Home Journals Progress in Chemistry
Progress in Chemistry

Abbreviation (ISO4): Prog Chem      Editor in chief: Jincai ZHAO

About  /  Aim & scope  /  Editorial board  /  Indexed  /  Contact  / 
Review

Ternary Random Strategy Applied in Active Layer of High Performance Non-Fullerene Organic Solar Cells

  • Chunyan Li ,
  • Xin Lin ,
  • Wen Wang , * ,
  • Hongyu Zhen
Expand
  • College of Chemistry and Materials Science, Fujian Normal University, Fuzhou 350007, China

Received date: 2024-02-05

  Revised date: 2024-05-26

  Online published: 2024-07-01

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China(51573026)

National Natural Science Foundation of China(22261002)

National Natural Science Foundation of China(61804065)

Natural Science Foundation of Fujian Province(2020J01144)

Abstract

in recent years,there has been significant progress in non-fullerene organic solar cells(NF-OSCs)due to the rapid development of narrow-bandgap small-molecule acceptor materials and the high-performance polymer donor materials,with the power conversion efficiency(PCE)approaching 20%.However,As the design of alternating D-A copolymer materials reaches saturation,there is an urgent need to develop more efficient conjugated polymer materials.the ternary random strategy has emerged to address this challenge.the advantages of the ternary random copolymerization,including easy energy level tuning,broad and strong absorption,and high molar absorptivity,which have attracted considerable attention in the field of organic solar cells.In this review,firstly,the advantages of the ternary random copolymerization strategy in modulating polymer properties and device performance are discussed.Through this strategy,the active layer morphology can be effectively regulated and optimized,and thus the charge transfer efficiency can be improved leading to the improved PCE.Furthermore,the application of the ternary random copolymerization into NF-OSCs is summarized from the perspectives of random polymer donors and acceptors.Finally,a summary and outlook of the further development of random polymers are presented.as expected,to understand the design concept and advantages of ternary random strategy would be beneficial for the development of organic solar cells。

Contents

1 Introduction

2 Advantages of random copolymerization strategy

3 Random polymer donors

3.1 PBDB series random polymer donor materials

3.2 D18 series random polymer donor materials

3.3 PTs series random polymer donor materials

3.4 PTB and PCE11 series random polymer donor materials

3.5 J series random polymer donor materials

4 Random polymer acceptors

4.1 NDI series random polymer acceptor materials

4.2 BTI series random polymer acceptor materials

4.3 PSMA series random polymer acceptor materials

5 Application of random copolymerization to OSCs stability

6 Conclusion and outlook

Cite this article

Chunyan Li , Xin Lin , Wen Wang , Hongyu Zhen . Ternary Random Strategy Applied in Active Layer of High Performance Non-Fullerene Organic Solar Cells[J]. Progress in Chemistry, 2024 , 36(9) : 1316 -1335 . DOI: 10.7536/PC240204

1 Introduction

Given the energy demands of today's world,it is already imperative to develop and upgrade reliable PV technologies for use.Organic solar cell(OPV),as a new green energy source with great development potential,has the advantages of low cost,light weight,high flexibility and roll-to-roll printing,and has attracted much attention and achieved excellent results in recent years[1~4]。 So far,the energy conversion efficiency(PCE)of organic solar cell single device has reached 19.6%,and the PCE of stacked device has reached 20.6%[5][6]。 Throughout the history of organic photovoltaic development,in 1958,Kearns and Calvin discovered the photovoltaic phenomenon of organic materials,which opened the prelude to the development of organic solar cells.in 1986,Deng Qingyun,who worked for Kodak Company in the United States,designed and prepared solar cells with double-layer heterojunction structure containing electron donor and electron acceptor materials,and made a so-called milestone progress in the field of organic photovoltaics,with the PCE of organic solar cells breaking through to 1%[7]。 In 1995,Heeger et al.Developed a novel bulk heterojunction(BHJ)cell with MEH-PPV as the donor and fullerene derivative(C60)as the acceptor,which could achieve more efficient exciton separation and charge transport[8]。 Since then,fullerene-based polymer solar cells(PSCs)have achieved rapid development,with PCE values exceeding 10%.At the same time,non-fullerene materials are also developing quietly.In 2015,A-D-a small molecule receptor ITIC developed by Zhan Xiaowei and others came into being,which promoted the rapid development of organic solar cells[9]。 in 2019,small molecule receptors ushered In a new wave.Zou Yingping et al.Published the small molecule receptor Y6 of A-type DA'D,which greatly improved the efficiency of organic photovoltaics[10]。 At the same time,the continuous and synchronous development of high-performance polymer donors has also made a significant contribution to the rapid development of polymer solar cells.Since the birth of organic solar cells,it has changed from the original fullerene era to the current Non-fullerene era,and the current research on organic solar cells mainly focuses on the non-fullerene system,as shown in Figure 1.non-fullerene organic solar cells can be divided into polymer solar cells and all small molecule solar cells according to the type of active layer,and polymer solar cells can be divided into polymer-small molecule solar cells and all polymer solar cells according to the type of receptor[11~13]。 the most important thing to promote the development of organic solar cells is to select and develop effective active layer materials,mainly because the active layer materials are closely related to the improvement of the PCE value of organic solar cells.in addition,due to the"push-pull"effect between electron-donating(D)and electron-withdrawing(A)units,D-A alternating copolymerization has proved to be a successful strategy for the development of high-performance polymer materials.However,the construction of D-A alternating copolymers by simply developing new structures of well-matched D units or A units is becoming increasingly limited.in this case,it is feasible to design ternary random polymers by properly introducing the third unit into the backbone of D-A copolymers to improve the PCE value,which may lead to broad absorption spectra with multiple absorption bands In random polymers due to the newly generated absorption bands caused by energy level transitions or intramolecular charge transfer(ICT)interactions In random polymers.In addition,the highest occupied molecular orbital(HOMO)and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital(LUMO)energy levels in random polymers can be tuned by reasonably choosing the structure and number of the third unit.On the other hand,the addition of a third unit can also improve polymer solubility and its molecular packing,helping to promote exciton dissociation into free charge carriers.In recent years,the random copolymerization strategy has made great contributions to the development of organic solar cells,and has great potential for development,which plays an important role in the future development of solar cell commercialization。
图1 非富勒烯有机太阳能电池的分类

Fig. 1 Classification of non-fullerene organic solar cells

in this paper,we review the research progress of ternary random copolymerization strategy applied to the active layer of high-performance non-fullerene organic solar cells,with the aim of better understanding its design concept and structure-performance relationship.in this paper,the basic content of ternary random copolymerization is introduced,and the advantages of random D-A copolymerization strategy in controlling polymer properties and device performance are discussed.Secondly,the application of random copolymerization strategy in active layer materials was reviewed from two aspects of random polymer donor materials and acceptor materials,and different series of polymers and third unit types were compared and discussed in detail,and the application of ternary copolymerization strategy in the stability of OSCs was introduced.Finally,the further development of ternary random polymers in organic solar cells is summarized and prospected。

2 Advantages of random copolymerization strategy

Random copolymerization is simply to introduce a large conjugated plane into the D-A alternating copolymer or to copolymerize the third unit(D1or A1),which is similar to the structure of the substituted unit,to produce random polymers.While in a typical D-A conjugated polymer,the polymerized units(D and A moieties)are alternately linked to each other along the polymer backbone.However,current research has found that the electron-donating units and electron-withdrawing units of D-a alternating copolymers,which can be used to construct high-performance polymer solar cells,are very limited.In addition,the following reasons have greatly limited the further development of D-A alternating copolymers:(1)it is difficult to further broaden the spectral absorption;(2)The solubility of polymer can only be optimized by adjusting the length of the molecular side chain,but the longer the side chain is,the less favorable it is to maintain the molecular planarity;(3)The synthesis of the novel electron-donating unit(D)and electron-withdrawing unit(A)is complicated and costly.For random polymers,the order of attachment of the units in the polymer backbone is not fixed.Various random polymer materials can be conveniently synthesized by adding polymeric units with different chemical structures during the polymerization process.In addition,the irregular proportion of the polymer backbone can be well adjusted by controlling the number of introduced third units.Therefore,the chemical and physical properties of polymer materials can be largely optimized through rational random copolymerization strategies.In other words,random copolymerization is likely to improve the photoelectric properties of polymer materials.As shown in fig.2,the structure of the random polymer may be composed of two different D units and one A unit in equal amounts or two different A units and one D unit in equal amounts,or may be composed of D units and A units in unequal amounts 。
图2 D-A交替共聚物和三元无规聚合物示意图

Fig. 2 Schematic illustration of alternative D-A conjugated copolymer and ternary random copolymer

The random copolymerization strategy is used to optimize the performance parameters of organic solar cells from the main performance parameters of organic solar cells,and further improve the device efficiency of organic solar cell.The main performance parameters of organic solar cells include open circuit voltage(VOC),short circuit current(JSC),fill factor(FF),and energy conversion efficiency.The energy conversion efficiency of the solar cell is closely related to the open-circuit voltage,and the(VOC)of the open-circuit voltage is proportional to the difference between the energy levels of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital(LUMO)of the acceptor and the highest occupied molecular orbital(HOMO)of the donor.In most cases,it is an effective way to improve the PCE value of polymer solar cells by properly increasing the LUMO energy level of the acceptor and properly decreasing the HOMO energy level of the donor.And the proper energy level alignment between the donor and acceptor materials is essential for enhancing the charge and energy transfer characteristics at the donor-acceptor interface and achieving high VOCfor low-voltage loss(Vloss).By using the strategy of random copolymerization,we can introduce a certain proportion of weak electron-withdrawing or strong electron-donating units into the original polymer backbone,which will increase the LUMO energy level of the polymer acceptor material to a certain extent;On the contrary,polymer donor materials with deeper energy levels can be obtained by introducing stronger electron-withdrawing or weaker electron-donating units into the original polymer backbone 。
Secondly,efficient polymer photovoltaic active layer materials generally have wide and strong absorption in the visible and near-infrared regions,as well as a higher absorption coefficient,which can harvest more solar photons and make full use of solar energy more effectively,thus facilitating PSCs to have a larger short-circuit current(JSC)value.In general,the absorption properties of polymer materials,including absorption spectral width and absorption coefficient,can be adjusted and optimized by rational random copolymerization strategies.That is to say,by introducing third units with different electron-donating or electron-withdrawing capabilities,a broader absorption spectrum can be obtained,and by introducing third groups with stronger absorption capabilities,the absorption coefficient can be improved 。
Thirdly,through the random copolymerization strategy,the third unit is added to the polymer skeleton and adjusted to the Appropriate content to reasonably modify the chemical structure,which can not only enhance the intermolecularπ-πinteraction,but also fine-tune the miscibility between the donor and acceptor materials,thus obtaining the ideal morphology characteristics.Generally,the morphology of the blend film includes the stacking and orientation of molecules,domain size,etc.,which mainly depend on the chemical structure of the polymer material.appropriate blend morphology is the key to achieve efficient exciton dissociation,carrier transport and suppression of charge recombination,which is essentially the key to achieve high fill factor(FF)value of PSCs。
Efficient PSCs rely on the combined contributions of high VOC,high JSC,and high FF.Based on the great progress of D-A copolymer in PSCs,the further improvement and optimization of PSCs focus on the precise regulation of the photoelectric properties of polymer materials.Compared with the typical D-A alternating conjugated copolymer,the random copolymerization strategy has obvious advantages and great potential in precisely regulating the optoelectronic properties for further development of efficient photovoltaic materials 。

3 Random polymer donor material

active layer materials play an important role in The photoelectric conversion process of organic solar cells,which almost determine the energy conversion efficiency of the whole cell device.polymer donor is one of the most widely used donor materials for the Active layer of organic solar cells.According to the different molecular structures of polymers,it can be divided into homopolymer,D-a type linear alternating conjugated polymer and random polymer,among which D-a type linear alternating conjugated polymer and random polymer are more widely studied.different from homopolymers,D-a type alternating polymers can control the energy level and band gap of polymers by adding different donor-acceptor units due to the orbital hybridization resonance of different units,so as to obtain the most suitable absorption spectrum and energy level structure,while random polymers are derived from D-a type alternating conjugated polymers.the introduction of a third unit by a random copolymerization strategy,such as the addition of a certain amount of thiophene units containing different alkyl chains,can improve polymer solubility and molecular stacking;the mobility of polymer materials can be improved by selecting bithiophene units with stronger planarity;the selection of thiophene side chain with two-dimensional conjugation can improve the absorption coefficient of the polymer,thereby improving the short-circuit current density of the device;the HOMO energy level of the donor material can also be effectively pulled down by the introduction of halogen atoms,and then the purpose of fine regulation of the molecular energy level can be achieved by controlling the introduction amount.At present,the application of random copolymerization strategy to optimize polymer materials and improve device performance by adding the third unit mainly focuses on the modification of high-performance polymer donors such as PBDB(PM6)series,D18 series and J series.the development of these series of random polymer donor materials is highlighted below。

3.1 PBDB series random polymer donor materials

Benzodithiophenedione(BDD)unit is one of the most attractive electron-withdrawing units in high efficiency polymer donors,mainly due to its planar symmetric fused ring structure and self-assembly characteristics.as a result,BDD-based polymers(such As PBDB-T,PM6,PM7,etc.)have achieved rapid development,and these polymer donor materials Have significantly improved the PCE of organic solar cells.Especially after the non-fullerene small molecule acceptor is reported,the PBDB series polymer donor material has the excellent properties of absorption spectrum and energy level structure matched with the small molecule acceptor,orderly molecular stacking,and obvious face-on orientation,and can form a suitable phase separation morphology with most non-fullerene acceptors.At present,the highest device efficiency of non-fullerene organic solar cells based on PBDB-TF(PM6)has exceeded 19%,making this donor material a star material,and there are endless explorations and designs for the modification of this series of materials.the ternary random copolymerization strategy has played a significant role in promoting the innovation of PBDB series materials.Fig.3 is a representative PBDB series random polymer donor material,and its corresponding photovoltaic performance parameters are shown in Table 1。
图3 PBDB系列无规聚合物给体

Fig. 3 The structure of PBDB series random polymer donors

表1 Performance Parameters of Organic Solar Cells Based on PBDB Series Random Polymer Donors

Table 1 Device performance of organic solar cells based on PBDB series random polymer donors

Active layer VOC /V JSC /mA·cm-2 FF /% PCE /% Ref
T1:IT-4F 0.899 21.5 78 15.1 10
S1:Y6 0.877 25.402 73.7 16.421 11
PBDB-TF-T10:Y6 0.84 27.9 70 16.4 12
PM6:S3:Y6 0.856 25.86 79.17 17.53 13
L1:L8-BO 0.901 26.38 78.9 18.75 14
L2:L8-BO 0.898 26.26 78.6 18.54 14
PF1:Y6 0.87 26.3 76 17.3 15
PF2:Y6 0.88 22.9 70 14.1 15
PM6-TTO-10:BTP-eC9 0.860 26.80 79.97 18.37 16
PTF3:Y6-BO 0.83 26.5 74.0 16.3 17
PTF5:Y6-BO 0.84 28.0 77.2 18.2 17
PTF10:Y6-BO 0.84 27.0 75.1 17.0 17
PM1:Y6 0.87 25.9 78 17.6 18
PM2:Y6 0.90 24.9 69 15.5 18
PM6-Tz20:Y6 0.86 27.3 75 17.6 19
PM6-Tz40:Y6 0.85 25.3 72 15.5 19
OPz1:Y6 0.871 25.34 73.7 16.28 20
OPz2:Y6 0.871 24.81 67.1 14.54 20
OPz3:Y6 0.881 18.68 43.1 7.09 20
PMZ-10:Y6 0.834 27.96 78.2 18.23 21
PMZ-20:Y6 0.841 27.39 76.6 17.64 21
PMZ-30:Y6 0.847 26.92 75.3 17.17 21
PMZ1:Y6 0.841 26.1 75.5 16.6 22
PMZ2:Y6 0.854 26.9 77.2 17.8 22
PMZ3:Y6 0.857 26.1 75.5 16.9 22
PM6-SiCl-10%:Y6 0.870 25.37 73.48 16.22 23
PM6-SiCl-15%:Y6 0.875 25.26 70.03 15.48 23
PM6-SiCl-20%:Y6 0.881 24.88 67.24 14.73 23
PBNB80:BO-4Cl 0.850 25.7 73.3 16.0 24
PM6-5Si:N3 0.852 26.32 75.81 17.01 25
PQB-2:PY-IT 0.942 24.2 79.5 18.1 26
PM6-C5:Y7 0.86 26.3 72 16.7 27
PM6-C10:Y7 0.86 26.8 74 17.0 27
PM6-C20:Y7 0.86 24.7 70 14.9 27
PM6-C30:Y7 0.84 23.9 68 13.8 27
PM6-TzBI-5:L8-BO 0.894 25.45 78.10 17.77 28
PM6-TzBI-10:L8-BO 0.897 25.63 79.84 18.36 28
PM6-TzBI-15:L8-BO 0.905 25.40 77.67 17.85 28
PM6-TzBI-20:L8-BO 0.909 25.03 76.78 17.47 28
PNB-1:L8-BO 0.903 26.21 78.04 18.47 29
PNB-3:L8-BO 0.907 26.59 78.86 19.02 29
PNB-5:L8-BO 0.914 25.53 76.20 17.78 29
PM6-Ir0.5:Y6 0.845 26.28 74.02 16.44 30
PM6-Ir1:Y6 0.842 26.12 78.41 17.24 30
PM6-Ir2.5:Y6 0.847 26.07 74.15 16.37 30
PM6-Ir5:Y6 0.842 25.92 73.43 16.03 30
For the design of the third unit,the simple structural unit is relatively more concerned.the energy level of the polymer Can be effectively adjusted by introducing electron-withdrawing units with simple structures to replace part of the BDD units,and intramolecular non-covalent bonding(O…H,O…S,etc.)can also be Introduced,thereby improving the coplanarity of the polymer molecules and facilitating the improvement of mobility.Among them,simple structures such as electron-withdrawing units such as substituted thiophenes have become the research focus.In 2019,Hou Jianhui et al.introduced ester substituted monothiophene into the main chain of PM6 and synthesized terpolymer T1,which reduced the molecular energy level,and the efficiency of battery devices based on T1:Y6 exceeded 15%[14]。 In the same year,Yan He et al.Introduced a fluorine atom into an ester-substituted thiophene as the third unit,and also embedded it into the PM6 skeleton to synthesize a polymer donor S1.After blending with Y6,the efficiency of the prepared device was 16.4%[15]。 In 2021,Xu Xiaofeng et al.Introduced diester-substituted thiophene and diester-substituted thiophene as the third unit into the main chain of PM6,and synthesized two types of random polymers[16]。 Due to the addition of the third unit,the structural disorder of the polymer increases,the absorption range broadens,and the HOMO energy level decreases.the device efficiency of PBDB-TF-T10:Y6 is 16.4%.In addition,the substitution of halogen for thiophene as the third unit is also a common simple structural design.In 2020,Guo Xugang et al.Replaced monothiophene with chlorine atom as the third unit,introduced it into the molecular skeleton of PBDB-TCl,and developed a terpolymer S3[17]。 S3 was added to the PM6:Y6 system,and the efficiency of the optimized ternary device was 17.53%after adding 20%S3.In 2023,Yang et al.Introduced a diester-substituted thiophene(DDT)unit as the third unit into the PM6 skeleton,and developed two terpolymers L1 and L2 with thiophene with alkyl chain as the bridging unit[18]。 Polymers L1 and L2 have deeper HOMO levels,higher molecular stiffness and planarity than PM6 due to their strong electron-withdrawing ability and S…O non-covalent intramolecular interactions.When mixed with the non-fullerene acceptor L8-BO,the device efficiency based on L1:L8-BO is as high as 18.75%.In addition,the substitution of functional groups on the bridge ring unit and the increase or decrease of the number of bridge ring units are also effective methods.For example,Zhang Maojie and Guoxia of Soochow University used fluorine atom substitution design to replace thiophene with single fluorine as the bridged ring unit,and constructed the third unit[19]。 Because of the small atomic radius of the fluorine atom,there is no additional steric hindrance and the corresponding reduction of molecular coplanarity,and because of the strong electron-withdrawing ability of the fluorine atom,the HOMO energy level of the random polymer is effectively lowered.When blended with Y6,the corresponding blend films show excellent morphology,with significant nanoscale interpenetrating network structure and increased fiber width.As a result,the PF1:Y6-based organic solar cell device achieved an energy conversion efficiency as high as 17.3%.In 2023,Chen Yiwang and Liao Xunfan first designed and synthesized two new isomeric units TTO and TTI by combining ternary copolymerization and regioisomerization strategies,and obtained a series of D-A-D-A1ternary polymer donor materials(PM6-TTO and PM6-TTI)through random copolymerization[20]。 It is found that different Cl substituent positions can significantly change the molecular planarity and surface electrostatic potential.Compared with TTI,TTO unit has more and stronger S…O non-covalent interactions,corrected electrostatic potential(ESP)and less isomer structure.Therefore,compared with PM6-TTI-10,the ternary polymer PM6-TTO-10 shows better molecular coplanarity,stronger crystallinity,more obvious aggregation behavior,and proper phase separation in the blend film,which is conducive to more efficient exciton dissociation and charge transfer.Thus,PM6-TTO-10:BTP-eC9 based PSC achieved a high PCE of 18.37%.In addition,the benzene ring can also be used as the third unit.In 2023,Lee et al.Introduced different numbers of trifluoromethyl(CF3)substituted benzene units into the main chain of PM6 polymer and synthesized a series of ternary polymer donors(PTF3,PTF5,PTF10,PTF20 and PTF50 )[21]。 Due to the optimized energy levels,molecular aggregation/miscibility,and the bulk heterojunction morphology of the photosensitive material,all photovoltaic parameters can be significantly improved even with the addition of random polymers with little CF3content,and thus,a PCE of 18.2%was achieved in the best binary OSC based on PTF5:Y6-BO 。
In the ternary random copolymerization strategy,nitrogen heterocycles are particularly common In the construction of the third unit due to their electron-withdrawing ability and strong crystallinity,and the typical structural units are benzothiazole and thiazoline.In 2019,Zhang Maojie et al.Reported a class of ternary random polymer donors.By adding 20%of weak electron-withdrawing thiazole(TTz)units to the PM6 polymer skeleton,the polymer PM1 was prepared,and the device efficiency of the organic solar cell based on PM1:Y6 was 17.6%[22]。 Importantly,the PM1 polymer has excellent batch reproducibility,and the random polymer PM1 has a lower HOMO energy level,and the active layer formed by blending with Y6 has a better morphology structure.in 2020,Zhang Maojie et al.further reported that two kinds of random polymers PM6-Tz20 and PM6-Tz40 were prepared with 5,5'-dithiazole-2,2'-dithiazole(DTBTz)units as the third unit,In which 20%of DTBTz units were added to successfully achieve the fine regulation of molecular order and aggregation performance,thus Further optimizing the morphology of the active layer blended with Y6[23]。 the results show that the PCE of the device based on PM6-Tz20:Y6 reaches 17.6%.Subsequently,Lu Shirong et al.Introduced ester-substituted thiazole(E-Tz)units into the PM6 backbone,and found that the incorporation of E-Tz units significantly improved the molecular planarity,energy level,and optical absorption range of the polymer donor[24]。 the PCE based on OPz1:Y6 device reaches 16.28%.Li Yongfang et al.Introduced another nitrogen heterocyclic 2,5-bis(4-(2-ethylhexyl)thiophen-2-yl)pyrazine(PZ-T)unit into The PM6 skeleton to construct a series of random polymer donor materials PMZ-10,PMZ-20 and PMZ-30[25]。 Compared with PM6,the random polymer has a lower HOMO energy level,so that the Voc of the prepared organic solar cell is significantly improved.the organic solar cell device based on PMZ-10:Y6 exhibits efficient exciton dissociation,higher and balanced electron/hole mobility,ideal aggregation,and a high PCE of 18.23%.In addition,Zhang Maojie et al.Synthesized a series of ternary polymers PMZ1,PMZ2 and PMZ3 by introducing carboxylate pyrazine(CPz)units into the main chain of PM6 using a ternary copolymerization strategy,which have excellent molecular flatness,and the highest device efficiency of PMZ2 blended with Y6 is 17.8%[26]
Designing a structural unit similar to the main chain as the third unit is also common In ternary random copolymerization strategies.the use of similar structures can avoid the risk of poor molecular coplanarity caused by the third unit to a certain extent,and can precisely control the properties of polymers by adding some substituents with specific properties.in 2021,Chen et al.Used a chlorine atom and silane chain substituted BDT unit(BDT-SiCl)as the third unit.BDT-SiCl and BDT-2F have the same skeleton.the similarity of the two structures not only greatly reduces the interference of random copolymerization on the ordered arrangement of molecules,but also enhances the face-on orientation of the active layer,which is conducive to charge transport[27]。 Compared with PM6,the substitution of silane group and chlorine atom makes the terpolymer have lower HOMO energy level and wider spectral absorption range.the results show that the PSC based on ternary polymer PM6-SiCl-10%has the highest efficiency of 16.22%,and the energy loss is only 0.50 eV.Hou et al.Reported two random polymer donors,PBNB80 and PBNB50,by adjusting the molar ratio of two BDD derivatives,NTD and chlorinated BDD units[28]。 Especially,the PBNB80:BO-4Cl blend can form a more excellent nanoscale phase separation morphology,resulting In an excellent efficiency of 16.0%,which is much higher than the 12.8%and 10.7%of the binary polymer donor device.in 2021,Yang et al.Designed a new iBDD-Si(TIPS replacement for BDD isomer)unit as the third component to embed the backbone of polymer donor PM6,and synthesized a series of iBDD-Si-based polymer donors.the iBDD-Si unit can fine-tune the optical properties,energy levels,and molecular packing,among which the device efficiency of PM6-5Si(iBDD-Si accounts for 5%):N3 reaches 17.01%[29]。 In 2023,Hou Jianhui et al.introduced quinoxaline derivatives into the PM6 skeleton,and designed and synthesized three ternary polymers PQB-x.Through ternary copolymerization,the molecular orientation of the polymer chain was changed from face-on and edge-on coexistence to face-on stacking,and the energy disorder and energy loss were greatly reduced.the PCE of the device based on PQB-2:PY-IT was 18.1%[30]。 This is also one of the highest device efficiencies of current all-polymer solar cells。
In addition to the above types,the design of other structural units as the third unit has also achieved some results In the preparation of modified devices based on PM6.In 2021,Kim et al.Designed two thiophene structures connected by the alkyl chain of C10 as the third unit to modify the PM6 polymer[31]。 After blending with small molecule acceptor Y7,the device efficiency based on PM6-C10:Y7 exceeds 17%,and has higher JSCand FF than PM6.In addition,structural units with strong electron-withdrawing ability can effectively control the energy level change of polymers,so they are often used as the third unit of random strategy to modify polymer donors.In 2022,Peng Qiang et al.Designed and synthesized a series of ternary random polymers by introducing a strong polar third unit TzBI into the main chain of high-performance polymer PM6[32]。 the introduction of a small amount of TzBI units improves the disorder of the molecular skeleton and increases the interaction force between molecules.In addition,the strong electron-withdrawing ability of TzBI units reduces the molecular energy level of the polymer,which realizes the precise control of the nano-morphology of the film.the device efficiency based on PM6-TzBI-10:L8-BO reaches 18.36%.In 2023,they introduced the BNIDT skeleton structure containing B—N coordination bond into the PM6 main chain,designed a series of wide band gap ternary polymer donor materials PNB-1,PNB-3 and PNB-5 by using the anti-resonance effect of B—N bond,realized the reduction of device non-radiative recombination loss and the improvement of device performance,and optimized the active layer morphology.Finally,the device efficiency based on PNB-5:L8-BO reached 19.02%[33]。 In addition,the organometallic complex building block is also a good choice as the third unit.In 2020,Min Jie et al.First doped heavy metal iridium complexes into the framework of high-performance polymer donor material PM6,and designed and synthesized a series of random polymers PM6-Irx(X=0.0.5,1,2.5 and 5).It is found that the molecular planarity,crystallinity,optical absorption,energy level of PM6 can be effectively controlled by doping with a small amount of iridium complex,and the miscibility with small molecular acceptor material Y6 can be improved[34]。 Based on PM6-Ir1:Y6 device efficiency up to 17.24%。
equivalent D-A random copolymerization is introduced above,and non-equivalent random copolymerization has also played an important role In the development of organic photovoltaic polymer donor materials.However,compared with the equivalent D-A copolymerization strategy,the research on non-equivalent D-A copolymerization is less at present,and only the modification of PBDB series polymers is available at present.in 2021,Li Yongfang et al.First proposed the non-equivalent D-A copolymerization strategy and synthesized non-equivalent D-A copolymer donor materials[35]。 A series of efficient D-A-D-D1type non-equivalent D-a copolymers PM6-Dn were synthesized by inserting more D units into the long chain of the copolymers.It was found that the HOMO energy level decreased,the absorption spectrum blue-shifted and the optical band gap widened with the addition of D units.The test results show that compared with PM6,the non-equivalent D-A copolymers PM6-Dn(n=1,2,3)have higher carrier mobility,better molecular crystallinity and self-assembly ability,among which PM6-D1 is the best,and its device efficiency reaches 17.71%.The corresponding results show that the PM6-Dn:Y6-based device exhibits more efficient exciton dissociation,less bimolecular recombination,and faster charge transport than the PM6:Y6-based device.In 2022,Liu Jinbiao et al.Used the ester-doped BDT unit(BDT-2EST)as the third unit to introduce into the PM6 skeleton,and developed the D-A-D-D1polymer donor[36]。 By adjusting the content of the third component,DM1 containing 5%BDT-2 EST has the appropriate crystallinity and miscibility to match the Y6 receptor,and the device efficiency based on DM1:Y6 can be as high as 17.21%.In 2022,our group designed and synthesized a vinyl-functionalized BDT-based monomer(BDTOA-2Br)and simple BDT-Br as the third unit,which were introduced into the PM6 skeleton to prepare two kinds of polymers,PM6-Ax and PM6-Tx[37][38]。 it was found that the efficiency of PM6-A5:Y6 and PM6-T15:Y6 based devices was higher than that of PM6:Y6 based reference devices.in 2023,our group again synthesized a simple electron-donating unit 2,6-dibromo-4,8-bis(octyloxy)benzo[1,2-b:4,5-b']dithiophene(BDT-O)as the third unit,which was added to the D-A backbone of PM6 to prepare PM6-Ox by non-equivalent D-A random copolymerization strategy.the effect of BDT-O units on the optoelectronic properties of the polymer was studied,and It was found that the addition of a small amount of BDT-O units to PM6 could effectively adjust the absorption,energy level,and molecular alignment of the polymer,resulting In better sunlight harvesting and enhanced charge transport,with a PCE of up to 17.65%based on the PM6-O5:Y6 device[39]。 in addition,the PM6-O5:Y6-based device has high thermal stability,storage stability,and excellent photostability.the above studies show that non-equivalent random copolymerization has also made a great contribution to the development of non-fullerene solar cells.Fig.4 shows a representative PBDB series of non-equivalent random polymer donor materials,and the corresponding photovoltaic performance parameters are shown In Table 2。
图4 PBDB系列非等量无规聚合物给体

Fig.4 The structure of PBDB series non-equivalent random polymer donors

表2 Performance parameters of organic solar cell devices based on PBDB series non-equivalent random polymer donor materials

Table 2 Device performance of organic solar cells based on PBDB series non-equivalent random polymer donors

Active layer VOC /V JSC /mA·cm-2 FF /% PCE /% Ref
PM6-D1:Y6 0.85 26.47 78.7 17.71 31
PM6-D2:Y6 0.85 26.18 75.6 16.82 31
PM6-D3:Y6 0.86 26.01 76.1 17.02 31
DM1:Y6 0.85 25.86 78.29 17.21 32
DM2:Y6 0.86 25.63 75.48 16.65 32
PM6-T5:Y6 0.89 23.20 68.61 14.17 34
PM6-T10:Y6 0.87 26.43 66.53 15.31 34
PM6-T15:Y6 0.86 27.02 71.14 16.61 34
PM6-T20:Y6 0.88 24.12 65.41 13.94 34
PM6-A5:Y6 0.84 26.36 68.65 15.20 33
PM6-A15:Y6 0.83 23.95 62.49 12.42 33
PM6-O5 0.84 27.87 75.39 17.65 35
PM6-O10 0.84 26.23 69.69 15.34 35
PM6-O30 0.84 19.09 62.66 10.14 35

3.2 D18 series random polymer donor materials

In addition to the BDD unit,the design of other novel receptor units has evolved In recent years.In 2020,Ding Liming et al.Developed a symmetrical acceptor unit DTBT and prepared D-A copolymer donor D18[40]。 D18 has a high hole mobility,and the energy conversion efficiency of the device obtained by blending D18 with Y6 is as high as 18.22%.Subsequently,Wang Jinliang and Anqiaoshi added chlorinated BDT units as the third unit to the D18 skeleton,and synthesized terpolymers D18-20%Cl and D18-40%Cl by adjusting the ratio of fluorinated BDT to chlorinated BDT units[41]。 the device based on D18-20%Cl has a deeper energy level and a higher open circuit voltage,and the efficiency of the device prepared by blending with Y6 is as high as 18.28%.In 2022,Lu Shirong et al.Introduced ester-substituted thiazole(E-Tz)units into the backbone of polymer D18,and synthesized a series of terpolymer donors OPz11,OPz12,OPz13 and OPz14[42]。 It is found that the addition of E-Tz units can finely tune molecular aggregation and phase separation,promote exciton dissociation and charge transport,and 5%E-Tz unit content makes the efficiency of the device blended with Y6 reach 18.42%.Bo Zhishan et al.synthesized three ternary polymer donor materials(PL1,PL2 and PL3)by random copolymerization strategy by adjusting the ratio of BDD unit to DTBT unit using the monomers used for the synthesis of two high-performance polymers PM6 and D18,and the highest device efficiency based on PL1:BTP-eC9-4F was 18.14%[43]。 In 2023,they further developed two new receptor units with C2Vsymmetry,B2TCl-o and B2TCl-i units,and introduced the B2TCl-o unit into the D18 polymer backbone to prepare ternary polymer PW2,with the highest device efficiency of 17.19%based on PW2:BTP-eC9-4F[44]。 the structural formula of a representative random polymer donor material is shown in fig.5,and The relevant photovoltaic performance parameters are summarized in Table 3。
图5 (1)D18系列无规聚合物给体,(2)聚噻吩系列无规聚合物给体,(3)PTB系列和PCE11系列无规聚合物给体,(4)J系列无规聚合物给体

Fig. 5 (1)The structure of D18 series random polymer donors, (2) The structure of PTs series random polymer donors, (3) The structure of PTB and PCE11series random polymer donors, (4) The structure of J series random polymer donors

表3 Performance parameters of organic solar cell devices with other random polymer donors

Table 3 Device performance of organic solar cells based on other series random copolymer donors

Active layer VOC /V JSC /mA·cm-2 FF /% PCE /% Ref
D18-20%Cl:Y6 0.861 27.20 78.06 18.28 37
D18-40%Cl:Y6 0.866 26.34 75.46 17.21 37
OPz11:Y6 0.865 27.02 78.71 18.42 38
OPz12:Y6 871 26.20 73.82 16.85 38
PW2:BTP-ec9-4F 0.87 27.32 72.72 17.19 40
PDCBT-Cl:ITIC-Th1 0.93 17.91 68.2 11.33 41
PDCBT-Cl-Si5:ITIC-Th1 0.93 18.70 70.1 12.67 41
PDCBT-Cl-Si10:ITIC-Th1 0.92 18.28 69.9 11.79 41
PDCBT-Cl-Si15:ITIC-Th1 0.91 17.13 64.0 9.95 41
P5TCN-F0:Y6 0.81 20.83 68.8 11.5 42
P5TCN-F25:Y6 0.79 27.13 77.1 16.6 42
P5TCN-F35:Y6 0.80 26.87 75.0 16.1 42
P5TCN-F50:Y6 0.82 24.78 72.0 14.6 42
P5TCN-F25:Y6:PCBM 0.80 27.55 77.7 17.2 42
PCE10-BDT2F-0.3:Y6 0.678 26.10 66.56 11.76 44
PCE10-BDT2F-0.5:Y6 0.720 26.01 69.42 13.01 44
PCE10-BDT2F-0.6:Y6 0.739 26.01 64.08 12.36 44
PCE10-BDT2F-0.7:Y6 0.746 26.17 68.95 13.46 44
PCE10-BDT2F-0.8:Y6 0.753 26.36 69.45 13.80 44
PCE10-BDT2F-0.9:Y6 0.766 25.14 67.71 13.03 44
PCE10-BDT2Cl-0.3:Y6 0.700 23.56 66.24 10.92 44
PCE10-BDT2Cl-0.5:Y6 0.724 25.37 64.41 11.83 44
PCE10-BDT2Cl-0.7:Y6 0.743 24.85 65.58 12.09 44
Si25:Y14 0.782 26.82 73.38 15.39 46
TBFCl50-FTAZ:ITIC 0.876 18.45 73.8 11.94 48
TBFCI50-BDD:ITIC 0.961 18.17 71.3 12.46 48
TBFCI50-BDD:IDIC-C4ph 0.908 17.66 76.6 12.29 48
PBTA-PS-F:ITIC 0.97 18.46 75.29 13.48 49
PSBTZ-60:ITIC 0.91 18.0 62.7 10.3 50

3.3 Polythiophene random polymer donor material

Polythiophenes(PTs)are considered as candidates for large-scale industrial preparation of OSCs due to their simple chemical structure,easy synthesis,and cheap raw material source.in recent years,some studies have shown that the random copolymerization strategy is a very effective way to optimize the donor properties of polythiophene polymers.Fig.5 contains the structural formulas of representative polythiophene series random polymer donor materials,and the relevant photovoltaic performance parameters are summarized In Table 3.In 2021,Geng Yanhou et al.introduced thiophene units with siloxane chains into the modified PDCBT structure through random copolymerization strategy,and finely adjusted the miscibility of polythiophene and non-fullerene blends by changing the ratio of siloxane terminal chains and alkyl chains in ester-substituted polythiophene[45]。 A series of ester-substituted polythiophene derivatives(PDCBT-Cl-Six)were synthesized and blended with the acceptor material ITIC-Th1,and the highest PCE of 12.85%was achieved.In addition,Duan Chunhui et al.introduced different amounts of fluorine atoms into polythiophene polymer donors containing cyano substitution,and the main chain fluorination led to strong interchain interaction,thus improving the crystallinity of the polymer,changing the problem of excessive phase separation of the active layer after blending of polythiophene donors and Y6 series acceptors,and optimizing the morphology structure[46]。 Finally,the PCE of the binary device based on P5TCN-F25 and Y6 was up to 16.6%,and the PCE of the three components based on P5TCN-F25:Y6:PC71BM was up to 17.2%,which was a major breakthrough in OSCs based on PTs 。

3.4 PTB series and PCE11 series random polymer donor materials

in 2013,Chen et al.Synthesized a narrow band gap polymer donor PTB7-Th(PCE10)by introducing 2-ethylhexyl-thiophene into the side chain of the BDT unit In PTB7[47]。 The results show that the absorption of PTB7-Th has a significant red shift of 25 nm compared with that of PTB7,and the maximum absorption wavelength is 695 nm,and the PCE of OSCs based on PTB7-Th:PC71BM is further improved to 9.35%.Chen et al.introduced BDT-2F and BDT-2Cl units into the polymer donor PCE10 by random copolymerization,and obtained two series of ternary random polymers PCE10-BDT2F-X and PCE10-BDT2Cl-X.Through this simple ternary polymer design strategy,the matching between Y6 and the narrow band gap polymer donor PCE10 was improved[48]。 Among them,the device based on PCE10-BDT2F-0.8:Y6 achieves an energy conversion efficiency of 13.80%,which is nearly 40%higher than that of the device based on PCE10:Y6.in addition to BDT units,which are often used to design polymer donor materials,donor materials based on fluoro-substituted benzothiadiazole(ffBT)units have also been a hot research topic In recent years.the introduction of strong electron-withdrawing F atoms into benzothiadiazole(BT)units enhances the planarity and hole mobility of their structures.Yan He et al.Reported a polymer donor PffBT4T-2OD(PCE11b)[49]。 The molecule has a broad absorption spectrum and high crystallinity,and when matched with the PC71BM,the best PCE of the final device reaches 10.8%.In 2021,Zou Yingping et al.introduced siloxane chains into the polymer PffBT4T-2 OD by random copolymerization to prepare the ternary polymer Si25,which controlled the aggregation strength of the polymer and realized the matching with the fused ring non-fullerene acceptor.In the organic solar cell prepared by blending with the acceptor material Y14,when the thickness of the active layer was 430 nm,the highest device efficiency was 15.39%[50]。 the structural formula of a representative random polymer donor material is shown in fig.5-3,and The relevant photovoltaic performance parameters are summarized in Table 3。

3.5 J series random polymer donor materials

In 2016,Li Yongfang et al.First reported that polymer donor materials J50 and J51 synthesized by copolymerization of BDT unit and benzotriazole(BTz)unit were blended with star non-fullerene small molecule acceptor ITIC.Thanks to the complementary absorption and matching energy level between the donor and acceptor,the efficiency of the prepared device exceeded 9.0%,which aroused the development wave of J series polymer donor materials[51]。 the structural formula of the representative J series random polymer donor materials is shown in Figure 5-4,and the relevant photovoltaic performance parameters are summarized in Table 3.Yang Renqiang et al.Used benzodithiophene(BDT)unit and thiophene[2,3-f]benzofuran(TBF)unit as two D units to construct a series of ternary polymer donors by ternary copolymerization strategy.the addition of TBF units with high crystallinity to the polymer with BDT units with low crystallinity can not only improve the order of the microstructure,maintain good face-on orientation,promote the formation of phase separation characteristics,but also produce high exciton dissociation and inhibit charge recombination[52]。 Finally,the PCEs of TBFCl50-FTAZ:ITIC,TBFCl50-BDD:ITIC,and TBFCl50-BDD:IDIC-C4ph based devices were 11.9%,12.4%,and 12.2%,respectively,by the above ternary copolymerization strategy.In 2019,they further designed and synthesized two polymers,fluorine-containing terpolymer(PBTA-PS-F)and fluorine-free polymer(PBTA-PS)[53]。 the fluorine-containing terpolymer PBTA-PS-F has a deeper HOMO energy level compared with PBTA-PS,and PBTA-PS-F exhibits ordered molecular packing and excellent face-on orientation.the PCE of the device based on PBTA-PS-F:ITIC is 13.48%,which is higher than that of the device based on polymer PBTA-PS(PCE=11.72%).in addition,In 2018,Zhang Maojie et al.Reported that alkylthio thienyl substituted benzodithiophene(BDTT-S)was used as the D unit,and 5,6-difluoro substituted benzotriazole(FBTz)and thiazolothiazole(TTz)were used as the A unit.A series of wide band gap ternary random copolymer donor materials were designed and synthesized,and the optical,electrochemical,molecular arrangement and charge transport properties of the polymers were effectively optimized by controlling the molar ratio of the two A units[54]。 Among them,the device PCE based on PSBTZ-60:ITIC processed with non-halogenated solvent was 10.3%。

4 Random polymer acceptor material

in recent years,all-polymer solar cells(All-PSCs)have attracted extensive research interest because of their inherent advantages such as good film forming,stable morphology,and mechanical flexibility.In addition to the achievements In device efficiency of materials synthesized by polymer donors using ternary random copolymerization strategy,polymer acceptor materials have also been greatly developed by ternary copolymerization method。
Generally speaking,most of the A units commonly used in the acceptor building units of D-A copolymers are imine derivatives,such as perylene diimine(PDI),naphthalene diimine(NDI),and dithiophene imine(BTI).in recent years,with the development of small molecule receptor polymerization(PSMA)strategy,"PSMA"polymer receptors have made remarkable progress.random copolymerization strategies have also played an important role in tailoring the optoelectronic properties of polymer acceptors.Wherein the molecular design strategy of the random polymer acceptor material is similar to that of the random polymer donor material discussed above。

4.1 Random polymer acceptor materials based on NDI series

NDI is considered to be a promising acceptor unit in imide-based polymer acceptors due to its high electron affinity rate and high electron mobility[55,56]。 Fig.6 shows the corresponding chemical structures of representative random polymer acceptor materials based on NDI,and the corresponding photovoltaic performance parameters are shown in Table 4。
图6 基于NDI系列无规聚合物受体

Fig. 6 The structure of NDI series random polymer acceptors

表4 Performance parameters of organic solar cell devices based on random polymer acceptors of NDI and BTI series

Table 4 Device performance of organic solar cells based on NDI and BTI series random polymer acceptors

Active layer VOC /V JSC /mA·cm-2 FF /% PCE /% Ref
copolymer2:PTB7-Th 0.805 9.60 45.1 3.48 52
copolymer3:PTB7-Th 0.790 12.66 48.6 4.86 52
copolymer4:PTB7-Th 0.794 13.75 48.3 5.27 52
PNDI-2FT-0.1:PBDB-T 0.850 16.62 67.1 9.46 53
PNDI-2FT-0.2:PBDB-T 0.848 14.66 64.4 8.05 53
PNDI-2FT-0.3:PBDB-T 0.823 11.91 60.7 5.85 53
0.3-NDI:PBDT(T)TPD 1.04 7.4 59.1 4.6 54
0.5-NDI:PBDT(T)TPD 1.05 9.1 56.1 5.4 54
0.7-NDI:PBDT(T)TPD 1.04 4.1 48.3 2.1 54
BSS10:PBDB-T 0.86 18.55 64 10.1 55
BSS20:PBDB-T 0.86 17.07 65 9.58 55
PNDI-2T-TR(5):PBDB-T 0.86 14.34 64.32 8.13 56
PNDI-2T-TR(10):PBDB-T 0.80 11.36 53.53 4.89 56
PNDI-2FT-TR10:PM6 0.921 17.32 67 10.71 57
PNDI-2FT-TR20:PM6 0.913 14.25 62 8.07 57
NOE10:PBDT-TAZ 0.84 12.9 75 8.1 58
NOE20:PBDT-TAZ 0.83 11.9 73 7.3 58
NOE30:PBDT-TAZ 0.82 10.7 69 6.1 58
BTI2-10TPD:PTB7-Th 1.04 12.72 56.25 7.42 59
BTI2-30TPD:PTB7-Th 1.05 13.56 58.25 8.28 59
BTI2-50TPD:PTB7-Th 1.07 12.23 49.95 6.54 59
BTI2-30BT:PTB7-Th 0.99 12.11 45.80 5.48 60
BTI2-30PhI:PTB7-Th 1.08 12.91 48.75 6.80 60
PBTI2(50DT)-FT:PTB7-Th 1.01 13.96 59.0 8.32 61
thiophene and its derivatives are the most widely used donor units In D-A copolymer acceptors.in 2016,Chen Zhikuan et al.Reported a new random D-A copolymer acceptor PNDI-TT-TVT,which consists of a naphthalene diimine acceptor unit and two donor units,thiophene[2-b]-thiophene(TT)and vinyl-vinyl(TVT)[57]。 this material structure makes the polymer main chain have better coplanarity,reduces the stacking distance between polymer chains,and improves the charge carrier mobility of the blend film.Subsequently,the PCE of the device prepared by blending PNDI-TT-TVT as the polymer acceptor and PTB7-Th as the polymer donor was 4.86%.in addition,In order to systematically understand the structure-property relationship of This random polymer,a series of random polymer PNDI-TT-TVTs were developed by adjusting the ratio of TT/TVT units[58]。 The data show that the absorption spectra of the random polymer in the film and solution state are red-shifted with the increase of the unit amount of TVT.Devices based on random polymer acceptors exhibit higher and more balanced charge mobility than those using the corresponding alternating D-A copolymer acceptors,resulting in significantly improved JSCand device performance.The device fabricated with Copolymer4:PTB7-Th as the active layer material has the highest PCE of 5.27%.In 2021,Chen Yiwang and Chen Lie introduced 3,3'-difluoro-2,2'-bithiophene(2FT)units into NDI-based polymer N2200 by random copolymerization,and synthesized a series of ternary polymer receptors PNDI-2FT-0.1,PNDI-2FT-0.2 and PNDI-2 FT-0.3[59]。 The absorption coefficient of the terpolymer can be significantly improved by adding N2200 backbone to the 2FT unit,and the random copolymerization of 2FT in the backbone can not only reduce the strong aggregation of the polymer,but also has better miscibility with the donor.the device efficiency based on PBDB-T:PNDI-2FT-0.1 reaches 9.46%。
in addition to thiophene and its derivatives,other heterocycles,such as furan and selenophene units,have also been widely used as D units for the construction of NDI-based random polymer acceptors.In 2017,our group developed a series of random polymer acceptors based on NDI,x-NDI,which can optimize the crystallinity,morphology and charge transport characteristics of the blend film by adjusting the ratio of T-NDI/Se-NDI In the polymer backbone[60]。 Among them,the device based on PBDT(T)TPD:0.5-NDI has a higher and more balanced charge mobility with a PCE value of 5.4%.In 2019,Jenekhe et al.Reported the synthesis of a series of new n-type semiconductor random polymers BSSx(X=10,20,50),and found that with the increase of monoselenophene content,the LUMO energy level of the acceptor increased,and the crystallinity decreased.all the All-polymer solar cells based on BSSx:PBDB-T produced efficient photovoltaic performance[61]。 the device based on BSS10 has The highest PCE of 10.1%and internal quantum efficiency of nearly 100%.Chen et al.Designed and synthesized a group of NDI-based polymer acceptors PNDI-2T-TR(5)and PNDI-2T-TR(10)based on rhodanine dyes[62]。 with the addition of the rhodanine-based dye fragment,the absorption coefficient of both random polymer acceptors increases and the LUMO energy level increases compared to the control polymer acceptor N2200.Therefore,the highest efficiency of the all-polymer solar cell based on PBDB-T:PNDI-2T-TR(5)is 8.13%without any additive treatment.In order to further improve the photovoltaic performance of NDI-based polymer acceptors doped With rhodannine-based dyes,Chen et al.Combined the advantages of fluorinated dithiophene and rhodanine dye units to obtain two random polymer acceptors,PNDI-2FT-TR10 and PNDI-2FT-TR20[63]。 with the synergistic effect of fluorine atoms and rhodanine dye molecules,the absorption coefficient of the all-polymer blend film is significantly improved,and the morphology and structure of the blend are optimized.the device based on PM6:PNDI-2FT-TR10 has a PCE of 10.71%.in addition,the introduction of NDI units With different side chain substitutions is also an effective way to construct random polymer acceptors.For example,In 2018,Cao Yong et al.Introduced a certain number of linear oligomeric ethylene oxide(OE)side chains to replace the branched alkyl chains on the NDI unit,and synthesized a series of random polymer acceptors NOEx based on NDI[64]。 Compared with the reference polymer acceptor NOE0,NOE10 has better miscibility with the polymer donor PBDT-TAZ,and the device has a PCE of up to 8.1%and a FF of up to 0.75,with good long-term stability and thermal stability.These results demonstrate the effectiveness of the random copolymerization strategy in fine-tuning the morphology and nanostructure and obtaining efficient imide-based holopolymer materials。

4.2 Random polymer acceptor materials based on BTI series

Because BTI derivatives Have tunable carrier polarity,reduced steric hindrance,extendedπ-electron delocalization,and ideal backbone coplanarity and interchainπ-πstacking,and compared with NDI and PDI,the thiophene ring in the BTI molecule has higher chemical activity and greatly reduced steric hindrance,and the BTI derivative is considered to be a promising acceptor unit in the construction unit of the high-mobility D-A copolymer acceptor material.Guo Xugang et al.have done a lot of excellent research on the development of BTI-based polymer receptors.in order to improve the light absorption and n-type properties,a series of random polymer acceptors based on BTI were also obtained by random copolymerization.Fig.7 shows the corresponding chemical structures of representative BTI-based random polymer acceptor materials,and the corresponding photovoltaic performance parameters are shown in Table 4。
图7 基于BTI系列无规聚合物受体

Fig. 7 The structure of BTI series random polymer acceptors

In 2019,Guo et al.Added different proportions of thienopyrrolidone(TPD)receptor units to the polymer(f-BTI2-FT)to construct a series of random ternary polymer receptors,namely BTI2-xTPD[65]。 Due to the introduction of TPD units,there are intramolecular non-covalent S…O interactions in the main chain of the random polymer,which is beneficial to improve the planarity and charge transport ability of the main chain.When a certain proportion of TPD units was incorporated,the random polymer acceptor BTI2-30TPD had better molecular orientation and better compatibility with the polymer donor compared with the binary polymer.Therefore,the device based on PTB7-Th:BTI2-30TPD has a higher and balanced electron/hole mobility,a device efficiency of up to 8.28%,and good stability.Due to the good efficiency of the above ternary polymer acceptor,they continued to incorporate a certain amount of o-phenylenediamine(PhI)and benzothiadiazole(BT)units into the f-BTI2-FT polymer acceptor,and further designed and synthesized two new random trimers based on BTI2(BTI2-30BT and BTI2-30PhI)[66]。 the three random polymer acceptors BTI2-30BT,BTI2-30PhI,and BTI2-30TPD showed different electrochemical properties and crystallization ability due to the different electron-withdrawing ability and solubility of BT,PhI,and TPD units.the device based on BTI2-30TPD shows the best photovoltaic performance because of its good face-on orientation and the synergistic effect of suitable crystals,and also shows that the selection of suitable electron-withdrawing units is very important In the development of efficient random terpolymer acceptors.in 2020,Guo Xugang et al.Reported a series of random polymer acceptors composed of BTI2-based units substituted by different side chains and fluorinated thiophene units,namely PBTI2(0 HD)-FT,PBTI2(30 HD)-FT,PBTI2(50 HD)-FT and PBTI2(70 HD)-FT[67]。 the morphology of the polymer film is optimized by adjusting the length of the side chain.Among them,the device based on PBTI2(50 HD)-FT:PTB7-Th achieved a high PCE of 8.23%without additives,and had good room temperature stability,retaining 90%of the initial efficiency after 400 H of storage。

4.3 "Small molecule acceptor polymer" random polymer acceptor material

In 2017,Zhang Zhiguo and Li Yongfang first discovered that"PSMA"polymer receptor has the advantages of low band gap and strong absorbance,and proposed the strategy of building a new generation of polymer receptor with"PSMA"[68]。 These types of polymer acceptors not only retain the advantages of small molecular acceptors,such as narrow band gap,strong absorbance and suitable aggregation,but also have the characteristics of good film forming performance,long electron transport channel,adjustable photophysical properties,good thermal stability and photostability,which promote the further development of All-PSCs,and the highest energy conversion efficiency is more than 18%.in recent years,the improvement of photovoltaic performance of"PSMA"polymer receptor has also been achieved by random copolymerization strategy.Fig.8 shows the corresponding chemical structure of the"PSMA"random polymer acceptor material,and the corresponding photovoltaic performance parameters are shown In Table 5。
图8 PSMA系列无规聚合物受体

Fig. 8 The structure of PSMA series random polymer acceptors

表5 Performance parameters of organic solar cell devices based on PSMA series random polymer acceptor materials

Table 5 Device performance of organic solar cells based on PSMA series random copolymer acceptor materials

Active layer VOC /V JSC /mA·cm-2 FF /% PCE/% Ref
PTPBT-ET0.1:PBDB-T 0.855 19.48 62.3 10.37 63
PTPBT-ET0.2:PBDB-T 0.864 20.78 65.5 11.76 63
PTPBT-ET0.3:PBDB-T 0.899 21.33 65.3 12.52 63
PTPBT-ET0.4:PBDB-T 0.900 21.22 55.3 10.56 63
PTPBT-ET0.5:PBDB-T 0.902 18.77 57.5 9.73 63
PTPBT-ET0.75:PBDB-T 0.903 14.50 38.8 5.08 63
PYE10:PBDB-T 0.900 20.93 69.43 13.09 64
PYE20:PBDB-T 0.905 20.97 71.63 13.60 64
PYE30:PBDB-T 0.875 21.63 70.18 13.28 64
PYE40:PBDB-T 0.861 22.24 68.12 13.04 64
PYT-TOE(10): PBDB-T 0.91 21.73 64.63 12.77 65
PYT-TOE(20):PBDB-T 0.91 18.75 61.41 10.49 65
PYT-TOE(30):PBDB-T 0.89 16.74 55.01 8.16 65
PYTS-0.1:PBDB-T 0.92 22.52 68 14.19 66
PYTS-0.3:PBDB-T 0.92 22.91 70 14.68 66
PYTS-0.5:PBDB-T 0.92 14.46 60 7.91 66
PYSe-TCl10:PBDB-T 0.894 22.84 64.3 13.23 67
PYSe-TCl20:PBDB-T 0.902 23.08 68.3 14.21 67
PYSe-TCl30:PBDB-T 0.911 21.02 61.4 11.85 67
PY-91:PM6 0.949 23.66 73.9 16.59 68
PY-82:PM6 0.950 23.82 75.8 17.15 68
PY-73:PM6 0.951 23.53 75.0 16.78 68
PA1-o:PM6 0.925 23.99 72.2 16.0 69
PYTH-A:PM6 0.943 22.89 71.28 15.39 70
PYTCl-B:PM6 0.942 23.49 73.04 16.16 70
PYTH-A:PM6 0.937 20.35 68.78 13.12 70
PYTCl-B:PM6 0.935 20.76 70.14 13.61 70
PY-0.1OBO:PM6 0.967 24.4 67.0 15.9 71
PY-0.2OBO:PM6 0.972 25.1 67.9 16.7 71
PY-0.3OBO:PM6 0.977 24.1 68.1 15.9 71
PY-0.5OBO:PM6 0.991 19.1 69.1 13.2 71
In 2020,Li Yongfang ET al.Designed and synthesized a series of"PSMA"random polymer acceptors by adding a certain amount of 3-ester thiophene(ET)units as the third unit in the main chain of polymer PTPBT PTPBT-ETx(where X is the molar ratio of ET units )[69]。 The ternary polymer PTPBT-ETxhas better solubility,higher LUMO energy level,higher and balanced charge mobility and more excellent morphological structure when blended with the corresponding donor.Finally,the all-polymer solar cell based on PBDB-T:PTPBT-ET0.3achieves an energy conversion efficiency of 12.52%,and has good photostability,which can reach more than 300 H without significant decline.At the same time,Min Jie et al.Also reported a similar study,which used different side alkyl chain substitutions in the TPBT unit[70]。 the device based on PYE20:PBDB-T has the highest PCE of 13.6%.And,they found that all the random polymer acceptor-based all-polymer cells had good efficiencies of more than 13%,indicating the high tolerance of the original polymer to the addition of et units.In addition,Yang ET al.Used random polymerization to introduce a simple thiophene with an oligomeric ethylene oxide side chain(TOE)as the third unit into the D-A copolymer PYT to obtain a series of novel random polymers PYT-TOE(X)(X represents the molar ratio of TOE units)[71]。 The electron-rich unit TOE directly replaces the electron-deficient unit Y5,which realizes the improvement of LUMO energy level.More importantly,an appropriate amount of TOE units can not only adjust the solubility and molecular arrangement of polymer acceptors,but also improve the compatibility between polymer donors and acceptors.Optimized crystallinity andπ-πstacking of the blend films were thus obtained,favoring charge transfer and better film morphology.Finally,with the simultaneous improvement of Jsc,Vocand FF,the device energy conversion efficiency increases from 11.75%for PBDBT:PYT to 12.77%for PBDB-T:PYT-TOE(10).In 2021,Wang Ergang et al.Copolymerized thiophene linked by thioalkyl chain as the third unit with thiophene and Y5 unit to obtain a series of ternary polymers PYTS-x[72]。 The addition of FCBS(thiophene linked by non-conjugated thioalkyl chain)can significantly improve the solubility and molecular flexibility of the polymer acceptor,resulting In a good temperature-dependent aggregation of the polymer,resulting in a better crystallinity and charge mobility of the acceptor in the film,and the device efficiency based on PYTS-0.3:PBDB-T is as high as 14.68%.in 2022,Chen Yiwang et al.Designed and synthesized a series of ternary polymers PYSe-TClx(X represents the molar ratio of TCl units)by copolymerizing selenophene as the bridging unit and 3-chlorothiophene(TCl)as the third unit with Y5 unit.Due to the ternary copolymerization,the aggregation degree of the polymer PYSe-TClx is significantly reduced,and the energy level is shifted up.the device efficiency of All-PSC based on PYSe-TCl20 is as high as 14.21%[73]
the method of introducing another electron-withdrawing unit as the third unit was also successfully used to construct random"PSMA"polymer acceptors.Recently,inspired by the successful research on modifying the branched side chain of Y6 receptor,Sun Yanming et al.Developed a series of random polymer receptors by introducing Y6 derivatives with branched side chain substitution as the third unit[74]。 and it was found that controlling the molecular ratio of the SMA-DT unit can effectively lead to tunable optical and electrical properties of the resulting random polymer PSMA receptor.Therefore,the device based on PY-82:PM6 exhibits excellent photovoltaic performance with a PCE of 17.15%,which belongs to the higher value among binary all-polymer solar cells.In addition,the PY-82-based device also has extremely low non-radiative energy loss(0.185 V)and excellent photostability.At the same time,Li Yongfang et al.Used this strategy to synthesize PSMA polymer acceptor PA1-by asymmetric copolymerization of two SMA building units and thiophene linker units[75]。 the device efficiency of the PM6:PA1-based solar cell is up to 16.0%.in 2022,Chen et al.introduced flexible non-conjugated units into the main chain of polymer PYSe to synthesize PYTCl-A,PYTCl-B,PYTH-A and PYTH-B polymer acceptors.the study showed that the introduction of non-conjugated units into the main chain through ternary random copolymerization could effectively inhibit the excessive aggregation behavior of polymer acceptors In the active layer during printing,and the device efficiency based on PM6:PYTCl-a was 16.16%[76]。 In 2023,Wei et al.Proposed a new type of terpolymer receptor,which was synthesized by random copolymerization of thiophene units and dithieno-thieno-pyrrolo-benzothiadiazole(BTP)core with alkoxy side chain(BTPO-IC)and alkyl side chain(BTP-IC).It was found that the open-circuit voltage of the device based on this terpolymer increased gradually with the increase of the molar ratio of BTPO-IC units[77]。 the device efficiency based on PM6:PY-0.2OBO is as high as 16.7%.The results show that random copolymerization is a simple and efficient method for The synthesis of high performance"PSMA"polymer acceptors。

5 Application of random copolymerization in the stability of OSCs

in addition to device efficiency,the stability of OSCs is another important factor that must be considered for their industrial application.the stability of photovoltaic devices with strict packaging can be maintained up to 40 000 H(about 4.5 years),while the performance of unpackaged devices will decline rapidly In just a few hours or even shorter.the photoactive layer is the core component of OSCs,and the stability of the material itself and the morphology of the active layer largely determine the stability of OSCs.the ternary random strategy can not only improve the device efficiency of OSCs,but also ensure their stability to a certain extent。
In the reported work of our group,the D-A-D-D1type cross-linkable polymer PM6-Ax was obtained by introducing the cross-linkable group(vinyl)as the third unit component(D1)into the D-a copolymer PM6[37]。 the cross-linked PM6-A5:Y6 active layer has excellent morphology,and the efficiency retention of the device after continuous annealing at 100℃and 150℃for 48 H is 120.1%and 91.6%,respectively.in addition,the cross-linked device based on PM6-A5:Y6 retains 92.8%of its initial PCE after continuous white LED illumination for 72 H.In 2023,our research group reported that the degree of molecular self-assembly of ternary polymer PM6-Ox donor In Y6 blend film was higher than that of PM6:Y6 blend film,and the aggregation phase of the blend film with appropriate size constructed a clear phase separation structure.Thus achieving a higher exciton dissociation constant and better charge transfer,and the rich S…O interactions within PM6-O5 can reduce the loss of conjugated polymer under prolonged illumination[39]。 Therefore,the PM6-O5:Y6 device exhibits excellent photostability,thermal stability,and room temperature storage stability.in addition,Zhang Maojie et al.Synthesized a series of ternary polymers PMZ1,PMZ2 and PMZ3 by using the ternary copolymerization strategy.Due to the existence of intramolecular forces of N…S and O…H,the trimer shows superior molecular planarity,which makes the molecular packing closer.In addition,it skillfully reduces the miscibility,which helps to obtain more obvious phase separation In the blend film[26]。 Therefore,the device based on PMZ2:Y6 not only has higher efficiency,but also shows better thermal stability than the PM6:Y6 system,which maintains an initial PCE of 79%after heating at 85℃for 66 H。
Based on the degradation principle of OSCs,organic photovoltaic materials(such as MDMO-PPV)are usually degraded by a two-step oxidation mechanism,and the oxidation reaction usually occurs at the ether substituent and the double bond[78]。 even in the absence of oxygen and water vapor,the existence of photocatalytic reaction will lead to the decomposition of organic photovoltaic materials,and photocatalysis and photooxidation usually proceed according to the free radical mechanism.in addition to the photostability,the thermal stability of the active layer material can also significantly affect the lifetime of OSCs,due to the molecular conformation and BHJ blend film morphology,which largely determine the exciton separation and carrier transport properties.the temperature at which OSCs begin to degrade is closely related to the glass transition temperature of the active layer material.When the temperature is higher than the glass transition temperature,polymer chains and molecules will move in the active layer film,causing molecular rearrangement and Even molecular dimerization or polymerization[79]。 Therefore,the ternary random copolymerization strategy can effectively use the conformational locking between atoms(such as S…O,H…F,etc.),molecular crosslinking,molecular functionalization and other methods to improve the optical/thermal stability of the material and control the morphology of the active layer,and ultimately improve the internal stability of the device。

6 Conclusion and prospect

in recent years,the application of random copolymerization strategy In the active layer of polymer solar cells has promoted the development of organic photovoltaics,especially for the polymer donors PM6 and D18,and the modification design of"small molecule acceptor polymer"polymer acceptor has made immeasurable achievements。
A third structural unit is introduced into the main chain of the high-performance D-a copolymer by adopting a random copolymerization strategy,and the molecular energy level,the crystallinity,the absorption coefficient and the molecular aggregation strength of the polymer are accurately regulated and controlled by regulating the introduction amount of the third structural unit,it can effectively optimize the spectral response range of the active layer material and fine-tune the energy level structure of the donor and acceptor molecules.more importantly,this method can also effectively regulate and optimize the morphology of the active layer,improve the charge transfer efficiency,and ultimately improve the energy conversion efficiency of the organic solar cell.the random copolymerization strategy can also be improved in the following aspects:(1)efficient synthesis methods.It should not only have low synthesis cost,but also be green and environmentally friendly.efficient synthetic methods with fewer steps,fewer toxic reagents,and higher reaction yields are essential for the future commercial application of OPV technology.(2)design a novel third component unit.In view of the current development of PSCs,the Design of a novel third unit with a simple structure can be More effective and convenient to construct efficient random polymers.Therefore,attention should be paid to the development and utilization of new heterocyclic units with simple structures.and(3)that energy Los of the device is reduced.Although OPV technology has achieved good results,the photovoltaic efficiency of PSCs needs to be improved compared with silicon-based and perovskite solar cells.the random copolymerization strategy can be used to effectively adjust the molecular conformation,aggregation characteristics and energy level of polymer materials to reduce energy loss.In the future,with the help of continuous innovation of organic synthesis methods and continuous optimization of device preparation processes,the commercialization of organic solar cells is no longer an unrealizable dream,and It is expected to become an important force in optimizing the national energy structure and promoting the country's green and sustainable development。
[1]
Meng D, Zheng R, Zhao Y P, Zhang E, Dou L T, Yang Y. Adv. Mater., 2022, 34(10): 2107330.

[2]
Zhang B, Yang F, Chen S S, Chen H Y, Zeng G, Shen Y X, Li Y W, Li Y F. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(29): 2202011.

[3]
Zhou K K, Xian K H, Qi Q C, Gao M Y, Peng Z X, Liu J W, Liu Y, Li S M, Zhang Y D, Geng Y H, Ye L. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(30): 2201781.

[4]
Li T F, Zhan X W. Acta Chim. Sin., 2021, 79(3): 257.

[5]
Zhu L, Zhang M, Xu J Q, Li C, Yan J, Zhou G Q, Zhong W K, Hao T Y, Song J L, Xue X N, Zhou Z C, Zeng R, Zhu H M, Chen C C, MacKenzie R C I, Zou Y C, Nelson J, Zhang Y M, Sun Y M, Liu F. Nat. Mater., 2022, 21(6): 656.

[6]
Wang J, Zheng Z, Bi P, Chen Z, Wang Y, Liu X, Zhang S, Hao X, Zhang M, Li Y, Hou J. Natl. Sci. Rev., 2023, 10(6): nwad085.

[7]
Tang C W. Appl. Phys. Lett., 1986, 48(2): 183.

[8]
Sariciftci N S, Smilowitz L, Heeger A J, Wudl F. Science, 1992, 258(5087): 1474.

[9]
Lin Y Z, Wang J Y, Zhang Z G, Bai H T, Li Y F, Zhu D B, Zhan X W. Adv. Mater., 2015, 27(7): 1170.

[10]
Yuan J, Zhang Y Q, Zhou L Y, Zhang G C, Yip H L, Lau T K, Lu X H, Zhu C, Peng H J, Johnson P A, Leclerc M, Cao Y, Ulanski J, Li Y F, Zou Y P. Joule, 2019, 3(4): 1140.

[11]
Yan C Q, Barlow S, Wang Z H, Yan H, Jen A K Y, Marder S R, Zhan X W. Nat. Rev. Mater., 2018, 3(3): 18003.

[12]
Wang J Y, Xue P Y, Jiang Y T, Huo Y, Zhan X W. Nat. Rev. Chem., 2022, 6(9): 614.

[13]
Cheng P, Li G, Zhan X W, Yang Y. Nat. Photonics, 2018, 12(3): 131.

[14]
Cui Y, Yao H F, Hong L, Zhang T, Xu Y, Xian K H, Gao B W, Qin J Z, Zhang J Q, Wei Z X, Hou J H. Adv. Mater., 2019, 31(14): 1808356.

[15]
Sun H L, Liu T, Yu J W, Lau T K, Zhang G Y, Zhang Y J, Su M Y, Tang Y M, Ma R J, Liu B, Liang J E, Feng K, Lu X H, Guo X G, Gao F, Yan H. Energy Environ. Sci., 2019, 12(11): 3328.

[16]
Xu Y X, Ji Q, Yin L Q, Zhang N, Liu T, Li N, He X C, Wen G Z, Zhang W, Yu L Y, Murto P, Xu X F. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2021, 13(20): 23993.

[17]
An Q S, Wang J W, Ma X L, Gao J H, Hu Z H, Liu B, Sun H L, Guo X G, Zhang X L, Zhang F J. Energy Environ. Sci., 2020, 13(12): 5039.

[18]
Lu J Y, Wu J R, Huang B, Fang Y, Deng X M, Zhang J L, Chen S S, Jeong S, Liu J B, Yang C. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2024, 34(13): 2312545.

[19]
Guo Q, Lin J, Dong X L, Zhu L, Guo X, Liu F, Zhang M J. Chem. Eng. J., 2022, 431: 134117.

[20]
Cheng F L, Cui Y J, Ding F, Chen Z, Xie Q, Xia X X, Zhu P P, Lu X H, Zhu H M, Liao X F, Chen Y W. Adv. Mater., 2023, 35(30): 2300820.

[21]
Rehman Z U, Haris M, Ryu S U, Jahankhan M, Song C E, Lee H K, Lee S K, Shin W S, Park T, Lee J C. Adv. Sci., 2023, 10(24): 2302376.

[22]
Wu J N, Li G W, Fang J, Guo X, Zhu L, Guo B, Wang Y L, Zhang G Y, Arunagiri L, Liu F, Yan H, Zhang M J, Li Y F. Nat. Commun., 2020, 11: 4612.

[23]
Guo X, Fan Q P, Wu J N, Li G W, Peng Z X, Su W Y, Lin J, Hou L T, Qin Y P, Ade H, Ye L, Zhang M J, Li Y F. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2021, 60(5): 2322.

[24]
Liao Z H, Yang K, Hou L C, Li J, Lv J, Singh R, Kumar M, Chen Q Q, Dong X Y, Xu T L, Hu C, Duan T N, Kan Z P, Lu S R, Xiao Z Y. Macromolecules, 2020, 53(20): 9034.

[25]
Zhou L Y, Meng L, Zhang J Y, Zhu C, Qin S C, Angunawela I, Wan Y, Ade H, Li Y F. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(8): 2109271.

[26]
Wu J N, Guo X, Xiong M H, Xia X X, Li Q, Fang J, Yan X, Liu Q, Lu X H, Wang E G, Yu D H, Zhang M J. Chem. Eng. J., 2022, 446: 137424.

[27]
Cheng Y J, Jin H, Oh J, Huang X X, Lv R Z, Huang B, Ma Z F, Yang C, Chen L, Chen Y W. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2021, 9(14): 9238.

[28]
Zhang T, An C B, Lv Q L, Qin J Z, Cui Y, Zheng Z, Xu B W, Zhang S Q, Zhang J Q, He C, Hou J H. J. Energy Chem., 2021, 59: 30.

[29]
Jeong M, Oh J, Cho Y, Lee B, Jeong S, Lee S M, Kang S H, Yang C D. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2021, 31(35): 2102371.

[30]
Zhang T, Xu Y, Yao H F, Zhang J Q, Bi P Q, Chen Z H, Wang J W, Cui Y, Ma L J, Xian K H, Li Z, Hao X T, Wei Z X, Hou J H. Energy Environ. Sci., 2023, 16(4): 1581.

[31]
Lee J W, Jeong D, Kim D J, Phan T N L, Park J S, Kim T S, Kim B J. Energy Environ. Sci., 2021, 14(7): 4067.

[32]
Yang T Y, Liao C T, Duan Y W, Xu X P, Deng M, Yu L Y, Li R P, Peng Q. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(51): 2208950.

[33]
Pang B, Liao C T, Xu X P, Peng S Q, Xia J L, Guo Y Y, Xie Y, Chen Y T, Duan C H, Wu H B, Li R P, Peng Q. Adv. Mater., 2023, 35(17): 2211871.

[34]
Wang T, Sun R, Shi M M, Pan F, Hu Z C, Huang F, Li Y F, Min J. Adv. Energy Mater., 2020, 10(22): 2000590.

[35]
Shang Z Y, Zhou L Y, Sun C K, Meng L, Lai W B, Zhang J Y, Huang W C, Li Y F. Sci. China Chem., 2021, 64(6): 1031.

[36]
Deng X M, Fang Y, Huang B, Liao F M, Liu K M, Zhang J L, Chen S S, Kim S, Yang C, Ye D N, Liu J B, Chen L. Chem. Commun., 2022, 58(84): 11823.

[37]
Tu S L, Lin X, Xiao L R, Zhen H Y, Wang W, Ling Q D. Mater. Chem. Front., 2022, 6(9): 1150.

[38]
Tu S L, Zhang L, Lin X, Xiao L R, Wang W, Ling Q D. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2022, 10(6): 2026.

[39]
Lin X, Tu S L, Xiao L R, Zhen H Y, Wang W, Ling Q D. Chem. Eng. J., 2023, 464: 142634.

[40]
Liu Q S, Jiang Y F, Jin K, Qin J Q, Xu J G, Li W T, Xiong J, Liu J F, Xiao Z, Sun K, Yang S F, Zhang X T, Ding L M. Sci. Bull., 2020, 65(4): 272.

[41]
Bai H R, An Q S, Zhi H F, Jiang M Y, Mahmood A, Yan L, Liu M Q, Liu Y Q, Wang Y, Wang J L. ACS Energy Lett., 2022, 7(9): 3045.

[42]
Liao Z H, Hu D Q, Tang H, Huang P H, Singh R, Chung S, Cho K, Kumar M, Hou L C, Chen Q Q, Yu W Y, Chen H Y, Yang K, Kan Z P, Liu F, Xiao Z Y, Li G, Lu S R. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2022, 10(14): 7878.

[43]
Lu H, Wang H, Ran G L, Li S, Zhang J Q, Liu Y H, Zhang W K, Xu X J, Bo Z S. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(34): 2203193.

[44]
Wang H, Lu H, Chen Y N, Zhang A D, Liu Y Q, Li D W, Liu Y H, Xu X J, Bo Z S. Adv. Energy Mater., 2022, 12(16): 2104028.

[45]
Wang Q, Li M M, Peng Z X, Kirby N, Deng Y F, Ye L, Geng Y H. Sci. China Chem., 2021, 64(3): 478.

[46]
Yuan X Y, Zhao Y L, Xie D S, Pan L H, Liu X Y, Duan C H, Huang F, Cao Y. Joule, 2022, 6(3): 647.

[47]
Liao S H, Jhuo H J, Cheng Y S, Chen S A. Adv. Mater., 2013, 25(34): 4766.

[48]
Huang X X, Zhang L F, Cheng Y J, Oh J, Li C Q, Huang B, Zhao L, Deng J W, Zhang Y H, Liu Z J, Wu F Y, Hu X T, Yang C, Chen L, Chen Y W. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(5): 2108634.

[49]
Liu Y H, Zhao J B, Li Z K, Mu C, Ma W, Hu H W, Jiang K, Lin H R, Ade H, Yan H. Nat. Commun., 2014, 5: 5293.

[50]
Pan F L, Luo M, Liu X C, Jiang H Y, Wang Z, Yuan D, Wang Q, Qing L C, Zhang Z S, Zhang L J, Zou Y P, Chen J W. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2021, 9(11): 7129.

[51]
Min J, Zhang Z G, Zhang S Y, Li Y F. Chem. Mater., 2012, 24(16): 3247.

[52]
Wang X C, Dou K K, Shahid B, Liu Z L, Li Y H, Sun M L, Zheng N, Bao X C, Yang R Q. Chem. Mater., 2019, 31(16): 6163.

[53]
Li X M, Liang Z Z, Wang H, Qiao S L, Liu Z L, Jiang H X, Chen W C, Yang R Q. J. Mater. Chem. A, 2020, 8(3): 1360.

[54]
Guo X, Fan Q, Cui C, Zhang Z, Zhang M J. Acta Phys.-Chim. Sin., 2018, 34(11): 1279.

[55]
Dai S X, Huang S, Yu H F, Ling Q D, Zhan X W. J. Polym. Sci. Part A Polym. Chem., 2017, 55(4): 682.

[56]
Dai S X, Cheng P, Lin Y Z, Wang Y F, Ma L C, Ling Q D, Zhan X W. Polym. Chem., 2015, 6(29): 5254.

[57]
Li X Z, Sun P, Wang Y L, Shan H Q, Xu J J, Song X, Xu Z X, Chen Z K. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2016, 4(11): 2106.

[58]
Li X Z, Sun P, Wang Y L, Shan H Q, Xu J J, You C, Xu Z X, Chen Z K. Polym. Chem., 2016, 7(12): 2230.

[59]
Chen D, Liu S Q, Liu J L, Han J H, Chen L, Chen Y W. ACS Appl. Polym. Mater., 2021, 3(4): 1923.

[60]
Zhang T, Lu M X, Wang W, Lv W, Cui J Y, Feng W H, Ling Q D. Dyes Pigm., 2017, 146: 169.

[61]
Kolhe N B, Tran D K, Lee H, Kuzuhara D, Yoshimoto N, Koganezawa T, Jenekhe S A. ACS Energy Lett., 2019, 4(5): 1162.

[62]
Chen D, Yao J, Chen L, Yin J P, Lv R Z, Huang B, Liu S Q, Zhang Z G, Yang C H, Chen Y W, Li Y F. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2018, 57(17): 4580.

[63]
Chen D, Liu S Q, Oh J, Huang B, Lv R Z, Liu J B, Yang C, Chen L. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2021, 13(15): 17892.

[64]
Liu X, Zhang C H, Duan C H, Li M M, Hu Z C, Wang J, Liu F, Li N, Brabec C J, Janssen R A J, Bazan G C, Huang F, Cao Y. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2018, 140(28): 8934.

[65]
Sun H L, Liu B, Koh C W, Zhang Y J, Chen J H, Wang Y, Chen P, Tu B, Su M Y, Wang H, Tang Y M, Shi Y Q, Woo H Y, Guo X G. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2019, 29(42): 1903970.

[66]
Liu B, Sun H L, Koh C W, Su M Y, Tu B, Tang Y M, Liao Q G, Wang J W, Yang W L, Meng H, Woo H Y, Guo X G. Org. Mater., 2020, 2(3): 214.

[67]
Sun H L, Liu B, Wang Z Y, Ling S H, Zhang Y J, Zhang G Y, Wang Y, Zhang M, Li B L, Yang W L, Wang J W, Guo H, Liu F, Guo X G. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2020, 8(12): 4012.

[68]
Zhang Z G, Li Y F. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed., 2020, 60(9): 4422.

[69]
Du J Q, Hu K, Meng L, Angunawela I, Zhang J Y, Qin S C, Liebman-Pelaez A, Zhu C H, Zhang Z J, Ade H, Li Y F. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2020, 59(35): 15181.

[70]
Wu Y, Wu Q, Wang W, Sun R, Min J. Sol. RRL, 2020, 4(11): 2000409.

[71]
Wu F Y, Liu J L, Liu J B, Oh J, Huang B, Chen D, Liu Z J, He Q N, Yang C, Chen L D. ChemElectroChem, 2021, 8(20): 3936.

[72]
Genene Z, Lee J W, Lee S W, Chen Q N, Tan Z P, Abdulahi B A, Yu D H, Kim T S, Kim B J, Wang E G. Adv. Mater., 2022, 34(6): 2107361.

[73]
Chen D, Liu S Q, Huang B, Oh J, Wu F Y, Liu J B, Yang C, Chen L, Chen Y W. Small, 2022, 18(20): 2200734.

[74]
Li Y, Li Q, Cai Y H, Jin H, Zhang J Q, Tang Z, Zhang C F, Wei Z X, Sun Y M. Energy Environ. Sci., 2022, 15(9): 3854.

[75]
Du J Q, Hu K, Zhu C, Zhang J Q, Zhang Z J, Wei Z X, Meng L, Li Y F. Macromolecules, 2022, 55(17): 7481.

[76]
Liu J B, Deng J W, Zhu Y Y, Geng X K, Zhang L F, Jeong S Y, Zhou D, Woo H Y, Chen D, Wu F Y, Chen L. Adv. Mater., 2023, 35(1): 2208008.

[77]
Lin Y C, Chen C H, Tsai B S, Hsueh T F, Tsao C S, Tan S, Chang B, Chang Y N, Chu T Y, Tsai C E, Chen C S, Yang Y, Wei K H. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2023, 33(26): 2215095.

[78]
Rivaton A, Chambon S, Manceau M, Gardette J L, Lemaître N, Guillerez S. Polym. Degrad. Stab., 2010, 95(3): 278.

[79]
Wang K, Li Y, Li Y. Macromolecular Rapid Communications, 2020, 41(4): 1900437.

Outlines

/