine high modulus and toughness with low thermally triggered molecular fluidity, so as to endow polyurethane (PU) with excellent mechanical properties (Young's modulus is about 80 ~ 225 MPa,Ultimate tensile strength 16 – 30 MPa, toughness ~26-96 MJ·m-3), and the ability to spontaneously heal damages such as large scratches, punctures, and complete cuts at low heating temperatures (60 – 70 ° C)[20]. In addition, the mobility of the molecular chain segment of polyurethane containing DA bonds will also have a huge impact on its self-healing properties. At the same temperature, the faster the mobility of polyurethane molecular segments, the higher the encounter probability of DA bonds, indicating that more DA bonds can be recombined in the same time, thus accelerating the self-healing rate of polyurethane. Ionic liquid (EMITFS) can also be added between the polyurethane molecular chains as a plasticizer to improve the fluidity of the polyurethane chain segments, thereby reducing the self-healing temperature[21]. The obtained composite has PU-DA as the polymer network, and the EMITFS molecules are dispersed between the polymer networks. The self-healing temperature was reduced from 120 ° C to 60 ° C due to the improved fluidity. In addition, the composites prepared by mixing polyurethane PU-DA containing DA bonds in the main chain with other rigid materials, such as carbon nanotubes, can also achieve self-healing through DA bonds, and the mechanical properties after self-healing can be almost restored to the original level[24].
图2 (a) Diels-Alder反应;(b) Diels-Alder反应的自愈合机理;(c) 含有Diels-Alder反应的聚氨酯和 (d) 不含Diels-Alder反应的聚氨酯在一定温度下的自愈合图片[20]

Fig.2 (a) Diels-Alder interaction; (b) Self-healing mechanism of Diels-Alder interaction; Self-healing pictures of polyurethane with Diels-Alder reaction(c) and polyurethane without Diels-Alder reaction (d) at a certain temperature[20]. Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society

Disulfide bonds have been one of the most widely used covalent bonds since they were introduced into polyurethane segments in 1972[25]. Unlike other polyurethanes containing strong covalent bonds, which need self-healing at high temperature, the disulfide bond has a small bond energy of about 251 kJ/mol, which can be exchanged at room temperature to achieve self-healing[26]. When the polyurethane containing disulfide bonds is damaged, the polyurethane at the two ends of the damage contacts with each other, and the disulfide bonds in the main chain are exchanged and recombined to reconnect the broken polyurethane molecular chains, which is reflected macroscopically in the disappearance of the gap of the polyurethane, that is, self-repair is realized[27,28]. This process can be clearly seen in the optical microscope images. At first, the gap is a black line under the microscope. As time goes on, the black line fades, meaning that the gap gradually disappears and becomes almost invisible after a while (Fig. 3). Although disulfide bonds play a key role in the self-healing process of polyurethane, the self-healing efficiency does not necessarily increase with the increase of disulfide bond content. This is because the mobility of the polyurethane segment also affects the efficiency of self-healing, and the two effects on self-healing are mutual[26,28 ~30]. And the position of the disulfide bond also has an effect on the self-healing performance. When the disulfide bond is used as a chain extender in the polyurethane hard segment, if the content of the dynamic disulfide bond is very low, although the mobility of the soft segment is very high, the low-density dynamic bond still cannot repair the material at an obvious speed; If the content of dynamic disulfide bonds is very high, no matter how high the density of dynamic bonds is, the degree of microphase separation in polyurethane is too deep, and the mobility of molecular chains in the hard phase region is severely inhibited due to its Tg higher than room temperature, and the bond exchange of disulfide bonds can not be realized. When disulfide bonds exist in the soft segment of polyurethane, the self-healing efficiency of polyurethane always increases with the increase of disulfide bond content. However, when the content of disulfide bonds is the same and the molecular weight of the soft segment is reduced, that is, the distribution of disulfide bonds is more dispersed, the self-healing efficiency of polyurethane will also be reduced. This is due to the fact that the molecular weight of the soft segment is reduced, the influence of the hard segment on the soft segment is enhanced, and the molecular chain fluidity of the soft segment linking the hard segment is inhibited, thereby reducing the overall self-healing performance of the polyurethane[31,32]. Therefore, the self-healing ability can be optimized by adjusting the proportion of soft and hard segments of polyurethane or the content of disulfide bonds. A kind of hydrophobic polyurethane (BS-PU) with bis (4-hydroxyphenyl) disulfide (HPS) as chain extender can achieve self-healing at room temperature by controlling the content of disulfide bonds[29]. Due to the presence of disulfide bonds, BS-PU can achieve self-healing within 360 min at room temperature. In order to further improve the mechanical properties of self-healing polyurethanes containing disulfide bonds for applications in more fields, bis (4-hydroxyphenyl) disulfide (HPS) containing benzene rings can be selected as an aromatic disulfide chain extender to prepare transparent and easy-to-process self-healing polyurethanes (TPU)[27]. The obtained polyurethane not only has ultrahigh tensile strength and toughness (6.8 MPa and 26.9 MJ·m-3), but also can recover 99% of the original mechanical properties within 120 min. In addition, dual chain extenders, such as the simultaneous use of bis (2-hydroxyethyl) disulfide (HEDS) and 1,8-alkanediamine (MD) as chain extenders, can also be selected to tailor the mechanical properties of self-healing polyurethanes[33]. The amino group of MD and isocyanate react to form a group containing hydrogen bonds, providing better mechanical properties, while the rigid ring structure of MD promotes the cleavage and reorganization of disulfide bonds, thereby improving the self-healing efficiency of polyurethane. In addition to being present in the chain extender, the disulfide bond can also be introduced into the polyurethane as part of the soft segment, and the synthesized polyurethane can be completely self-healed after 48 H at room temperature[32].
图3 (a) BS-PU的化学结构;(b) 拉长的PU膜示意图,裂缝可以在动态二硫键的驱动下自我修复(右);(c)缺口和自愈的BS-PU-3薄膜的光学显微镜图像;(d) 自愈合后的BS-PU的560 g的举重测试[29]

Fig.3 (a) Chemical structure of BS-PU; (b) Schematic of an elongated PU film, and the crack could be self-healed driven by dynamic disulfide bonds (right); (c) Optical microscope images of the notched and self-healed BS-PU-3 film; (d) Weight lifting test demonstrating the self-healing capability of BS-PU with a load of 560 g[29]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society

In addition to the above covalent bonds, borate ester bonds, as a classical class of dynamic covalent bonds, are also widely used in the synthesis of self-healing polyurethanes[34]. It can be cleaved into benzene diboronic acid and alcohols at room temperature to realize the bond exchange and recombination of borate ester bonds, thus realizing the self-healing of polyurethane. In addition, another dynamic thiocarbamate bond, which can realize C — S bond exchange and recombination under light and 50 ℃, has also been used as a commonly used dynamic covalent bond in the synthesis of self-healing polyurethane[35]. Recent studies have shown that the diselenide bond, which exists in biological macromolecules such as proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids, can also be used as a reversible dynamic bond in self-healing polyurethanes (Figure 4)[36,37]. These studies have shown that reversible covalent bonds are an excellent class of self-healing functional groups that can be used in polyurethane segments.
图4 (a) 自愈合聚氨酯 (CBPU) 中的动态键:硫代氨基甲酸乙酯交换[35];(b) 含有硫代氨基甲酸酯键的聚氨酯的自愈合图像[35];(c) 可见光照射下的二硒化合作用[36];(d) 含有二硒键的自愈合聚氨酯在压力下的愈合行为:光照24 h后裂纹消失[36]

Fig.4 (a) Dynamic bonds contained in self-healing polyurethanes (CBPU): thiourethane exchange (b) Optical self-healing microscope images of polyurethanes containing thiourethane bonds[35]; (c) Diselenide metathesis under visible light irradiation[36]; (d) Healing behavior under pressure; the crack disappeared after 24 h light irradiation[36]. Copyright 2018, American Chemical Society

2.2 Dynamic noncovalent interaction

Unlike reversible covalent bonds, which require shared electron pairs, dynamic non-covalent interactions achieve the self-healing function of polyurethane through the breakage and reconnection of weak interactions between different atoms. Noncovalent interactions, however, are relatively labile, susceptible to disruption under the same conditions, and also susceptible to reassociation[37].
Therefore, the dynamic non-covalent interaction can not only be used as a dynamic bond to synthesize self-healing polyurethanes, but also sometimes be used as a sacrificial bond to improve the mechanical properties of self-healing polyurethanes. Common dynamic non-covalent interactions are hydrogen bonds, metal coordination bonds, ionic bonds, etc.
The hydrogen bond is formed by the interaction between a proton donor and a proton acceptor, and is an interaction force that is slightly stronger than the intermolecular force and slightly weaker than other covalent bonds. Because there are a lot of urethane bonds in polyurethane, there are a lot of hydrogen bonds in polyurethane itself. And are most commonly used in the construction of self-healing polyurethanes due to their selectivity, directionality, and reversibility[38,39]. Unlike the increase in reversible covalent bonds, which depletes the mechanical properties of polyurethanes, the increase in hydrogen bonds, especially the presence of multiple hydrogen bonds, can improve the mechanical properties and self-healing ability of polyurethanes (fig. 5). This is because multiple hydrogen bonds exist between stretchable polymer chains, which aggregate to form geometrically constrained arrays that act as strong but reversible sacrificial and crosslinking bonds, building a physically dynamic crosslinking network. The strength of the hydrogen bond is below 40 kJ/mol, which is much smaller than the chemical bond in the polyurethane chain segment. When polyurethane is stretched, hydrogen bonds are first destroyed, dissipating a part of energy, eliminating stress concentration and promoting molecular chain orientation, thus significantly improving the strength and toughness of polyurethane. Therefore, the broken hydrogen bonds at room temperature can also recombine to form new hydrogen bonds to achieve macroscopic self-healing. It is worth noting that heating can accelerate the self-healing process of hydrogen bonds. This is because some molecular segments are difficult to move at room temperature, and can hardly drive the broken hydrogen bonds on their segments to combine with other broken hydrogen bonds. Therefore, the application of a certain temperature can accelerate the movement of the molecular chain segment and accelerate the combination of the broken hydrogen bonds on the chain segment with other broken hydrogen bonds. The macroscopic manifestation is that the temperature rises and the self-healing speed accelerates. When the heating process is over, the temperature drops, and the hydrogen bonds have reconnected the broken polyurethane molecular chains, which is reflected in the macroscopic self-repair of polyurethane[38,40,41]. Due to the movement of polyurethane molecular chains, many macromolecules in organisms, such as carnosine, cellulose, spider silk, etc., are also self-healing through hydrogen bonds without loss of mechanical properties[42][43,44][45]. Inspired by this, polyurethane (SPU) with multiple hydrogen bonds, which imitates the structure of spider silk, not only has ultra-high true fracture stress (1. 21 GPa) and ultra-high toughness, but also can self-heal[46]. The tensile strength and elongation at break of the fractured SPU elastomer reached nearly 100% self-healing efficiency after 36 H at 100 ℃. However, the self-healing speed of this kind of polyurethane needs to be improved, which is difficult to meet the needs of daily applications. Increasing the density of hydrogen bonds can be one of the ways to solve this problem, for example, chain extenders with quadruple hydrogen bonds on the side chain can be used to increase the density of hydrogen bonds in polyurethane chain segments.Then a self-healing polyurethane with higher self-healing efficiency and more robustness was prepared by virtue of the inverse pearl structure and the high-density non-covalent bond interaction at the interface between the dopamine-modified graphene oxide and the polyurethane matrix[46~48][40]. Among them, dopamine can increase the density of hydrogen bonds at the interface and obtain an interwoven network, which endows polyurethane with excellent self-healing ability at ambient temperature. The prepared polyurethane can not only self-heal at room temperature (the healing efficiency reaches 90% after 1 H), but also self-heal at-18 ℃, showing excellent self-healing performance.
图5 (a) 含有非平面环和 (b) 含有苯环的多重氢键聚氨酯的结构式;(c) 自愈合聚氨酯在一定温度下划痕消失的显微图[46]

Fig.5 Structure of polyurethanes with multiple hydrogen bonds featuring (a) non-planar rings and (b) benzene rings;(c) Microscope images of self-healing polyurethane scratch disappearance at a certain temperature[46]. Copyright 2021, Willey

As a non-covalent interaction, the bond energy of ionic bond is weaker than that of general covalent interaction, but stronger than that of hydrogen bond and intermolecular interaction, and it is also widely used in self-healing polyurethane due to its excellent reversible recombination reaction (fig. 6)[49~52]. There is an electrostatic interaction between two anions and cations, and when two ions with reversible charges are close to each other, they will attract each other and form an ionic bond[53,54]. However, the complete recovery of mechanical properties of polyurethane can not be achieved only by ionic bonds. When polyurethane is broken by external force, the more unstable ionic bonds are destroyed first. Only when the unstable ionic bond is completely destroyed, the covalent bond that is difficult to destroy will be destroyed, but the destroyed covalent bond accounts for a small part. When the two ends of the broken polyurethane are in contact, the ionic bonds will attract each other under the electrostatic interaction, which will re-entangle the molecular chains at the two ends of the fracture surface and produce a large number of strong physical entanglement points, accompanied by the process of re-linking the broken polyurethane short chain segments into polyurethane long chain segments. The large number of physical entanglement points can compensate for the loss of mechanical properties of polyurethane caused by the breakage of some covalent bonds. However, a small amount of broken covalent bonds can not self-heal, and the strength of physical entanglement points is slightly lower than that of covalent bonds, so the mechanical properties of polyurethane after self-healing can only be close to 100% of the original, but not consistent[5,13]. With the ionic bond as the self-healing driving force, the ionic polyurethane (i-PU) with quaternary ammonium salt in the main chain can achieve complete self-healing after standing at room temperature for 400 min, and its mechanical properties can be restored to 97. 5% of the original[49]. In addition to the ionic bonds on the main chain, the ionic bonds carried on the side chain can also endow polyurethane with excellent self-healing properties. Polyurethanes (ionic PUs) with imidazolium cationic groups on the side chain not only have high tensile strength (about 16. 9 MPa), elongation at break (about 1600%) and toughness (about 198 MJ·m-3), but also the reversible ionic interaction between the ionic pairs on the side chain of polyurethane helps the polyurethane to achieve crack self-repair at mild temperature (40 ℃)[55]. In addition, there is not only a single ion in the polyurethane molecular chain, but also a variety of ions to improve the self-healing efficiency and mechanical properties[50,56]. For zwitterionic polyurethanes (ZSMPUs), due to the special structure of cations in the main chain and anions in the side chain, the polyurethane molecules can form a dynamic crosslinking network through ionic bonds to improve the mechanical properties, and have repeatable self-healing properties, which can recover the original properties after 2 H of self-healing at 50 ℃[56].
图6 (a) 离子键的自愈合机理;(b) 有缺口的含有离子键的自愈合聚氨酯薄膜的光学显微镜图像和三维表面映射显微镜图像和 (c) 划痕深度图[49]

Fig.6 (a) Self-healing mechanism of ionic bonds; (b) Optical microscopic images and 3D surface mapping microscopic images of the notched i-PU film with ionic bond; (c) Scratch depth diagram[49]. Copyright 2022, Willey

In addition to the above common hydrogen and ionic bonds, the metal coordination bond formed by the metal ion and the ligand together is also an excellent dynamic non-covalent interaction for the synthesis of self-healing polyurethanes, and the self-healing of polyurethanes can be achieved through the bond exchange between the metal ion and the ligand (fig. 7)[57~61]. In the polyurethane chain segment, the metal coordination bond formed by the cobalt ion as the metal center and the iminodiol as the ligand can be used as a physical dynamic crosslinking network point, and the self-healing polyurethane HPPU-Co containing the coordination bond not only has excellent tensile properties, but also can be completely self-healed after standing for 12 H at room temperature[62]. In addition to metal coordination bonds, the Donor-Acceptor structure (DA structure) has attracted much attention because it can endow polymers with significant stretchability, toughness, and self-healing properties (Fig. 7)[63~66]. Moreover, because polyurethane is a special polymer with microphase separation, the synergistic effect of the movement of its molecular chain during microphase separation and D-A self-assembly can further improve the mechanical properties of polyurethane. Inspired by this, we introduced the electron-donating structure of naphthalene ring (D) and the electron-withdrawing structure of imide group (A) into polyurethane, and the synthesized polyurethane DA-PU with alternating donor and acceptor groups along the main chain not only has excellent mechanical properties,At the same time, when the polyurethane is damaged, under the movement of the molecular chain segment, the damaged DA structure and the isolated D and A units will self-assemble again to realize the self-healing of the polyurethane. [67]. The polyurethane can completely recover its original properties after self-healing at 60 ℃ for 400 min. In addition, many researchers have introduced ion-dipole moment interaction into polyurethane chain segments, which can also endow polyurethane with excellent self-healing properties[68,69].
图7 (a) 金属配位键的自愈合机理和 (b) 含有金属配位键的自愈合聚氨酯在一定温度下的划痕消失图[62];(c) Donor-Acceptor相互作用示意图和含有Donor-Acceptor相互作用的自愈合聚氨酯在一定温度下自愈合的偏光显微图[67]

Fig.7 (a) Self-healing mechanism of metal ligand bonds; (b) Digital photos and optical microscope photos of the cutting-healing-stretching procedure of self-healing polyurethanes containing metal ligand bonds[62]; (c) Schematic illustration of the breakup and restore of Donor-Acceptor self-assembly and (d) micrographs of self-healing polyurethane containing Donor-Acceptor at certain temperatures[67]. Copyright 2021, Willey

2.3 Combined Action of Multiple Driving Forces

Although the introduction of reversible covalent bonds or dynamic non-covalent interactions in the polyurethane chain segment can endow polyurethane with excellent self-healing properties, the energy of reversible covalent bonds is usually relatively low, resulting in slow self-healing rate, and most of the self-healing bonds can only maintain the original mechanical properties of polyurethane and can not be further improved. In order to obtain polyurethanes with high toughness and fast self-healing ability, reversible covalent bonds and dynamic non-covalent interactions can be introduced into the polyurethane chain segment. The reversible covalent bond is responsible for the self-healing ability, while the dynamic non-covalent interaction acts as a sacrificial bond, which is first destroyed during the stretching process, thus improving the mechanical properties of the self-healing polyurethane as a whole[70~73]. Because the polyurethane segment itself forms one of the dynamic non-covalent hydrogen bonds, the most common combination of multiple driving forces is the combination of hydrogen bonds with other reversible covalent bonds. For example, disulfide bonds can be introduced into polyurethanes containing multiple hydrogen bonds to effectively improve their self-healing efficiency[33]. Under the synergistic effect of multiple hydrogen bonds and disulfide bonds, the tensile strength of the synthesized polyurethane reaches 24. 8 MPa, the elongation at break reaches 2 143. 7%, and the scratch of the polyurethane disappears completely after 30 min of self-healing at 40 ℃. Another combination effect is the combination of dynamic ditellurium bond and quadruple hydrogen bond, namely 2-ureido-4 [1H] -pyrimidone (UPy), which endows polyurethane with excellent self-healing properties and toughness at the same time[74]. Quadruple hydrogen bonding (UPy) can make the toughness of polyurethane up to 105.2 MJ·m-3 by enhancing the physical crosslinking of intramolecular/intermolecular chains; After the introduction of dynamic ditellurium bond, the self-healing efficiency was significantly improved under the synergistic effect of quadruple hydrogen bond, which could be restored to 92. 9%. In addition, the developed high-toughness self-healing polyurethane can also combine the characteristics of high toughness (127.0 MJ·m-3) and fast self-healing (60 ℃, 2 H) by using the synergistic effect of dynamic imine bond and multi-level hydrogen bond[75]. In addition to the combination of dynamic covalent bonds, hydrogen bonds and other dynamic non-covalent bonds, such as ionic bonds and metal coordination bonds, can also endow polyurethanes with excellent mechanical properties and self-healing properties[73][69,72].
However, in the self-healing process of polyurethane, the effect of broken covalent bonds on its mechanical properties cannot be ignored. In the polyurethane network, the covalent bond of polyurethane is only a basis for maintaining the mechanical properties of polyurethane, and a single molecular chain of covalent bond alone cannot maintain sufficient mechanical strength.The physical crosslinking points produced by the physical entanglement of polyurethane molecular chains and the dynamic crosslinking points produced by the introduction of self-healing bonds can greatly improve the mechanical properties of polyurethane. In the fracture process of polyurethane subjected to external force, the physical entanglement point absorbs a part of the external force and is destroyed first; Secondly, self-healing bonds such as hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, and coordination bonds are more unstable than stable covalent bonds such as urethane bonds, and are destroyed as sacrificial bonds after absorbing most of the external force. Only when these sacrificial bonds are completely destroyed, more force is needed to destroy other stable covalent bonds, and the remaining external force can only destroy a very small part of the covalent bonds. When the broken polyurethane is in contact with each other, due to the reversible effect of the self-healing bond, the self-healing bond first contacts with each other to form a new bond, and the broken polyurethane short molecular chain is relinked into a long molecular chain to restore the chain length of the polyurethane to a certain extent. Moreover, at a certain temperature, the polyurethane molecular chains can re-entangle to form a large number of physical entanglement points. The newly formed physical entanglement points can compensate for the loss of mechanical properties of polyurethane caused by the breakage of some covalent bonds. After the above two processes, the polyurethane can almost restore the original mechanical properties. However, the broken covalent bonds such as urethane bonds can not heal themselves, and the strength of physical entanglement points is lower than that of covalent bonds, so the mechanical properties of polyurethane can not be fully restored to 100%, but can only be close to 100%[5,13,70 ~73].

3 Functional integration of self-healing polyurethane

As can be seen from the previous chapter, self-healing polyurethanes can spontaneously repair damage, thereby extending their service life and reducing maintenance costs. However, only self-healing performance still can not meet the needs of polyurethane in some special occasions. In smart home and other fields, although self-healing polyurethane can spontaneously heal after being damaged by external forces to prolong its service life, it lacks the reversibility of multiple deformation and recovery, which limits its partial application. In the field of packaging materials, although self-healing polyurethane can self-heal after damage to reduce the environmental pollution of packaging products, it is easy to pollute the environment because it can not be degraded, and its lack of antibacterial properties limits some applications. In the field of biomedicine, although the mechanical properties of self-healing polyurethane can be controlled to replace the current wound dressings and surgical sutures that can not be self-healing, it can not be used because of its lack of biocompatibility. In order to further realize the application of self-healing polyurethane in multiple scenarios, it is necessary to consider introducing some new functional groups to realize the functional integration of self-healing polyurethane while retaining the self-healing performance of polyurethane.

3.1 Shape memory

Stimulus-responsive polymers with similar abilities have attracted much attention, inspired by the shape transformation of organisms in nature in response to environmental changes. Among them, shape memory polymers (SMP) are a representative class of stimuli-responsive polymers, which can be pre-set in shape and restored to their original shape after being stimulated by external stimuli[76~79]. This process has good reversibility. Therefore, after the shape memory function is introduced into the self-healing polyurethane, the obtained shape memory self-healing polyurethane not only has the function of spontaneous healing after being damaged, but also has the shape memory function of restoring the original shape after being stimulated after deformation, and can be designed into a sensor responding to stimulation to be applied in the fields of medical treatment, aerospace and the like (fig. 8)[80~82].
图8 (a) 聚氨酯的自愈合机理和形状记忆机理;(b) 自愈合聚氨酯的形状记忆特性以及 (c)自愈合性能[76]

Fig.8 (a) Self-healing mechanism and shape memory mechanism of polyurethane; (b) Shape memory performance and (c) self-healing properties of polyurethane[76]. Copyright 2018, Willey

By introducing Diels-Alder reaction and aniline trimer (AT) into the light-induced programmed shape memory polyurethane, a polyurethane with both target shape memory and precise self-healing properties can be obtained[78]. Under the action of Diels-Alder reaction, the polyurethane has excellent self-healing performance, and the healing efficiency is still more than 70% after three cycles of self-healing. In addition, the shape memory property of the prepared polyurethane is also excellent, and the polyurethane can restore the original complex 3D structure or perform pre-designed motion under the excitation of infrared rays; At the same time, it also has repeatable shape memory performance, and after three consecutive shape memory cycles, its shaping rate and shape recovery rate are both above 90%. In addition, the introduction of ionic bonds in shape memory polyurethane gels that can be used for 4D printing can also endow them with excellent self-healing properties[83]. The self-healing property is dependent on the ionic bonds formed between the COO- groups of the polyurethane nanoparticles and the NH 3 + groups on the gelatin chains. Moreover, the polyurethane used as the raw material for the shape memory 4D printing structure shows good shape fixation (more than 95%) and shape recovery (more than 98%). This 4D bioprinted, self-healing polyurethane hydrogel with shape memory has very large potential for custom biomanufacturing. In addition to ionic bonds, the introduction of dynamic oxime-carbamate bonds and hydrogen bonds into the molecular chain can also achieve the combination of self-healing properties and shape memory properties of polyurethane[84]. Polyurethane with 1,4-benzoquinone dioxime (BQDO) and 1,4-butanediol (BDO) as chain extenders has a self-healing effect of 80% within 80 s, and has significant shape memory properties, which can be effectively triggered by near-infrared radiation or direct heating.

3.2 Degradable

With the increasingly serious environmental problems, countries around the world are formulating different policies to reduce pollution. Among them, the government has put forward measures such as plastic ban and garbage classification to reduce the white pollution caused by material waste. This shows that the use of degradable materials in all aspects is imminent[85,86]. At present, in addition to natural degradable polymers and biodegradable polymers synthesized by microorganisms, there are also many synthetic degradable polymers, such as polylactic acid (PLA), polycaprolactone (PCL), poly (butylene terephthalate/adipate) (PBAT), etc., which are widely used because of their excellent processability and wide mechanical range. For self-healing polyurethanes, they can prolong their service life by self-healing in the process of use, which is a means to reduce material waste to some extent. However, any material will have the end of its service life, and self-healing polyurethane is no exception. If the self-healing and degradable properties can be integrated into polyurethane, the environmental protection can be achieved with half the effort. In recent years, the introduction of degradable groups into the molecular chain of self-healing polyurethane and the development of degradable self-healing polyurethane decomposed into small molecules or oligomers through unstable bonds under mild conditions have become one of the hot spots to meet the sustainable development strategy (Fig. 9)[87~90].
图9 (a) 可降解的水凝胶与不可降解的水凝胶的分子结构以及 (b) 可降解的低温凝胶与不可降解的低温凝胶的质量损失对比图[93]

Fig.9 (a) Schematic structure of a self-healing polyurethane with degradable properties; (b) Weight loss of degradable hydrogels and non-degradable cryogels[93]. Copyright 2020, Willey

Ester bond is one of the most common degradable groups, which can be introduced into the molecular chain of polyurethane to endow self-healing polyurethane with certain degradability[84~86]. When the ester bond is introduced into the polyurethane molecular chain containing the disulfide bond and the hydrogen bond, the obtained polyurethane can have both self-healing property and degradable property[91]. Due to the influence of disulfide bonds and hydrogen bonds in the molecular chain segment, the synthesized polyurethane PU-ATs can recover to the original state after self-healing for 3 H at 40 ℃. At the same time, due to the ester bond in the molecular chain segment, PU-ATs could be hydrolyzed in PBS buffer solution (37 ℃, pH = 7.4), and its mass lost 30% in seven weeks. In the case of glutathione (GSH) as a disulfide reducing and degrading agent, polyurethane can be degraded more effectively. GSH is an effective reductant that converts disulfide bonds to thiol groups. In GSH solution, PU-ATs exhibited a faster degradation rate than in PBS medium. In addition, the self-healing polyurethane synthesized from biomaterials can also be degraded under certain conditions. After introducing alginate groups into the polyurethane backbone, alginate can not only act as an ionic bond to endow polyurethane (ASPU) with excellent self-healing properties, but also act as a degradation group to promote the rapid degradation of polyurethane in vivo, and its degradation rate is similar to that of PCL[92]. Due to the presence of a large number of cations and alginate, the two pieces of ASPU can be completely self-healed after 30 seconds of contact under the action of ionic bonds, and the self-healing efficiency can still reach more than 70% after repeated "breaking-self-healing". When ASPU was put into the solution containing Lipase, the mass loss of ASPU was nearly half after 96 H, which was much faster than the degradation rate of PCL, indicating that ASPU had excellent degradation ability. Similarly, the novel bifunctional polyurethane CS-PU obtained by introducing chitosan into the polyurethane chain containing ester bonds and Schiff bases also has excellent degradability and self-healing properties[84].

3.3 Antibacterial

To date, self-healing polyurethanes have been widely used in healthcare, textile industry, and food packaging due to their excellent mechanical properties, water resistance, gas permeability, and biocompatibility[94~96]. It is worth noting that the antibacterial activity of pure polyurethane is not good, and it is easy to breed bacteria in the long-term use process. Bacterial contamination of various polyurethane surfaces, including implantable devices, surgical equipment and packaging films, may lead to widespread epidemics.It adversely affects our daily lives and, at the same time, poses a devastating threat to human health, causing serious complications for patients and placing a heavy burden on the health care system[97~99]. In this infection process, bacterial adhesion to the polyurethane surface is a prerequisite. To make matters worse, bacteria that adhere to polyurethane surfaces produce extracellular polymers to form biofilms composed of proteins and other extracellular polymers. It protects bacteria from antimicrobials and is difficult to eliminate. Therefore, in order to improve the safety of self-healing polyurethanes against bacterial infection, it is of great significance to study self-antibacterial polyurethanes.
At present, there are two ways to endow self-healing polyurethane with excellent antibacterial properties: one is to introduce chemical bonds, such as disulfide bonds and ionic bonds, into the molecular chain of polyurethane to achieve antibacterial function (Fig. 10)[100,101]. The introduction of disulfide bond in the main chain of polyurethane can not only endow polyurethane with excellent self-healing performance (the self-healing efficiency can reach 88. 60% after 30 min of illumination), but also endow polyurethane with excellent antibacterial performance, the antibacterial performance of Escherichia coli can reach 90. 2%, and the antibacterial performance of Staphylococcus aureus can reach 92. 5%[102]. In addition, the introduction of metal coordination bonds in the polyurethane chain can not only improve the self-healing efficiency of polyurethane, but also improve the antibacterial properties of polyurethane[103]. These polyurethanes form a covalently crosslinked zinc-dimethylethylenediamine-polyurethane coordination network with a portion of hydrogen bonds, which have triple dynamic bonds. The recombination of hydrogen bonds and metal coordination bonds produces an effective self-healing property; At the same time, the metal coordination bond also endows the polyurethane with excellent antibacterial properties, and the obtained polyurethane film has a bacterial inhibition rate of 99.5% and 98.9% against Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, respectively. The other is to achieve antibacterial function by mixing antibacterial agents, such as silver nanoparticles, metal cations and so on[55,104,105]. This method is more common. In order to make the combination of polyurethane and silver nanoparticles more stable, polydopamine nanoparticles with furfural group (FPDA NPs) can be introduced into the polyurethane chain through DA reaction as a crosslinking agent of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs)[106]. The polyurethane film has excellent self-healing properties (90%) due to the presence of DA bonds. Importantly, due to the presence of FPDA, AgNPs can be completely coated and connected with PU molecular chains. The AgNPs act as antibacterial agents and nanofillers, giving the polyurethane film excellent long-term antibacterial properties against Gram-negative Escherichia coli and Gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus.
图10 (a) 自愈合聚氨酯 (CBPU) 中含有的动态键:硫代氨基甲酸酯键;(b) 自愈合聚氨酯的自愈合偏光显微图;(c) 自愈合聚氨酯的抗菌测试[35]

Fig.10 (a) Dynamic bonds contained in self-healing polyurethanes (CBPU): thiourethane exchange; (b) Optical self-healing microscope images of polyurethanes containing thiourethane bonds; (c) Antibacterial testing of self-healing polyurethane[35]. Copyright 2021, Elsevier

3.4 Biocompatibility

Self-healing polyurethanes are considered to have great potential in biomedical materials such as wound dressings, surgical sutures and sternal fixation lines because of their controllable mechanical properties[93,107 ~110]. However, once the material is not properly selected, it will cause discomfort to the human body, and even cause a series of complications such as aggravation of injury and tissue infection, causing secondary injury to the human body. Ideal biomedical materials need to meet the following requirements: (1) good histocompatibility and no cytotoxicity; (2) Sufficient physical and mechanical strength to ensure its integrity and avoid the invasion of external bacteria caused by material damage; (3) Appropriate surface microstructure and biochemical properties to promote cell adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation[109,111]. Therefore, it is necessary for the self-healing polyurethane to be biocompatible and to promote cell growth on the surface without cytotoxicity. At present, the methods to improve the biocompatibility of polyurethane are mainly achieved by introducing biocompatible groups into the polyurethane chain segment (Fig. 11)[110,112]. The high strength self-healing elastomer (SHE) was synthesized by using biocompatible dimethylglyoxime and glycerol as chain extenders and polytetrahydrofuran (PTMEG) as soft segment, which not only has excellent self-healing properties, but also has excellent biocompatibility[119]. The self-healing properties of SHE are dependent on the dynamic oxime-carbamate bonds and hydrogen bonds in the polyurethane segment.
图11 (a) 具有生物相容性的自愈合聚氨酯的结构示意图;(b) 具有生物相容性的自愈合聚氨酯的自愈合演示;(c) 细胞在具有生物相容性的自愈合聚氨酯上生长的荧光染色图[113]

Fig.11 (a) Scheme of a self-healing polyurethane with biocompatibility; (b) Demonstration of self-healing with biocompatible self-healing polyurethane; (c) Fluorescent staining of cells grown on biocompatible self-healing polyurethane[113]. Copyright 2022, American Chemical Society

In the analysis of acute and chronic subcutaneous inflammation, the inflammatory response of SHE is the smallest, which proves that SHE has excellent biocompatibility and can be used to treat some clinical diseases, such as limiting aneurysms, covering nerves and fixing sternum. The CS-PU containing Schiff base synthesized from chitosan also has excellent self-healing properties and biocompatibility[93]. CS-PU could completely self-heal after standing at room temperature for 1 H, and the cells proliferated significantly after seven weeks of culture on the polyurethane substrate. Because of these advantages, the polyurethane can be used as a wound dressing to promote the reorganization of skin cells and the generation of new tissue. In addition to the above methods, the polyurethane gel obtained by blending the aloe gel having excellent biocompatibility with the water-soluble self-healing polyurethane also has both biocompatibility and self-healing properties[113]. The polyurethane hydrogel can be used as a microneedle scaffold after secondary processing, and the microneedle scaffold has excellent self-healing performance due to the existence of dynamic hydrogen bonds and Schiff bases in the polyurethane hydrogel. Subsequently, they were placed in medium containing microneedle scaffolds to culture 3T3 cells. Five days later, it was found that the cells not only grew well in the scaffold part, but also adhered and grew in the microneedle part. This result shows that the prepared polyurethane hydrogel microneedle scaffold has excellent biocompatibility, and the polyurethane hydrogel can be used for wound tissue healing and drug release control.

3.5 Other

In addition to introducing a series of functionalizations such as shape memory, degradability, antibacterial and biocompatibility into self-healing polyurethane, other researchers have endowed self-healing polyurethane with a variety of other functions to match more application scenarios[114~117]. The incorporation of a large number of fluorine atoms in the self-healing polyurethane molecular chain can be used to separate immiscible oil/water mixtures and water-in-oil emulsions driven by gravity alone[118]; The self-healing waterborne polyurethane composite film containing boric acid and borax synthesized by nucleophilic substitution method can be used as a leather coating to improve the abrasion resistance of leather[119]. Due to the aggregation-induced emission (AIE) characteristics of the specific tertiary amine structure of the side chain, the high-strength self-healing polyurethane with bisamide hydrogen bonds in the side chain not only has good self-healing ability at room temperature, but also can be used as a fluorescent coating for anti-counterfeiting applications[120].

4 Application of Self-healing Polyurethane in Flexible Sensing

Traditional sensors based on rigid materials, such as metal and rigid plastics, are increasingly unable to meet the requirements of artificial intelligence and health care because of their shortcomings such as non-stretchability and poor fit with human skin. People hope to develop a kind of sensor with stretchability, fatigue resistance and close fit with human body. Therefore, flexible sensors made of flexible substrate materials have emerged as the times require, and have attracted more and more research interests because of their great application potential in medical, national defense and artificial intelligence loads. However, the flexible sensor is prone to micro-cracks and mechanical fracture during long-term use, resulting in the loss of sensing performance. Therefore, it is necessary to introduce self-healing characteristics into flexible sensors to improve their reliability and durability. Self-healing polyurethane has become one of the important component materials in flexible sensors because of its excellent mechanical properties, self-healing properties and easy multi-function. On the one hand, the self-healing polyurethane can be directly used as a dielectric material or blended with other materials to become a sensing material in a flexible sensor; On the other hand, the self-healing polyurethane can be used as a substrate material of carbon-based, metal-based and other conductive particles to prepare a self-healing flexible conductive material which can be used as a flexible sensor wire. In addition, the self-healing polyurethane can also be directly used as the encapsulation material of the conductive network to protect the conductive network from external damage.

4.1 Polyurethane-based sensing material

Self-healing polyurethane is very suitable as the substrate material of flexible sensors because of its strong plasticity, good wear resistance, strong corrosion resistance and self-healing. In detail, polyurethane has excellent plasticity and can be made into different shapes for complex sensor designs. The good wear resistance can make the polyurethane-based sensor maintain its good performance in the long-term use process, which can be used in long-term monitoring and other fields. In addition, the excellent corrosion resistance ensures that the polyurethane-based sensor is free from chemical interference during use. Most importantly, the excellent self-healing performance makes the polyurethane-based sensor heal spontaneously after being damaged by external force, which further prolongs the service life of the flexible sensor. Due to these advantages, polyurethane has been widely used as a flexible sensing material.
Because the self-healing polyurethane itself has a certain dielectric constant, it can be directly used as a flexible sensing material to sense small physical changes (Figure 12)[29,30,35,67]. A kind of pressure sensor with self-healing polyurethane (BS-PU) containing disulfide bond as dielectric layer and liquid metal as conductor can be used to sense the change of different pressures[29]. The sensor can identify a specific pressure by a change in capacitance. Moreover, due to the disulfide bond in BS-PU, the sensor showed obvious toughness and self-healing ability at room temperature. After self-healing at room temperature for 6 H, the sensor recovered its function as before. In addition, the sensor with polyurethane as the sensing material can sense not only the change of pressure, but also the change of strain. The sensor with self-healing polyurethane containing DA structure as the sensing material can produce the change of capacitance signal under different strains, which can be used to monitor the standard degree of athletes'movement[67]. Due to the DA structure in the polyurethane backbone, the sensor can self-heal at room temperature, and the sensing performance is hardly affected after self-healing.
图12 (a) 可自愈合聚氨酯 (BS-PU) 的结构示意图;(b) 以BS-PU为基底制备的传感器的过程以及(c) 传感性能[29]

Fig.12 (a) Structure of self-healing polyurethane (BS-PU); (b) Process of preparing a sensor based on BS-PU and (c) its sensing performance[29]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society

Although the sensor directly using self-healing polyurethane as sensing material can sense different physical changes, due to the limitation of the dielectric constant of self-healing polyurethane itself, the sensitivity of the sensor is low, and it can not be applied to more sophisticated environments. In order to overcome the defect of sensitivity while retaining the self-healing performance of polyurethane, we can achieve it by filling the conductive material into the self-healing polyurethane. Common conductive fillers can be divided into two categories, one is to transmit signals through electron migration, such as graphene, carbon nanotubes, etc[121~124]. The other is to transmit signals through ion migration, mainly ionic liquids (IL)[34,125]. The first type of research is more extensive, for example, the self-healing polyurethane containing dynamic oxime-carbamate bonds blended with graphene as a dielectric layer is integrated into the corresponding sensor, which can be used to monitor human movement and various mechanical movements sensitively and stably[121]. The sensor relies on electron migration to transmit signals, and different strains will change the distribution of the conductive network in the sensor, resulting in different electrical signals to distinguish different actions. In addition, the polyurethane molecular chain contains abundant dynamic bonds, so that the flexible sensor has excellent self-healing ability, and still has excellent strain response ability after self-healing. The second type of research is later than the first type, but it has a more significant effect on improving sensitivity[34,49,52,126]. For example, the ionic sensing material developed by us is obtained by blending ionic self-healing polyurethane (i-PU) and ionic liquid, and a small pressure will produce a significant change in capacitance[49]. Therefore, the sensor I-Skin-i prepared with this dielectric layer has excellent sensitivity. Moreover, because the polyurethane as the substrate material contains a large number of ionic bonds, I-Skin-i can self-heal at room temperature, and the sensitivity after self-healing can still be restored to its original state without affecting the subsequent use of the sensor.

4.2 Polyurethane-based electrode material

For flexible sensors, electrode materials for electrical signal transmission by electron migration are an integral part. At present, most of the electrode materials used are rigid metal materials, such as gold, silver, copper, and indium tin oxide (ITO). Although these electrode materials have very low resistance and strong conductivity, they have little stretchability and poor fatigue resistance, and are easy to break and fail after multiple deformations, which seriously hinders their use in the field of flexible sensors. At the same time, this kind of electrode lacks self-healing performance, once damaged, it can not self-heal, affecting the transmission of electrical signals, and ultimately affecting the service life of flexible sensors. The integration of flexible substrate materials and conductive materials has become one of the breakthroughs in the development of flexible conductive electrodes. Self-healing polyurethane has great potential as a flexible electrode substrate material because of its excellent stretchability, fatigue resistance, and self-healing ability (Fig. 13).
图13 (a) 以自愈合聚氨酯为基底制备的柔性电极示意图;(b) 不同应变下的柔性电极;(c) 柔性电极的电学信号[129]

Fig.13 (a) Design of a flexible electrode based of self-healing polyurethane; (b) Flexible electrode under vary strain levels; (c) Analysis of the electrical signal generated by the flexible electrode[129]. Copyright 2019, Willey

Filling nanoscale conductive rigid materials, such as graphene, carbon nanotubes and silver nanowires, into self-healing polyurethane is one of the important strategies for the preparation of stretchable electrodes[122~124,127,128]. The two-dimensional sp2-hybridized carbon structure in graphene can effectively adsorb polymer chains, thereby improving the conductivity and mechanical robustness of the composite. Therefore, a self-healing and stretchable flexible electrode can be obtained by blending graphene with self-healing polyurethane containing oxime-urethane bonds and hydrogen bonds[121]. The obtain flexible conductor can have a tensile strain as high as 1000% (about 6 MPa), yet has a very low resistivity (R=47.8Ω-1). Due to the presence of oxime-urethane bonds and hydrogen bonds in the polyurethane substrate, the prepared flexible electrode can also self-heal at room temperature (10 min, 25 ℃), and the mechanical properties and conductivity can be restored to more than 90% of the original after self-healing.
In addition to the excellent conductivity of rigid materials such as graphene and carbon nanotubes, liquid metal (LM) also has good conductivity. Different from rigid conductive materials, liquid metal (LM) is a special kind of high deformation metal, which exists in liquid form at room temperature and has good fluidity[129,130]. Considering this point, choosing LM and self-healing polyurethane for overcoating or blending is also one of the important strategies to prepare stretchable electrodes. Inspired by this, we used LM as the conductive ink as the inner core and self-healing polyurethane as the outer shell to prepare a stretchable, self-healing and highly conductive flexible electrode based on the core-shell structure[29]. Due to the disulfide bond in the polyurethane, the flexible electrode can self-heal at room temperature, and the resistance can be restored to 7. 6 Ω after self-healing. In addition, LM can also be used as a filler to combine with self-healing polyurethane containing six-fold hydrogen bonds, which will not lose the mechanical properties of polyurethane, nor will it hinder the movement of polyurethane molecular segments in the self-healing process and affect the overall self-healing performance. The prepared conductive film can achieve complete self-healing at 75 ℃ for 10 min[47]. Due to the existence of LM, the resistance of the prepared conductive film is only 1 to 2 ohms, and the conductive film is one of excellent flexible electrode materials.

4.3 Polyurethane-based packaging material

Packaging is an essential part of the sensing element in order to protect it from the environment. Specifically, the encapsulation layer can protect the sensing element from the following aspects: (1) Mechanical protection. The sensing element is generally small and easily damaged by external force, so the packaging layer can provide physical protection for the sensing element as a buffer layer to prevent damage caused by external force; (2) Environmental protection. As mentioned in the above article, sensing elements generally transmit signals through electrons or ions, which are easily disturbed by environmental factors such as external humidity and temperature. If exposed to harsh environment for a long time, the sensing element is prone to failure. Therefore, the packaging layer can provide moisture-proof, dust-proof and other protection for the sensing element to prolong its service life; (3) Electrical protection. In the process of using the sensing element, the external electromagnetic, electrostatic discharge and other factors will destroy the process of signal transmission and affect its normal work. Therefore, the encapsulation layer can provide anti-electromagnetic interference protection for the sensing element and maintain its normal use. In addition, the encapsulation layer also has the advantages of facilitating the installation and use of the sensing element.
At present, the common packaging materials are ceramics, plastics, epoxy resins and elastomers, etc[131~133]. Ceramic is a high strength, high temperature resistant packaging material that protects the sensing element from the effects of temperature. Plastics are used in the packaging of sensing elements because of their excellent mechanical properties and flame retardancy. Epoxy resin has excellent chemical resistance and electrical insulation properties, and is also a good packaging material. However, the mechanical strength of these materials is too large and the ductility is too poor, so they can only be used to package conventional devices, and can not meet the growing demand for flexible sensors[134]. Elastomer materials not only have good high temperature resistance, chemical resistance and electrical insulation, but also have good impact resistance and stretchability, which are most suitable for flexible sensing. Common elastomeric encapsulating materials include polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), polyurethane, and polyolefin thermoplastic elastomer (POE). Among these elastomers, self-healing polyurethane is considered to be one of the most reliable encapsulating materials due to its outstanding combination of properties. On the one hand, the high stretchability of polyurethane allows the flexible sensor to retain its original stretchability after packaging; On the other hand, polyurethane has high resistivity, which can be used as an encapsulation layer to effectively prevent the sensor from losing its sensing performance due to short circuit. More importantly, compared with ordinary polyurethane, the use of self-healing polyurethane as the encapsulation material can also endow the sensor with overall self-healing performance at the same time, thus improving the service life of the sensor (Fig. 14)[35,135 ~137].
图14 (a) 以自愈合聚氨酯为封装层制备传感器的示意图;(b) 封装后传感器的传感性能;(c) 聚氨酯封装层的自愈合性能示意图[138]

Fig.14 (a) Illustration of sensor fabrication using self-healing polyurethane as an encapsulation layer; (b) Sensing performance of the encapsulated sensor; (c) Illustration of self-healing properties of the polyurethane encapsulation layer[138]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society

The self-healing polyurethane can be directly cast in the form of a solution on a sensor containing a 3D binary conductive network of silver nanowires @ sulfated graphene foam (AgNWs @ TGF) to realize the encapsulation of the sensing element[138]. Thanks to the good elasticity of the FPU, the resulting strain transducer exhibits excellent mechanical properties, including good stretchability (up to 60% strain) and 800 cycle fatigue tests. In addition, the strain sensor also exhibits excellent self-healing properties due to the strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding in the packaging material and the dynamic exchange reaction between aromatic disulfides. In addition to the casting method, the mixture of liquid metal and copper powder Cu/GaInSn can also be used as an ink to be printed on the self-healing polyurethane AL-PU containing dynamic disulfide bonds, and then turned over to coat the ink on the dielectric layer AL-PU[30]. Due to the excellent mechanical properties of AL-PU, the flexible sensor E-Skin packaged with it also retains its excellent mechanical properties, not only the tensile strain can be as high as 800%, but also the modulus does not decrease significantly after 1000 repetitions at 100% strain, showing excellent fatigue resistance. Moreover, thanks to the dynamic disulfide bond in AL-PU, the damaged encapsulation layer can recover its original mechanical properties after 300 min of self-healing at room temperature, preventing the external environment from interfering with it. In addition, the flexible sensor encapsulated with pure liquid metal and self-healing polyurethane BS-PU containing disulfide bonds also has good stretchability and self-healing performance while retaining excellent sensing performance[29].

5 Conclusion and prospect

In conclusion, the introduction of reversible covalent bonds (such as DA reaction, disulfide bonds, etc.) Or dynamic non-covalent interactions (such as hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, etc.) Into the polyurethane chain segment can endow the polyurethane with spontaneous healing properties after damage. The main factors to evaluate the self-healing performance are self-healing temperature, self-healing speed and mechanical property recovery rate. The self-healing performance of the self-healing polyurethane containing reversible covalent bonds is not easily interfered by the external environment and other filling substances. However, the energy of reversible covalent bonds is usually relatively low, resulting in slow self-healing, and most of the self-healing bonds can only maintain the original mechanical properties of polyurethane and can not be further improved. The introduction of dynamic non-covalent interactions into self-healing polyurethanes can effectively resolve this contradiction. The only fly in the ointment is that the non-covalent dynamic interaction is easily disturbed by the external environment. In order to obtain polyurethane with good mechanical properties and high healing efficiency, both covalent bonds and non-covalent interactions can be introduced into the molecular structure design of polyurethane.
Although self-healing polyurethanes have good mechanical properties and excellent self-healing properties, their range of use is still limited. First of all, in the field of smart home, polyurethane can be endowed with certain shape memory properties to meet the application needs in this field. At the same time, the self-healing polyurethane containing biodegradable groups can be used in packaging and other fields. In addition, self-healing polyurethanes with antibacterial functional groups or mixed with antibacterial particles have both self-healing and antibacterial properties, and have great application prospects in the fields of health care, textile industry and food packaging. In addition to the above application ranges, the self-healing polyurethane with biocompatibility can be used to replace the current medical materials and the like to reduce the discomfort of the human body. More importantly, self-healing polyurethane is an excellent flexible substrate material, which can be blended with conductive particles or ionic liquids to prepare sensors.It can also be combined with liquid metal to prepare highly stretchable and low-resistance flexible electrodes, and can also be used as an external packaging layer of a flexible sensor to protect the sensor from interference from the external environment.
However, although a variety of self-healing polyurethanes based on different self-healing mechanisms have been developed and proved to have broad application prospects, there are still some unsolved problems. First of all, it is difficult to provide a stable heat supply for self-healing polyurethane to promote its self-healing in general application scenarios, so it is very necessary to develop self-healing polyurethane at room temperature. However, the self-healing property at room temperature means that its molecular chain will also undergo significant creep at room temperature, and its mechanical properties will be reduced accordingly, thus limiting the application of polyurethane. Secondly, the self-healing process of self-healing polyurethane in the current study occurs in the case of very fine scratches, without considering whether the material still has excellent self-healing performance when the scratches are too wide in the actual situation. Then, for the self-healing process of self-healing polyurethane, only the special damage process of scratch is considered, and whether it still has excellent self-healing performance in the face of more complex damage in the actual use process is not considered. Finally, only a few studies have considered the self-healing properties of self-healing polyurethanes in the face of some extreme environments. Therefore, in the face of these problems, the author puts forward some future prospects for the work of self-healing polyurethane. (1) adjusting the density of the self-healing driving force in the molecular chain segment of the self-healing polyurethane to balance self-healing efficiency and mechanical properties; (2) considering the effective combination of the self-healing property and the shape memory property, when the polyurethane produces a wide scratch, the shape memory generates a driving force to drive the polyurethane to contact with each other, so as to realize self-healing; (3) The self-healing characterization should not only be limited to the process of scratch disappearance, but also introduce other damages to observe the self-healing effect of polyurethane; (4) By optimizing the type and location of the self-healing driving force in the self-healing polyurethane molecular chain, a polyurethane that can self-heal in extreme environments is developed.
In a word, self-healing polyurethane is a material with great potential in life, medical treatment and national defense. Overcoming the above problems can promote the application of self-healing polyurethane in a wide range, thus really prolonging the life of materials and reducing pollution.
[1]
Zhang L S, Huang M M, Yu R L, Huang J C, Dong X, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2014, 2(29): 11490.

[2]
Zhang L S, Shams S S, Wei Y P, Liu X Q, Ma S Q, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2014, 2(47): 20010.

[3]
Dong F, Maganty S, Meschter S J, Cho J. Prog. Org. Coat., 2018, 114: 58.

[4]
Zka B, Qiang T C, Rz A, Jy B, Lei S A, Wu B, Han H A, Cy A, Kai W A, Jin Z A. Polymer., 2019, 185: 121943.

[5]
Wang S H, Oh J Y, Xu J, Tran H, Bao Z N. Acc. Chem. Res., 2018, 51(5): 1033.

[6]
Wang X, Liu Y, Cheng H, Ouyang X. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(27): 2200260.

[7]
Sui G P, Liu D Y, Liu Y H, Ji W J, Zhang Q, Fu Q. Polymer, 2019, 182: 121838.

[8]
Li Z L, Zhu M M, Shen J L, Qiu Q, Yu J Y, Ding B. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2020, 30(6): 1908411.

[9]
Kumar S, Gupta T K, Varadarajan K M. Compos. B Eng., 2019, 177: 107285.

[10]
Cai W, Hu Y X, Pan Y, Zhou X, Chu F K, Han L F, Mu X W, Zhuang Z Y, Wang X, Xing W Y. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 2020, 561: 32.

[11]
Patrick J F, Robb M J, Sottos N R, Moore J S. Nature, 2016, 540: 363.

[12]
Zhu D Y, Rong M Z, Zhang M Q. Prog. Polym. Sci., 2015, 49: 175.

[13]
Urban M W. Prog. Polym. Sci., 2009, 34(8): 679.

[14]
Toohey K S, Sottos N R, White S R. Exp. Mech., 2009, 49(5): 707.

[15]
Nji J, Li G. Polymer, 2010, 51(25): 6021.

[16]
Toohey K S, Sottos N R, Lewis J A, Moore J S, White S R. Nat. Mater., 2007, 6(8): 581.

[17]
Jones N, Guoqiang L. Smart Mater. Struct., 2012, 21: 025011.

[18]
Deeken J S, Farona M F. Polym. Bull., 1992, 29(3/4): 295.

[19]
Rivero G, Nguyen L T T, Hillewaere X K D, Du Prez F E. Macromolecules, 2014, 47(6): 2010.

[20]
Truong T T, Thai S H, Nguyen H T, Phung D T T, Nguyen L T, Pham H Q, Nguyen L T T. Chem. Mater., 2019, 31(7): 2347.

[21]
Tiwari N, Ho F, Ankit A, Mathews N. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2018, 6(43): 21428.

[22]
Feng L B, Yu Z Y, Bian Y H, Lu J S, Shi X T, Chai C S. Polymer, 2017, 124: 48.

[23]
Postiglione G, Turri S, Levi M. Prog. Org. Coat., 2015, 78: 526.

[24]
Wang T, Yu W C, Zhou C G, Sun W J, Zhang Y P, Jia L C, Gao J F, Dai K, Yan D X, Li Z M. Compos. B Eng., 2020, 193: 108015.

[25]
Fildes F J T, Tobolsky A V. J. Polym. Sci. A-1 Polym. Chem., 1972, 10(1): 151.

[26]
Canadell J, Goossens H, Klumperman B. Macromolecules, 2011, 44(8): 2536.

[27]
Kim S M, Jeon H, Shin S H, Park S A, Jegal J, Hwang S Y, Oh D X, Park J. Adv. Mater., 2018, 30(1): 1705145.

[28]
Lai Y, Kuang X, Zhu P, Huang M M, Dong X, Wang D J. Adv. Mater., 2018, 30(38): 1802556.

[29]
Ying W B, Yu Z, Kim D H, Lee K J, Hu H, Liu Y W, Kong Z Y, Wang K, Shang J, Zhang R Y, Zhu J, Li R W. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(9): 11072.

[30]
Li F L, Xu Z F, Hu H, Kong Z Y, Chen C, Tian Y, Zhang W W, Ying W B, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 410: 128363.

[31]
Liu Q, Liu Y B, Zheng H, Li C M, Zhang Y, Zhang Q Y. J. Polym. Sci., 2020, 58(8): 1092.

[32]
Gao W T, Bie M Y, Quan Y W, Zhu J Y, Zhang W Q. Polymer, 2018, 151: 27.

[33]
Dong F H, Yang X X, Guo L Z, Wang Y Q, Shaghaleh H, Huang Z, Xu X, Wang S F, Liu H. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2022, 10(18): 10139.

[34]
Xu J H, Wang H, Du X S, Cheng X, Du Z L, Wang H B. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 426: 130724.

[35]
Ying W B, Liu H X, Gao P Y, Kong Z Y, Hu H, Wang K, Shen A, Jin Z J, Zheng L, Guo H X, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 420: 127691.

[36]
Xia J H, Li T Y, Lu C J, Xu H P. Macromolecules, 2018, 51(19): 7435.

[37]
Utrera-Barrios S, Verdejo R, LÓpez-Manchado M A, Hernández Santana M. Mater. Horiz., 2020, 7(11): 2882.

[38]
Zeng Y, Chen Y Z, Sha D, Wu Y C, Qiu R H, Liu W D. ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng., 2022, 10(35): 11524.

[39]
Tan M W M, Thangavel G, Lee P S. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2021, 31(34): 2103097.

[40]
Zhu X B, Zheng W R, Zhao H C, Wang L P. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2021, 9(36): 20737.

[41]
Wang J P, Fu C H, Wu Z H, Lan H, Cui S W, Qi T. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2022, 10(39): 21093.

[42]
Song Y, Liu Y, Qi T, Li G L. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2018, 57(42): 13838.

[43]
Zhao D, Zhu Y, Cheng W, Chen W, Wu Y, Yu H. Adv. Mater., 2021, 33(28): e2000619.

[44]
Tu H, Zhu M, Duan B, Zhang L. Adv. Mater., 2021, 33(28): e2000682.

[45]
Chan N J A, Gu D Y, Tan S, Fu Q, Pattison T G, O’Connor A J, Qiao G G. Nat. Commun., 2020, 11: 1630.

[46]
Li Z Q, Zhu Y L, Niu W W, Yang X, Jiang Z Y, Lu Z Y, Liu X K, Sun J Q. Adv. Mater., 2021, 33(27): 2101498.

[47]
Zhang E D, Liu X H, Liu Y C, Shi J, Li X B, Xiong X Y, Xu C G, Wu K, Lu M G. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2021, 9(40): 23055.

[48]
Yao Y, Liu B, Xu Z Y, Yang J H, Liu W G. Mater. Horiz., 2021, 8(10): 2742.

[49]
Chen C, Ying W B, Li J Y, Kong Z Y, Li F L, Hu H, Tian Y, Kim D H, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(4): 2106341.

[50]
Mostafavi A, Daemi H, Rajabi S, Baharvand H. Carbohydr. Polym., 2021, 257: 117632.

[51]
Cheng Y, Zhu W D, Lu X F, Wang C. Nano Energy, 2022, 102: 107636.

[52]
Boahen E K, Pan B H, Kweon H, Kim J S, Choi H, Kong Z Y, Kim D J, Zhu J, Ying W B, Lee K J, Kim D H. Nat. Commun., 2022, 13: 7699.

[53]
Yu Z C, Wu P Y. Mater. Horiz., 2021, 8(7): 2057.

[54]
Kim H J, Chen B H, Suo Z G, Hayward R C. Science, 2020, 367(6479): 773.

[55]
Duan N, Sun Z, Ren Y Y, Liu Z Y, Liu L L, Yan F. Polym. Chem., 2020, 11(4): 867.

[56]
Chen S J, Mo F N, Yang Y, Stadler F J, Chen S G, Yang H P, Ge Z C. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2015, 3(6): 2924.

[57]
Pan G F, Wang Z, Gong X B, Wang Y F, Ge X, Xing R G. Chem. Eng. J., 2022, 446: 137228.

[58]
Lai J C, Jia X Y, Wang D P, Deng Y B, Zheng P, Li C H, Zuo J L, Bao Z N. Nat. Commun., 2019, 10: 1164.

[59]
Li C H, Zuo J L. Adv. Mater., 2020, 32(27): e1903762.

[60]
Wang Z H, Xie C, Yu C J, Fei G X, Wang Z H, Xia H S. Macromol. Rapid Commun., 2018, 39(6): 1700678.

[61]
Xu H L, Zhao S W, Yuan A Q, Zhao Y L, Wu X D, Wei Z K, Lei J X, Jiang L. Small, 2023, 19(26): 2300626.

[62]
Teng J W, Qu L, Liu Z Q, Qin Z H, Xu J, Wang Z N, Hou Z S. ACS Appl. Polym. Mater., 2022, 4(10): 7801.

[63]
Ikkanda B A, Iverson B L. Chem. Commun., 2016, 52(50): 7752.

[64]
Li Z Y, Davidson-Rozenfeld G, Vázquez-González M, Fadeev M, Zhang J J, Tian H, Willner I. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2018, 140(50): 17691.

[65]
Wang C, Fadeev M, Vázquez-González M, Willner I. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2018, 28(35): 1803111.

[66]
Pramanik B, Ahmed S, Singha N, Das B K, Dowari P, Das D. Langmuir, 2019, 35(2): 478.

[67]
Ying wu bin, Wang G Y, Kong Z Y, Yao C K, Wang Y B, Hu H, Li F L, Chen C, Tian Y, Zhang J W, Zhang R Y, Zhu J. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2021, 31(10): 2009869.

[68]
Cao Y, Tan yu jun, Li S, Lee W W, Guo H C, Cai Y Q, Wang C, Tee B C K. Nat. Electron., 2019, 2(2): 75.

[69]
Xu J, Wang X, Zhang X, Zhang Y, Yang Z, Li S, Tao L, Wang Q, Wang T. Chem. Eng. J., 2023, 451: 138673.

[70]
Liu X J, Liu X, Li W J, Ru Y, Li Y H, Sun A L, Wei L H. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 410: 128300.

[71]
Yang X X, Wang S B, Liu X X, Huang Z, Huang X J, Xu X, Liu H, Wang D, Shang S B. Green Chem., 2021, 23(17): 6349.

[72]
Zhang L Z, Liu Z H, Wu X L, Guan Q B, Chen S, Sun L J, Guo Y F, Wang S L, Song J C, Jeffries E M, He C L, Qing F L, Bao X G, You Z W. Adv. Mater., 2019, 31(23): 1901402.

[73]
Wang L, Yang K, Li X Z, Zhang X H, Zhang D W, Wang L N, Lee C S. Acta Biomater., 2021, 124: 139.

[74]
Fan W H, Jin Y, Shi L J, Du W N, Zhou R, Lai S Q, Shen Y C, Li Y P. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(5): 6383.

[75]
Shi Z, Kang J, Zhang L. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(20): 23484.

[76]
Ur Rehman H, Chen Y J, Hedenqvist M S, Li H, Xue W C, Guo Y L, Guo Y P, Duan H N, Liu H Z. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2018, 28(7): 1704109.

[77]
Yang H, Leow W R, Wang T, Wang J, Yu J C, He K, Qi D P, Wan C J, Chen X D. Adv. Mater., 2017, 29(33): 1701627.

[78]
Zhang Y, Yin X Y, Zheng M Y, Moorlag C, Yang J, Wang Z L. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2019, 7(12): 6972.

[79]
Wang W, Shen D F, Li X, Yao Y, Lin J P, Wang A, Yu J, Wang Z L, Hong S W, Lin Z Q, Lin S L. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2018, 57(8): 2139.

[80]
Zheng K W, Tian Y Z, Fan M J, Zhang J Y, Cheng J. J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 2018, 135(13): 46049.

[81]
Zhang W W, Leng X F, Gao M Y, Wei Z Y, Wang Y Y, Li Y. Polym. Test., 2021, 96: 107099.

[82]
Menon A V, Madras G, Bose S. Polym. Chem., 2019, 10(32): 4370.

[83]
Wu S D, Hsu S H. Biofabrication, 2021, 13(4): 045029.

[84]
Wang J, Lin X, Wang R, Lu Y, Zhang L. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 33(15): 2211579.

[85]
Worch J C, Dove A P. ACS Macro. Lett., 2020, 9(11): 1494.

[86]
Fortman D J, Brutman J P, de Hoe G X, Snyder R L, Dichtel W R, Hillmyer M A. ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng., 2018, 6(9): 11145.

[87]
Shuai L, Jun Z, Jianjun C, Ming Y, Xuepeng L, Zhiguo J. Polym. Eng. Sci., 2019, 59(s2): E310.

[88]
Xie F W, Zhang T L, Bryant P, Kurusingal V, Colwell J M, Laycock B. Prog. Polym. Sci., 2019, 90: 211.

[89]
Han J, Chen B, Ye L, Zhang A Y, Zhang J, Feng Z G. Front. Mater. Sci. China, 2009, 3(1): 25.

[90]
Acik G, Karabulut H R F, Altinkok C, Karatavuk A O. Polym. Degrad. Stab., 2019, 165: 43.

[91]
Shaabani A, Sedghi R, Motasadizadeh H, Dinarvand R. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 411: 128449.

[92]
Daemi H, Rajabi-Zeleti S, Sardon H, Barikani M, Khademhosseini A, Baharvand H. Biomaterials, 2016, 84: 54.

[93]
Lin T W, Hsu S H. Adv. Sci., 2020, 7(3): 1901388.

[94]
Dallinger A, Keller K, Fitzek H, Greco F. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(17): 19855.

[95]
Zhang H, Chen G P, Yu Y R, Guo J H, Tan Q, Zhao Y J. Adv. Sci., 2020, 7(16): 2000789.

[96]
Shi C Y, Zhang Q, Yu C Y, Rao S J, Yang S, Tian H, Qu D H. Adv. Mater., 2020, 32(23): 2000345.

[97]
Duan J, Jiang G. Polymers (Basel), 2022, 14(1): 213.

[98]
Xia Q F, Yang L, Hu K, Li K J, Xiang J, Liu G Y, Wang Y B. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2019, 11(2): 2352.

[99]
Xie X L, Sun T C, Xue J Z, Miao Z H, Yan X, Fang W W, Li Q, Tang R P, Lu Y, Tang L X, Zha Z B, He T. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2020, 30(17): 2070106.

[100]
Huang Z X, Nazifi S, Cheng K, Karim A, Ghasemi H. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 422: 130085.

[101]
Ding Y Y, Sun Z, Shi R W, Cui H Q, Liu Y Y, Mao H L, Wang B, Zhu D M, Yan F. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2019, 11(3): 2860.

[102]
Zeng W H, Jin Y, Li Y P, Zhou R, Shi L J, Bai L, Shang X, Li J. Prog. Org. Coat., 2023, 178: 107461.

[103]
Feng H M, Wang W, Wang T, Zhang L, Li W, Hou J, Chen S G. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2023, 133: 89.

[104]
Li Q, Cao L, Wang W, Qin X, Chen S. Composites Part A, 2022, 163: 107213.

[105]
Xu Z Q, Wang X H, Liu X M, Cui Z D, Yang X J, Yeung K W K, Chung J C, Chu P K, Wu S L. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2017, 9(45): 39657.

[106]
Wang H B, Yan R, Zou Y K, Xing D M, Zhong K. J. Mater. Chem. B, 2022, 10(7): 1085.

[107]
Jiang C Y, Zhang L Z, Yang Q, Huang S X, Shi H P, Long Q, Qian B, Liu Z H, Guan Q B, Liu M J, Yang R H, Zhao Q, You Z W, Ye X F. Nat. Commun., 2021, 12: 4395.

[108]
Liu J, Qu M Y, Wang C R, Xue Y M, Huang H, Chen Q M, Sun W J, Zhou X W, Xu G H, Jiang X. Small, 2022, 18(17): e2106172.

[109]
Liang Y P, He J H, Guo B L. ACS Nano, 2021, 15(8): 12687.

[110]
Huang R, Zhang X, Li W, Shang L, Wang H, Zhao Y. Adv. Sci. (Weinh), 2021, 8(17): e2100201.

[111]
Simões D, Miguel S P, Ribeiro M P, Coutinho P, Mendonça A G, Correia I J. Eur. J. Pharm. Biopharm., 2018, 127: 130.

[112]
Tamura K, Maruyama T, Sakurai S. Gen. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 2019, 67(3): 277.

[113]
Shao Y, Dong K Y, Lu X Y, Gao B B, He B F. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2022, 14(51): 56525.

[114]
Gu X X, Gao T T, Meng X P, Zhu Y, Wang G Y. Prog. Org. Coat., 2022, 162: 106561.

[115]
Chen S L, Li S Y, Ye Z P, Zhang Y F, Gao S D, Rong H, Zhang J H, Deng L D, Dong A J. Chem. Eng. J., 2022, 446: 136985.

[116]
Bayan R, Karak N. Composites Part A, 2018, 110: 142.

[117]
Yang G W, He X T, Cheng S, Li X L, Yang S Z, Wei H B, Ding Y S. Appl. Surf. Sci., 2018, 456: 270.

[118]
Fang W Y, Liu L B, Li T, Dang Z, Qiao C D, Xu J K, Wang Y Y. Chem. Eur. J., 2016, 22(3): 878.

[119]
Liu C, Yin Q, Li X, Hao L F, Zhang W B, Bao Y, Ma J Z. Adv. Compos. Hybrid. Mater., 2021, 4(1): 138.

[120]
Yao Y, Xu Z, Liu B, Xiao M, Yang J, Liu W. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2020, 31(4): 2006944.

[121]
Gao H, Xu J N, Liu S, Song Z Q, Zhou M, Liu S W, Li F, Li F H, Wang X D, Wang Z X, Zhang Q X. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 2021, 597: 393.

[122]
Pu W L, Fu D H, Wang Z H, Gan X P, Lu X L, Yang L, Xia H S. Adv. Sci., 2018, 5(5): 1800101.

[123]
Xu K M, Chen G Q, Zhao M J, He W Y, Hu Q M, Pu Y. RSC Adv., 2022, 12(5): 2712.

[124]
Yang Y, Ye Z S, Liu X X, Su J H. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2020, 8(15): 5280.

[125]
Wen X, Xu J H, Wang H B, Du Z L, Wang S, Cheng X. Polym. Eng. Sci., 2022, 62(10): 3132.

[126]
Xun X C, Zhang Z, Zhao X, Zhao B, Gao F F, Kang Z, Liao Q L, Zhang Y. ACS Nano, 2020, 14(7): 9066.

[127]
Zhang E D, Shi J, Xiao L Q, Zhang Q, Lu M P, Nan B F, Wu K, Lu M G. Polym. Chem., 2021, 12(6): 831.

[128]
Dong F H, Yang X X, Guo L Z, Qian Y H, Sun P H, Huang Z, Xu X, Liu H. J. Colloid Interface Sci., 2023, 631: 239.

[129]
Park S, Thangavel G, Parida K, Li S H, Lee P S. Adv. Mater., 2019, 31(1): 1805536.

[130]
Lou Y, Liu H Z, Zhang J Y. Chem. Eng. J., 2020, 399: 125732.

[131]
(张广伟, 张来斌, 樊建春, 孙秉才, 齐立娟, 赵坤鹏, 张仁庆. 无损检测, 2013, 35(1): 56.

( Zhang G W, Zhang L B, Fan J C, Sun B C, Qi L J, Zhao S P, Zhang R Q. Nondestructive Testing, 2013, 35(1): 56.).

[132]
Zhou G P. Piezoelectrics Acoustooptics, 2010, 32(4):534.

(周国鹏. 压电与声光, 2010, 32(4):534.).

[133]
任越, 张钰民, 钟国舜, 宋言明, 孟凡勇. 激光与红外, 2020, 50(5): 598.

(Ren Y, Zhang Y M, Zhong G S, Song Y M, Meng F Y. Laser Infrared, 2020, 50(5): 598.).

[134]
Song H L, Luo G Q, Ji Z Y, Bo R H, Xue Z G, Yan D J, Zhang F, Bai K, Liu J X, Cheng X, Pang W B, Shen Z M, Zhang Y H. Sci. Adv., 2022, 8(11): eabm3785.

[135]
Gao Z Y, Lou Z, Han W, Shen G Z. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(21): 24339.

[136]
Fan C J, Wen Z B, Xu Z Y, Xiao Y, Wu D, Yang K K, Wang Y Z. Macromolecules, 2020, 53(11): 4284.

[137]
Tian Q, Yan W R, Li Y Q, Ho D. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(8): 9710.

[138]
Zhang L, Li H Q, Lai X J, Gao T Y, Zeng X R. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2020, 12(39): 44360.

Outlines

/