Potential Health Risks Associated with Biodegradable Plastics and Future Research Prospects: A Focus on Biodegradable Microplastics
Received date: 2024-09-12
Revised date: 2024-11-19
Online published: 2025-01-20
Supported by
National Natural Science Foundation of China(22276073)
National Natural Science Foundation of China(22376032)
Joint Fund of Colleges and Departments of Southeast University(2242024K40045)
Research Start-up Fund for New Faculty of Southeast University(RF1028623238)
Zhishan Young Scholar Fund of Southeast University by the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities(2242024RCB0027)
The global concern over white pollution and microplastic contamination caused by traditional non-degradable plastic waste has garnered widespread attention. Promoting biodegradable plastics (BPs) as alternatives to non-degradable plastics is a strategic approach to mitigating these forms of plastic pollution. However, under real-world environmental conditions, BPs often face challenges in achieving rapid degradation and may release significant quantities of biodegradable microplastics (BMPs) during the degradation process, posing potential environmental and health risks. In this review, we critically examine the environmental risks associated with traditional non-degradable plastic waste and the use of BPs. We systematically evaluate current pre-treatment techniques, analytical methods, and occurrence patterns of BMPs in environmental and biological samples. Furthermore, we highlight recent advancements in understanding the potential impacts of BMPs on organisms across various trophic levels, including human health. Finally, we address the challenges in applying BPs, particularly in identifying, analyzing, assessing health impacts, and developing future regulatory standards and measures for BMPs. This review provides theoretical foundations and technical guidance for advancing environmentally friendly and safe BPs.
1 Introduction
1.1 The importance of plastics in modern human social life and production
1.2 Ecological and environmental risks associated with the use of traditional refractory plastics
1.3 Production, application status, and potential risks of emerging degradable plastics
2 Analytical methods and environmental occurrence of degradable plastics
2.1 Methods for analyzing biodegradable microplastics
2.2 Environmental occurrence of degradable plastics
3 Research progress on potential environmental and health risks of biodegradable plastics
3.1 Potential ecological and environmental risks of degradable plastics
3.2 Potential health risks of biodegradable plastics
4 Conclusion and outlook
4.1 Insufficient public awareness of BPs and BMPs
4.2 Suitable for BMPs extraction and detection method vacancy
4.3 The long-term migration and transformation of BMPs in vivo and its health risks need to be clarified
4.4 Bioplastics and BMPs management and control methods and governance standards are missing
Yongfeng Deng , Ailin Zhao , Changzhi Shi , Ao Guo , Ruqin Shen , Mingliang Fang . Potential Health Risks Associated with Biodegradable Plastics and Future Research Prospects: A Focus on Biodegradable Microplastics[J]. Progress in Chemistry, 2025 , 37(1) : 59 -75 . DOI: 10.7536/PC240904
Table 1 The share of plastic production by type and industrial use sector calculated from the data of Europe, the United States, China and India from 2002 to 2014[6]Table 1 Share of plastic production by type and industrial use sector, calculated from data for Europe, the United States, China, and India covering the period 2002—2014[6] |
Total | Other | PUR | PET | PVC | PS | PP | HDPE | LDPE,LLDPE | Market sector |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6.70% | 1.40% | 1.60% | 0.00% | 0.30% | 0.00% | 2.60% | 0.80% | 0.10% | Transportation |
44.80% | 0.10% | 0.20% | 10.10% | 0.90% | 2.30% | 8.20% | 9.30% | 13.50% | Packaging |
18.80% | 0.50% | 2.40% | 0.00% | 8.10% | 2.20% | 1.20% | 3.30% | 1.10% | Building |
3.80% | 1.00% | 0.40% | 0.00% | 0.40% | 0.60% | 0.90% | 0.20% | 0.50% | Electronic |
11.90% | 0.20% | 1.00% | 0.00% | 0.60% | 1.80% | 3.80% | 1.70% | 2.90% | Consumer products |
0.80% | 0.00% | 0.30% | 0.00% | 0.00% | 0.00% | 0.20% | 0.10% | 0.20% | Industrial machinery |
13.20% | 1.70% | 2.50% | 0.00% | 1.40% | 0.70% | 4.20% | 0.90% | 1.70% | Other |
100.00% | 4.90% | 8.20% | 10.20% | 11.80% | 7.60% | 21.00% | 16.30% | 20.00% | Total |
Table 2 Separation and purification of microplastics (MPS) from environmental samples[31]Table 2 Methods for separating and purifying microplastics (MPs) in environmental samples[31] |
Purification/Separation | Applicable media | Limitations |
---|---|---|
Manual extraction* | Sediments,wastewater,atmospheric fallout | 1~5 mm |
Acidic and alkaline digestion | Sediments,Biological tissues | 10~500 μm |
Oxidization with hydrogen peroxide* | Sediments,Biological tissues | 1 mm |
Enzymatic digestion* | Biological tissues | 10~500 μm |
Density separation* | Sediments,Soil samples,Biological samples after digestion | <1 mm~2.5 cm |
AF4* | Soil samples,Biological samples after digestion | 1~1000 nm |
HT-GPC | Personal-care products | 0.1%~3%w/w |
Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC)* | Biological tissues | ≤100 nm |
Electrostatic separation* | Quartz sand,freshwater, suspended particulate matter, sediments, beach sand | 0.063~5 mm |
Magnetic extraction* | Seawater | 200 μm~1 mm |
* implies that the method is applicable to degradable microplastics (BMPs) as well. |
Table 3 Comparison of detection methods for degradable microplastics in aquatic environment (MPS)[54]Table 3 Comparison of methods for the detection of biodegradable microplastics (BMPs) in aquatic environments[54] |
Methods | Size | Identification | Characteristic fragment ions | LOQ (ng/g) | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pyr-GC/MS | >1 μm | PLA | 2,3-pentadione; meso-lactide (3,6-dimethyl-1,4-dioxane-2,5-dion); DL-lactide (3,6-dimethyl-1,4-dioxane-2,5-dion); methyl 2-hydroxypropanoate; methyl 2-methoxypropanoate | 50 | Destructive method; Particle size distribution and shape cannot be obtained |
PCL | ε-caprolactone; dimer of ε-caprolactone; trimer of ε-caprolactone; pentyl pent-4-enoate; 5-oxo-5-(pentyloxy)pentyl pent-4-enoate; 5-hexenoic acid; 6-(5-hexenoyloxy)hexanoic acid; methyl 6-methoxyhexanoate | 30 | |||
PBS | tetrahydrofuran; 1,4-butanediol; 3-dibutenyl succinate; 3-butenyl-4-hydroxybutyl succinate; bis(4-hydroxybutyl) succinate; dibut-3-enyl-butane-1,4-diyl disuccinate; dimethyl succinate; butylene glycol methyl ether | 40 | |||
PBAT | tetrahydrofuran; cyclopentanone; benzoic acid; 3-butenyl 4-hydroxybutyl adipate; 2-((but-3-enyloxy)carbonyl)benzoic acid; dimethyl terephthalate; dimethyl hexanedioate | 30 | |||
PHAs | 2-butenoic acid (cis); 2-butenoic acid (trans); 1H-indene,1-chloro-2,3-dihydromethyl 2-butenoate (cis); methyl 2-butenoate (trans) | 20 | |||
LC-MS/MS | 0.075,0.15, and 2 mm | PLA | lactic acid | 18.7 | Simultaneous detection is not possible |
TED-GC/MS | >1 μm | PLA | propanoic acid propenoic acid 3,6-dimethyl-1,4-dioxan-2,5-dione | / | Not applicable to complex organic systems |
PBAT | terephthalic acid dibut-3-enyl ester adipic acid dibut-3-enyl ester 1,6-dioxacyclododecane-7,12-dione |
Table 4 Toxic effects of degradable plastics on organisms at all levels of ecosystemTable 4 Toxic effects of biodegradable plastics on organisms at all levels of the ecosystem |
Test species | type | MPs type and concentration | research objective | size | Exposure mode | Exposure period | Toxic effects | reference literature |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aquatic plants | chlorella pacifica | 10. MPE, MPa, MPLA and mPBS at 100 and 1000 mg/l | Effects of BMPs on Phytoplankton | PE(77.75 µm) PA(59.88 µm) PLA(57.41 µm); PBS(53.33 µm) | Water source exposure | 1~11 d | Growth was inhibited; Stimulating chlorophyll content to prevent stress; EPS generation increase | 63 |
Microcystis | 10. 50 and 200 mg/l PLA | Effects of BMPs on Phytoplankton | 0.5~100 μm | Water source exposure | 63 d | Cause oxidative damage, cell deformation, inhibit first and then promote growth | 64 | |
Heterotrophic cyanobacteria and chlorella | 20 g PCL particles were degraded in 200 ml PBS for 14 days, and the supernatant was obtained by fractional filtration | Toxicity difference of PCL with different sizes | PCL submicron (1 μm~100 nm), Nanometer Grade (<100 nm), oligomer (<50 kDa) | Water source exposure | 3 d | Excessive production of ROS, changes in intracellular pH and metabolic activity, and membrane potential and morphology damage inhibit the nitrogen fixation of algae | 65 | |
Brown algae | 0.01, 0.1, 1 mg/ml PCL or OCL | Comparison of toxicity differences between PCL and oligomer | -- | Water source exposure | 24 h | Plasma membrane damage and energy metabolism disorder in OCL exposed group | 66 | |
Terrestrial plant | rice | 1% PBAT or PE | Effects of microplastics on crops | 50 μm | Soil exposure | 60 d or 120 d | The growth of rice plants was affected by nitrogen metabolism and photosynthesis. After treatment, the net photosynthetic rate of rice shoots was significantly inhibited, and the gene expression was reduced | 68 |
Sorghum, cress, mustard, corn | 0.02, 0.095, 0.48, 2.38 and 11.9% w/W PLA, PHB and PP were added to the soil | Effects of BMPs on Germination and early growth of higher plants | 3~5 mm | Soil exposure | 72 h | PLA and PHB were inhibited earlier than PP Stage root growth | 80 | |
soybean | Adding 0%, 0.1%, 0.5% and 1% w/w PE or degradable plastic film (PLA or PBAT) to soil | Effects of different mulching films on Seed Germination and plant growth of soybean | 0.5、1、2 cm2 | Soil exposure | 60 d or 120 d | Seed germination rate and leaf area decreased | 82 | |
wheat | 10~100 mg/kg PS and degradable film fragments | Effects of multiple MPs interactions on plant growth | 5 μ m or 70 nm | Soil exposure | 14 d | Reduce plant height, especially when combined with PS | 83 | |
Aquatic animals | Daphnia magna | 1. 5 mg/l PLA or pet | Acute and chronic toxicity of BMPs | 1~80 μm | Water source exposure | 21 d | Survival rate decreased, offspring decreased, sex ratio changed and abnormal embryos increased | 67 |
Sea urchin | 1. 5 and 10 mg/l PBS PBSA、PCL、PHB、PLA | Effects of BPS on marine invertebrates | PBS(193.10 ± 148.40 μm) PBSA(207.70 ± 131.40 μm) PCL(164.90 ± 99.20 μm) PHB(0.64 ± 0.30 μm) PLA(335.00 ± 182.01 μm) | Water source exposure | 48 h | PCL, PHB and PLA MPs affect embryonic development; PHB and PLA destroy the first mitosis of eggs and lead to developmental retardation of other eggs; PCL causes embryonic malformation | 68 | |
Zebrafish | 3、9 mg/L PLA MPs | Toxicity of PLA on early development of zebrafish | 150 μm | Water source exposure | 5 d | The larvae 'swimming distance and speed led to anxiety like behavior and decreased acetylcholinesterase activity | 69 | |
Zebrafish | 1. 25, 50, 100, 250 and 500 mg/l PGA and PLA granular solutions | Effects on development and neurobehavior | 667.5~4213.5 nm | Water source exposure | 96 h | It leads to developmental retardation of early larvae, reduces survival rate, destroys movement, affects sleep/wake behavior, and induces anxiety like behavior | 70 | |
Zebrafish | 1. 25, 50, 100, 250 and 500 mg/l PGA and PLA granular solutions | Effects on development and neurobehavior | 667.5~4213.5 nm | Water source exposure | 96 h | It leads to developmental retardation of early larvae, reduces survival rate, destroys movement, affects sleep/wake behavior, and induces anxiety like behavior | ||
European perch | PLA 2%(w:w) | Behavioral toxicity of BPS | 90~150 μm | Dietary exposure | 180 d | The visual response to the same species was enhanced, the motor ability was decreased, the internal gathering distance was reduced, and the active predator response was weakened | 72 | |
Zebrafish | 1 mg/l and 100 mg/l PGA, PLA, PBS, PHA and PBAT | Effects of BPS on eye development and visual function | -- | Water source exposure | 5 d | Influence on early development of zebrafish juveniles and gene changes related to visual development | 73 | |
Zebrafish | 1000 grains/l PLA or pet | Toxicity of chronic exposure to BPS | PET(204 ± 51 µm); PLA(222 ± 58 µm) | Dietary exposure | 90 d | PLA accumulated more in intestine; Lactic acid utilization capacity was enhanced; Significant intestinal injury | 75 | |
Tilapia | 100 μg/L PLA Or PVC | Intestinal toxicity of BPS | PLA (2.52 ± 0.46 μ m) and PVC (1.58 ± 0.36 μ m) | Water source exposure | 14 d | Intestinal tissue was severely damaged, including edema of intestinal mucosal epithelial cells, swelling of mitochondria, extensive dissolution of some epithelial cell matrix, release of organelles, expansion of intercellular space and damage of intestinal barrier | 76 | |
Daphnia magna | 1 μ g/ml or 1 ng/ml PCL or OCL | Comparison of toxicity differences between PCL and oligomer | -- | Water source exposure | 21 d | The total number of offspring in OCL exposed group decreased | 66 | |
Zebrafish | 0.1, 1, 10, 25 mg/l PLA | Toxic effect of photoaging on BPS | 5~50 μm | Water source exposure | 7 d | The bioaccumulation ability of photodegradable PLA increased; Inhibition of bone development, apoptosis, fission inhibition, depolymerization and mitochondrial structural damage | 107 | |
Barramundi | PLA and PBAT mixture 20 capsules/D; The control is PE plastic | Gastrointestinal toxicity of dietary intake of BPS | 3.06 ± 0.26 mm | Dietary exposure | 21 d | Inducing intestinal microbial diversity Sexual and protein changes; There is no difference in the effect of different micro plastics | 108 | |
Zebrafish | 2.5 and 5 mg/l PLA | Multi endpoint toxicity | 2.34 ± 0.07 μm | Water source exposure | 30 d | Acetylcholinesterase activity increased; Oxidation reduction system imbalance | 88 | |
Zebrafish | 60 mg/ml or granular leaching solution | Toxicity of PCL and its extract | -- | Water source exposure | 3 D or 24 h | Consumer grade PCL has acute toxicity to zebrafish embryos, and polymer decomposition products may be the source of toxicity | 102 | |
Terrestrial animals | earthworm | 0, 0.125, 1.25, 12.5, 125, 250 and 500 g/kg PLA, PPC and PE | Toxicity difference of degradable and non degradable plastics to earthworms | 120 μm | Soil exposure | 7, 14, 21, 28 d | Significantly reduced the survival rate of earthworms | 85 |
earthworm | 5. 20 and 50 g/kg (wet weight of soil) PLA, PVC and LDPE | Effects of BMPs on terrestrial organisms | 0.8~1 mm | Soil exposure | 7、4、 28 d | Mucous vacuole formation and longitudinal muscle disorder, PLA is not safer than traditional plastics | 86 | |
drosophila | 25, 100 and 400 μ g/ml PLA | Effects of PLA NPs on Drosophila melanogaster | 463.9 ± 129.4 nm | Instant medium wetting method | 4 d | Oxidative stress and possible DNA damage | 87 | |
Dragonfly larvae | 6 mg/l PLA or PE | Toxicity of traditional and bioplastics to model organisms | 35.46 ± 18.17 μm | Water source exposure | 48 h | The levels of nitrite and lipid peroxidation increased; The decrease of superoxide dismutase activity and total mercaptan level; Decreased AChE activity | 88 | |
mice | 0.1, 0.5 mg/day PLA or PVC | Toxic effects of different MPs on mice | PLA(16~350 μm);PVC(40~300 μm) | Gavage | 42 d | Weight gain inhibition; Compared with PVC, PLA MPs had greater effects on lipid metabolism and digestive system | 94 | |
mice | 5、50 mg/kg | Hepatotoxicity of PLA | -- | Gavage | 10 d | Weight loss, reduced food intake, impaired liver function, increased liver inflammation, changes in bile acid profile, and dysregulation of bile acid metabolic pathways | 95 | |
mice | 0.2 mg/day PLA NPs or MPs; 0.03 mg/day PLA NPs or MPS | Hepatotoxicity induced by PLA from different exposure sources | PLA NP(50 nm) And MP (5 μ m) | Intragastric or nasal administration | 42 d | Food borne and air exposure to PLA lead to imbalance of intestinal and pulmonary non biota, metabolic and transcriptional disorders, respectively, and induce hepatotoxicity through enterobacteria gut liver axis and airway bacteria lung liver axis | 96 | |
mice | 0.01, 0.1, 1 mg/day PLA MPS or oligomers | Toxicity of PLA and degradation products | PLA MPs(25 μm); Oligomer (molecular weight 900 DA) | Gavage | 7 d | PLA is degraded to oligomer under the catalysis of gastrointestinal esterase, inducing intestinal injury and acute inflammation | 19 | |
mice | 2.5, 25 mg/kg polymer PLA or oligomer PLA | ADME and neurotoxicity of PLA and oligomers | PLA polymer (40 kDa); PLA oligomer (2 kDa) | Gavage | 28 d | PLA and oligomers induce Parkinson's disease like neurotoxicity, and the mechanism involves the up regulation of midbrain micu3, leading to neuronal mitochondrial calcium overload | 97 |
Table 5 Evaluation of toxic effects of degradable plastics by in vitro modelTable 5 Evaluation of toxic effects of biodegradable plastics in vitro |
In vitro model | Exposure type and concentration | research objective | MPs size | Exposure mode | Exposure time | research conclusion | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Caco-2 and HT29 cell lines | 0, 50 and 100 µ g/ml PLA | Fate of nanoparticles released from tea bags in gastrointestinal tract | 100 nm | Medium exposure | 48 h or 72 h | Internalize intestinal cells (such as intestinal cells and goblet cells), cross the protective mucus layer and epithelial barrier in the intestine, and destroy the barrier | 99 |
Calu-3 cell line | 2.5, 10 and 20 µ g/cm2 | Respiratory toxicity of PLA NPS | 130.06 nm | Gas liquid interface exposure | 24 h; 7 d or 14 d | The barrier permeability and mucus secretion increased; Long term exposure leads to significant genotoxicity and immune response | 100 |
J774A.1 cell line | 10 μ g/ml PLA or PS | Response of macrophages to PLA NPS | 150 nm | Medium exposure | 24 h | Phagocytic activity of macrophages decreased and secretion of proinflammatory cytokines increased | 101 |
RAW 264.7 | 800 ng/ml~0.5 mg/ml PLA MPs, NPs or oligomers | Pro inflammatory effect of PLA and oligomer | PLA MPs(25 μm); Oligomer (molecular weight 900 Da) | Medium exposure | 24 h | The levels of C5a, C3a and THF - α in oligomer treated group were significantly increased, while the secretion of mmp12 was decreased | 19 |
PC12 cell line | 0.1, 0.5, 1 mg/ml PCL or OCL | Comparison of toxicity differences between PCL and oligomer | -- | Medium exposure | 24 h | In OCL exposed group, cell viability decreased, mitochondrial function was impaired, and neuronal morphology changed | 66 |
HepG2 cell line | 1. 3,9 μ l PCL extract | Multi endpoint evaluation of bioactivity of PCL extract | -- | Medium exposure | 24 h | The five activation endpoints included pregnane X receptor (PXR/pxre), peroxisome proliferator activated receptor γ (PPAR γ/ppre) and nuclear factor red blood cell 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2) | 102 |
Luminescent bacteria, arec3 cell line, yeast | Bio based plastics include PLA PHA、PBS、PBAT、Bio-PE, Methanol extract of plant-based plastics including fiber, starch, etc | Is biological and plant-based plastics a safe alternative to traditional plastics | -- | Medium exposure | -- | 67% of the samples induced baseline toxicity, 42% of the samples induced oxidative stress, 23% of the samples induced anti androgen and one sample induced estrogen activity; Toxicity varies by product | 103 |
Plhc-1 cell line | Methanol extract after photodegradation and composting of plastic consumer goods (PBAT, starch, pet, LDPE, etc.) | Effects of photodegradation and composting on toxicity | -- | Medium exposure | 24 h or 48 h | After 24 hours, cell viability decreased, and photodegradation and composting increased toxicity | 104 |
A549 cell line and HepG2 cell line | Crushed particles or organic solvent extracts of plastic consumer goods (PLA, PHB and HDPE) | Toxicity of bioplastics and additives | 100 nm ~ 10 μm | Medium exposure | 24 h | Extract causes significant oxidative stress | 105 |
In vitro simulated digestion and fermentation model | 0.166 g PLA or PCL | Digestion characteristics of BMPs and potential effects on intestinal flora | PLA MP(75 μm); PCL MP(150 μm) | -- | 24 h | Disturbance of intestinal flora and reduced secretion of short chain fatty acids | 106 |
[1] |
|
[2] |
|
[3] |
|
[4] |
|
[5] |
|
[6] |
|
[7] |
|
[8] |
|
[9] |
|
[10] |
|
[11] |
|
[12] |
|
[13] |
|
[14] |
China Resources Recycling Association. 2023 Report on the Scale of China's Plastic Recycling Industry, 2024.
(中国物资再生协会. 2023年中国塑料回收产业规模报告. [2024-08-01] http://www.replastics.org/. 2024)
|
[15] |
|
[16] |
|
[17] |
|
[18] |
|
[19] |
|
[20] |
|
[21] |
|
[22] |
|
[23] |
|
[24] |
Bioplastics market development update,[2024-10-14]. https://www.european-bioplastics.org/market/. 2023
|
[25] |
(赛迪顾问. 先进制造2024, 2024.).
|
[26] |
|
[27] |
|
[28] |
|
[29] |
|
[30] |
|
[31] |
|
[32] |
|
[33] |
|
[34] |
|
[35] |
|
[36] |
|
[37] |
|
[38] |
|
[39] |
|
[40] |
|
[41] |
|
[42] |
|
[43] |
|
[44] |
|
[45] |
|
[46] |
|
[47] |
|
[48] |
|
[49] |
|
[50] |
|
[51] |
|
[52] |
|
[53] |
|
[54] |
|
[55] |
|
[56] |
|
[57] |
|
[58] |
|
[59] |
|
[60] |
|
[61] |
(黄丹妮, 章敏, 高富龙, 郑榕辉, 黄文树, 薄军, 方超. 生态毒理学报, 2023, 18(3): 175. ).
|
[62] |
(王加珍, 许婷婷, 程昊东, 徐亘博, 於伟琼, 郑春苗, 徐向荣, 裘文慧. 海洋环境科学, 2024, 43(2): 186.).
|
[63] |
|
[64] |
|
[65] |
|
[66] |
|
[67] |
|
[68] |
|
[69] |
|
[70] |
|
[71] |
|
[72] |
|
[73] |
|
[74] |
|
[75] |
|
[76] |
|
[77] |
|
[78] |
|
[79] |
|
[80] |
|
[81] |
|
[82] |
|
[83] |
|
[84] |
|
[85] |
|
[86] |
|
[87] |
|
[88] |
|
[89] |
|
[90] |
|
[91] |
|
[92] |
|
[93] |
|
[94] |
|
[95] |
|
[96] |
|
[97] |
|
[98] |
|
[99] |
|
[100] |
|
[101] |
|
[102] |
|
[103] |
|
[104] |
|
[105] |
|
[106] |
|
[107] |
|
[108] |
|
/
〈 |
|
〉 |