Home Journals Progress in Chemistry
Progress in Chemistry

Abbreviation (ISO4): Prog Chem      Editor in chief: Jincai ZHAO

About  /  Aim & scope  /  Editorial board  /  Indexed  /  Contact  / 
Review

Rare EarthDoped Lead Halide Perovskites: Synthesis, Properties and RadiationDetectors

  • Weiran Chen ,
  • Lin Ma , * ,
  • Ting Zhao ,
  • Zhengguang Yan ,
  • Jiawen Xiao ,
  • Zhenzhong Wang ,
  • Xiaodong Han , *
Expand
  • Institute of Microstructure and Property of Advanced Materials, Beijing Key Lab of Microstructure and Property of Advanced Materials, Faculty of Materials and Manufacturing, Beijing University of Technology,Beijing 100124, China, Beijing 100020, China
*Corresponding author e-mail: (Lin Ma);
(Xiaodong Han)

Received date: 2023-04-07

  Revised date: 2023-09-17

  Online published: 2023-11-30

Supported by

National Natural Science Foundation of China(12174016)

National Key R&D Program of China(2021YFA1200201)

Beijing Outstanding Young Scientists Projects(BJJWZYJH01201910005018)

Beijing Postdoctoral Research Foundation(Q6009A03202301)

Abstract

In recent years, lead halide perovskites have shown excellent performance in photovoltaic devices and photodetectors due to its excellent semiconductor properties and have become a hot spot in materials science.Doping rare earth elements is a promising way to improve the performances of lead halide perovskites. In this paper, we review the latest research progress of rare earths doped lead halide perovskite materials in the preparation, structures, properties, as well as radiation detectors. The doped rare earths introduce new luminescent centers and energy levels for new luminescence properties, improving the crystallinity and semiconductor performances of perovskite crystals. Therefore, rare earth doping can further improve the performance of lead halide perovskite radiation detectors.

Contents

1 Introduction

2 Growth and structure of rare earth doped lead halides perovskites

2.1 rare earth ions and Rare earth doped lead halides perovskites

2.2 Synthesis of rare earth-doped lead halides perovskites

2.3 Effect of rare earth ions on the growth and structure of perovskite

2.4 Composition distribution and doping sites of rare earth ions in lead halide perovskite

3 Luminescence properties of rare earth doped lead halides perovskites

3.1 Introducing the luminous centers of rare earth ions

3.2 Enhanced emission of perovskite matrix

4 Semiconductor electrical properties of rare earth doped lead halides perovskites

4.1 Theoretical study on electrical doping of lead perovskite halide by rare earth ions

4.2 Experimental study on electrical doping of lead perovskite halide by rare earth ions

5 Application of rare earth Ions doped lead halides perovskite crystals in radiation detection

5.1 Brief introduction of perovskite radiation detection

5.2 Rare earth doped lead perovskite halide radiation radiation detector

6 Conclusion and prospect

Cite this article

Weiran Chen , Lin Ma , Ting Zhao , Zhengguang Yan , Jiawen Xiao , Zhenzhong Wang , Xiaodong Han . Rare EarthDoped Lead Halide Perovskites: Synthesis, Properties and RadiationDetectors[J]. Progress in Chemistry, 2023 , 35(12) : 1864 -1880 . DOI: 10.7536/PC230404

1 Introduction

In recent years, Lead halide perovskites (LHPs) have shown excellent performance in solar cells, radiation detectors and other fields. Lead halide perovskites in the narrow sense have a similar crystal structure to traditional oxide perovskites such as SrTiO3 (Fig. 1): the chemical formula is APbX3,A with sites Cs+, CH3NH3+ (methylamine,MA+), CH(NH2)2+ (formamidine,The FA+),X bits are Cl-, Br-, I-.
图1 钙钛矿(ABX3)晶体结构

Fig. 1 The crystal structure of perovskites (ABX3)

In a broad sense, lead halide perovskites can be divided into three-dimensional (3D) versus low-dimensional perovskites (0 D, 1 D, 2D) according to the different connection modes between the coordination octahedra containing [BX6][1,2]. The 3D perovskites are connected in three dimensions by octahedral co-vertices, and the A-site cations are located in the interstices between the octahedra. If a larger-sized organic molecule is used as the A-site ion, such as C4N2H142+, the size cannot be accommodated in the gap, so that the [BX6] octahedron becomes a low-dimensional connection accordingly[3]. For example, 2D perovskite, with the chemical formula of ABX5, its [BX6] octahedra are connected only in the two-dimensional direction, while the upper and lower vertices are not shared, forming a layered structure, and the A-site ions are located between every two layers[4]. The 1D perovskite structure is composed of coordinated octahedra connected by points, edges, or planes to form straight or zigzag chains, which are separated by A-site ions[5]. In 0 D perovskite, the octahedra are completely isolated and not connected to each other[6]. Goldschmidt tolerance factor (Goldschmidt's tolerance factor) is used to evaluate the stability of perovskite structure, which can predict potential new perovskite materials[7]. Due to the variety of ions, this kind of metal halide perovskite materials has the diversity of composition and structure, which provides a wide range of possibilities for material design.
Since 2008, the energy conversion efficiency (PCE) of organic-inorganic perovskite thin film solar cells has repeatedly reached new heights, and the device stability has been continuously improved[8,9]. According to the report of the Renewable Energy Laboratory of the United States, the conversion efficiency of single heterojunction solar cells with organic-inorganic perovskite as the absorber layer reaches 25.5%, while the efficiency of perovskite/silicon tandem solar cells reaches 29.15%[8]. Such high energy conversion efficiency is comparable to other conventional photovoltaic materials, such as polysilicon, cadmium telluride (CdTe), gallium arsenide (GaAs), and copper indium gallium selenide (CuInGaSe2).
At the same time, organic-inorganic perovskites also shine in other optoelectronic fields, such as light-emitting diodes, lasers, photodetectors, transistors, X-ray scintillators and so on[10~13]. The excellent performance of perovskite devices is attributed to the advantages of the material itself: tunable band gap, low defect density, high carrier mobility, large diffusion length and so on.

2 Growth and Structure of Rare Earth Doped Lead Halide Perovskite

2.1 Rare Earth Ions and Rare Earth Doped Lead Halide Perovskite

Rare earth (RE) element is a general term for Sc, Y and 15 lanthanide elements[14]. Rare earth ions are often used as dopants to improve the physical and chemical properties of materials, and are widely used in magnetism, luminescence and other fields[15]. The ionic radii of lanthanides decrease with increasing atomic number, from La3+(106 pm) to Lu3+(85 pm).
Lanthanides have either a 4fn-15d16s2 or a 4fn6s2 electronic configuration. It is necessary to lose valence electrons when participating in chemical reactions, because the 4F orbital is effectively shielded by the outer electrons, and because of the E4f<E5d, in the case of 4fn6s2, f electrons must first jump from the 4F orbital to the 5d orbital to participate in the reaction. The chemical activity of elements is different because of the different electronic configuration and the different excitation energy. Therefore, the doped rare earth ions can modulate the electrical properties of the perovskite semiconductor on the basis of maintaining its original band gap. Except for Sc3+, Y3+, La3+ and Lu3+, which are optically inert due to the absence or full filling of 4F layer electrons, the rest of the rare earth ions have abundant transition energy levels, so their luminescence properties can be controlled by doping.

2.2 Process for preparing rare earth doped lead halide perovskite

The forms of lead halide perovskite materials include thin films, powders, single crystals and nanocrystals. The doping method of rare earth ions is usually to add rare earth ions in the raw materials or precursors. Doping occurs during the growth of crystalline materials, and its possible sites include lattice, defects, grain boundaries, or surfaces. In addition, doping can also be achieved by post-treatment methods such as ion exchange and surface treatment after the crystal growth is completed.

2.2.1 Preparation of polycrystalline thin films of rare earth doped lead halide perovskite.

Spin Coating Method and Vapor Deposition Method are commonly used in the preparation of rare earth doped perovskite thin films[16].
The spin coating method is to spin coat the perovskite precursor solution on the substrate, and then heat or introduce an antisolvent to increase the supersaturation of the precursor solution to induce crystallization to form a dense and uniform film (Figure 1A). Duan et al. Finally obtained CsPbBr3:RE3+(RE3+=Yb3+, Er3+, Ho3+, Tb3+, Sm3+) films by spin coating rare earth ions with lead bromide in N, N-dimethylformamide followed by addition of cesium bromide in alcohol[17].
Spin coating is a common method for preparing halide and oxide perovskite thin films, which has the advantages of small and controllable film thickness, high surface flatness, high crystallinity, few defects, low pollution, large yield and high efficiency. At present, this method has been widely used in the preparation of solar cell films and other films[18].
Vapor deposition methods include multi-source co-deposition and single-source deposition, in which raw materials are transported in vapor phase to form a coating on the surface of a substrate. Crane et al. Prepared CsPb(Cl1-xBrx)3:Yb3+ thin films using a single-source vapor deposition method[19]. The CsPb(Cl1-xBrx)3:Yb3+ powder was selected as the raw material, and the thin films with the thickness of 50 – 1000 nm were obtained by heating and sublimation.
Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) is a technology that uses gaseous or vaporous substances to react in the gas phase or at the gas-solid interface to form solid deposits. This technology has the advantages of simple operation and controllable reaction, so it is widely used in high-quality material synthesis experiments[20].

2.2.2 Preparation of rare earth doped lead halide perovskite powder

The main methods of synthesizing perovskite powder are Mechanochemical Synthesis Method, Thermal Annealing Method and Precipitation Method[21].
The mechanochemical method usually uses a ball mill (Fig. 2C) or a mortar to grind halide raw materials to prepare perovskite powder. For example, Aleksanyan et al. Prepared CsPbI3:Nd3+ powder by ball milling, and found that NdI3 doping could prevent phase transformation[22].
图2 典型的钙钛矿晶体合成手段。 (a) 旋涂法, (b) 气相沉积法, (c) 机械化学研磨法, (d) 沉淀法, (e) 布里奇曼法, (f) 水热法, (g) 反溶剂蒸发辅助结晶法, (h) 逆温结晶法, (i) 热注入法, (j) 配体辅助沉淀法合成纳米晶体

Fig. 2 Typical synthesis methods for perovskite crystals. (a) Spin coating method, (b) Vapor deposition method, (c) Mechanochemical synthesis method, (d) Precipitation method, (e) Bridgman method, (f) Hydrothermal method, (g) Antisolvent vapor-assisted method, AVC, (h) Inverse temperature crystallization method, ITC, (i) Thermal injection method, HI, (j) Ligand assisted precipitation method, LARP

The thermal annealing method is to place the halide raw materials at a high temperature so that they can fully diffuse and react to form perovskite powder. Stefanski et al. Selected YbCl3·6H2O as the rare earth doping source and synthesized CsPbCl3:Yb3+ powder by thermal annealing[23]. A small amount of methanol is added to the raw materials, mixed, ground and evaporated, and then the mixture is thermally annealed to obtain the CsPbCl3:Yb3+ powder.
The precipitation method is to obtain perovskite powder by cooling and stirring the precursor or dropping the precursor into an antisolvent and then rapidly precipitating the precursor (fig. 2D). Dagnall et al. Used cesium chloride and lead chloride as raw materials and YbCl3·6H2O as rare earth doping raw materials[24]. Tirring and evaporating to obtain intermediate powder, grinding the intermediate powder, and annealing at high temperature to obtain CsPbCl3:Yb3+ powder.
The advantage of precipitation method is that it is easy to prepare nano-powder materials with small particle size and uniform distribution. However, the disadvantage is that the addition of precipitant may cause local concentration to be too high, resulting in agglomeration or uneven composition.

2.2.3 Preparation of rare earth doped lead halide perovskite single crystal

At present, the main processes for growing perovskite single crystals include melting Method such as Bridgman Method, solution method such as Hydrothermal method, Inverse Temperature Crystallization (ITC), Antisolvent Vapor-assisted Crystallization (AVC) and Solvent Evaporation[25][26][27][28][29].
The Bridgman method is a simple and practical method for single crystal growth (Fig. 2 e). A halide raw material or a perovskite polycrystalline material is melted, and the raw material in a molten state is solidified into a target phase. Bridgman method is often used for inorganic perovskite single crystal growth. Taking the growth of inorganic lead-based 3D perovskite CsPbBr3 as an example, Kanatzidis et al. Used the vertical Bridgman method to grow CsPbBr3 single crystals in a three-temperature zone growth furnace[30]. Zhang et al. Further optimized the growth conditions, reduced the Pb-CsPbBr3 rich phase with local stoichiometry deviating from CsPbBr3, and further improved the quality of the single crystal[31]. Examples of rare earth ion doping by Bridgman method have been reported in the literature, including CsPbCl3:La3+, CsPbCl3:Dy3+, CsPbCl3:Er3+, CsPbCl3:Yb3+ and Cs4PbBr6:Pr3+ single crystals[32][33][34][35][36]. CsX of 5 N grade purity and PbX2 halide or CsPbX3(X=Cl, Br, I) perovskite are usually used as raw materials, and anhydrous rare earth halide is used as doping source. The atomic ratio of RE/Pb in that raw material is 0.3 to 3%.
The crystal growth method in solution can also grow large-size lead halide perovskite single crystals, as shown in Figure 2G ~ H. The liquid phase growth method has a growth rate and a crystal product size similar to or even better than those of the melt method. For example, Ma et al. Grown single crystals of MAPbI3, MAPbBr3, FAPbBr3, etc., exceeding the size of a 1 cm2 in about a day by adding a polymer to control nucleation and growth[37]. Wang et al. Used the surface tension of the solution to grow the BA2PbBr4(BA=C4H12N+) single crystal film at the gas-liquid interface, and the crystal area reached 38 cm2 and the thickness was 78 nm[38]. Rong et al. Used dichlorosilane as an antisolvent to volatilize into the MAPbBr3:Er3+ perovskite precursor solution by the AVC method, in which the ErCl3 was fed at a ratio of Er/Pb = 1%[39]. The final single crystal size is 7 mm × 7 mm × 2 mm. Hydrothermal method is a traditional crystal synthesis method, and the conditions of high temperature and high pressure improve the degree of solute ionization and the rate of chemical reaction[40]. Zi et al. Improved the solvothermal method for MAPbI3:RE3+, and continued the reaction of the prepared precursor at 180 ° C, and finally slowly cooled the temperature for crystallization to obtain 4~5 mm2 sized MAPbI3:RE3+(Yb3+,Er3+,Yb3+/Er3) single crystal[41].
Hydrothermal method, as a mild synthesis method, allows co-condensation of different metal cations to obtain perovskites. However, the crystal grown by hydrothermal method is also sensitive to reaction temperature and time[42].

2.2.4 Preparation of Rare Earth Doped Lead Halide Perovskite Nanocrystal

Hot Injection and Ligand-assisted reprecipitation (LARP) are the main methods for nanocrystallization[43][44].
The hot injection method (Figure 2 I) is a method in which the precursor solution containing part of the reactants is heated to 150 ~ 250 ℃ in an inert atmosphere, and then other reactants are injected to obtain perovskite crystals by rapid nucleation and growth controlled by ligands such as oleylamine and oleic acid. Kovalenko et al. First used the hot injection method to synthesize CsPbX3 nanocrystals[43]. Cesium carbonate is used as a cesium source, 1-octadecene is used as a high-boiling-point solvent, oleic acid is used as the ligand, and the CsPbX3 nanocrystal is obtained by further crystallization through ice-water bath cooling. Pan et al. Used a hot injection method to synthesize rare earth doped CsPbCl3 nanocrystals[45]. Oleic acid and oleylamine are used as ligands, rare earth chloride hexahydrate is used as a doping agent,CsPbCl3:RE3+(RE3+=Ce3+, Sm3+, Eu3+,Tb3+, Dy3+, Er3+, Yb3+) nanocubes. With the increase of the atomic number of the doped ions, the size of the nanocrystals decreases.
The ligand-assisted precipitation method can be carried out at room temperature under an air atmosphere (Fig. 2j). Perovskite nanocrystals were obtained by dropping the precursor solution into a non-polar solvent (toluene, n-hexane, dichloromethane) with the assistance of ligands. Zhang et al. Used oleylamine and oleic acid as ligands, dropped toluene and stirred to obtain CsPbX3 nanocrystals[44]. Liu et al. Obtained MAPbBr3:Eu2+ crystals at room temperature using EuBr2 as the rare earth doping source, oleylamine and oleic acid as the ligands, and toluene as the anti-solvent[46].
In addition to the above doping methods of introducing rare earth ions into the precursor, rare earth doping can also be achieved by ion exchange. Ion exchange method refers to the introduction of other ions into the pre-synthesized perovskite solution to change the ionic composition of perovskite. Debnath et al. Have dissolved rare earth ions (Nd3+, Sm3+, Eu3+,DMF of Tb3+, Dy3+, Yb3+) was dropped into the pre-synthesized CsPbBr3 nanocrystals,The rare earth (Nd, Sm, Eu, Tb, Dy, Yb) doped CsPb(Br/Cl)3 nanocrystals were obtained after standing for a period of time at room temperature followed by centrifugation[47].
The hot injection method has the advantages of short reaction time and rapid crystal nucleation, and the size of the synthesized perovskite nanocrystal is uniform and adjustable. However, the hot injection method is not suitable for large-scale production because of its high environmental requirements (inert gas protection) and low synthesis yield[48].
Rare earth ion doped cesium lead halide perovskite in ion exchange method can control the band gap of the host through halide ion exchange, achieve energy matching, and better produce energy transfer from perovskite to rare earth ions. The method is simple, can occur in the environment, has a fast reaction rate, and has been widely used in the synthesis of rare earth doped CsPbX3 nanocrystals[48].

2.3 Effect of Rare Earth Ions on Growth and Structure of Perovskite

Recent studies have shown that rare earth ions can affect the nucleation and growth of perovskite crystals. Rare earth ions improve the crystal quality, passivate defects, and change the crystal dimension and phase by coordinating with organic solvents, coordinating with crystal surface ions, and inducing heterogeneous nucleation.

2.3.1 Effect of Rare Earth Ions on Growth and Structure of Perovskite Thin Films

Zheng et al. Prepared MAPbBr3:Nd3+ thin films by spin coating, and observed that Nd3+ had a significant effect on the nucleation and growth of perovskite[49]. The addition of Nd3+ led to heterogeneous nucleation and improved the crystallinity of perovskite films. Compared with homogeneous nucleation, heterogeneous nucleation has lower nucleation energy and higher nucleation rate. The crystal growth process is relatively separated from the nucleation process, resulting in the formation of crystals with high phase purity and fewer defects. The MAPbBr3:Nd3+ photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) was enhanced by a factor of 6 and remained PLQY stable for at least 8 months under ambient conditions. Wang et al. Introduced Eu3+-Eu2+ ion pairs in MAPbI3 solar cells[50]. The ion pair acts as a "redox shuttle" while selectively oxidizing Pb0 and reducing I0 defects. At the same time, the crystallinity of the film is improved. The final device achieved a PCE of 21.52% with long-term durability. Yang et al. Added GdF3 to spin-coated perovskite films and annealed them in aminobutanol atmosphere. The introduction of Gd produced a redox shuttle effect and optimized the Oswald ripening crystallization process[51]. Finally, a high-performance solar cell with a PCE of 21.21% is obtained.

2.3.2 Effect of Rare Earth Ions on Growth and Structure of Perovskite Nanocrystals

Wu et al. Added different proportions of europium acetate (Eu(AcO)3) during the synthesis of CsPbCl3 by hot injection method, and found that the CsPbCl3 nanocrystals changed from cubic morphology to nanowires with the growth direction of (200) under the induction of Eu(AcO)3[52]. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) shows that the doping sites of Eu3+ are located on the surface of the nanocrystals. Combined with density functional theory (DFT) calculations, the co-adsorption of AcO- and Eu3+ on the crystal surface regulates its growth and passivates the defects. The responsivity and detectivity of the prepared UV detector are 398 mA/W and 3.3×1011Jones, respectively.
Lei et al. Used the sonochemical method to sonicate the precursor solution with the addition of EuBr2 to synthesize CsPbBr3/Cs4PbBr6:Eu composite nanocrystals[53]. The X-ray diffraction pattern (XRD) illustrated that the EuBr2 induced the phase transformation from CsPbBr3 to Cs4PbBr6 and formed the CsPbBr3/Cs4PbBr6 composite structure crystal. Eu2+ is oxidized to Eu3+ during synthesis. Meanwhile, Eu3+ forms a Eu (DMF ) x 3 + complex with N, N-dimethylformamide. The Eu (DMF) ) x 3 + regulates the ion concentration in the solution and coordinates with the surface of the Cs4PbBr6 crystal to inhibit the growth rate , of the CsPbBr3 phase, thereby promoting the formation of the Cs4PbBr6 phase.

2.4 Study on Composition Distribution and Doping Sites of Rare Earth Ions in Lead Halide Perovskite

The study of composition distribution and doping sites helps us to further understand the structure and physical characteristics of rare earth doped perovskites. In rare earth doped perovskite, the spatial position of rare earth ions includes two parts: the macroscopic composition distribution and the microscopic lattice doping sites. For the composition distribution, the ion doping process can occur at the bulk, surface, and grain boundary of the crystal. For doping sites, rare earth ion doping produces point defects in the form of substitutions and vacancies.

2.4.1 Composition Distribution of Rare Earth Ions in Lead Halide Perovskite

In terms of single crystals, Wang et al. Grew CsPbBr3:Y3+ single crystals by the ITC-method[54]. The Y doping concentration at different positions of the single crystal sample was measured by atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP), and the results showed that the concentration at the outer edge of the crystal was higher than that at the inner part of the crystal. Lin et al. Prepared MAPbI3:Ce3+ single crystal and polycrystalline thin films[55]. The doping increases the carrier concentration and decreases the mobility of the film. Time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) results show that the surface Ce concentration of the MAPbI3:Ce3+ is much higher than the bulk Ce concentration at 800 nm depth. These results all illustrate that the Ce3+ ion doping occurs only on the surface of the MAPbI3 crystal.
In terms of nanocrystals, Ma et al. Synthesized CsPbCl3:Yb3+ nanocrystals by hot injection method[56]. Repeated centrifugal separation was used to distinguish nanocrystals of different sizes, and it was found that nanocrystals of different sizes had significant doping concentration differences. Time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) and positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy (PALS) measurements show that the defects in the high concentration doped crystals are more than those in the low concentration doped crystals. The authors believe that increasing the number of defects in the CsPbCl3 crystal can increase the doping concentration of Yb3+.

2.4.2 Study on the Doping Sites of Rare Earth Ions in Lead Halide Perovskite

Generally, after doping with ions, the lattice of perovskite crystal is contracted or expanded, which will lead to the shift of XRD peaks. However, the recent study of trivalent rare earth (Ⅲ) ion doping in lead-based (Ⅱ) perovskite crystals shows that the lattice parameters of lead-based (Ⅱ) perovskite crystals are not significantly changed by trace trivalent rare earth (Ⅲ) ion doping, and the corresponding interplanar spacing in high-resolution transmission electron microscopy atomic images is also very small[57,58][59].
The ionic radius of trivalent rare earth ions is closer to that of lead ions than that of A-site ions and halide ions. The radius of lead ion is 119 pm, and the radius of trivalent lanthanide ion is 86 ~ 103 pm. Therefore, the rare earth ions are more likely to replace the Pb ions in the host lattice. He et al. Calculated the defect formation energy in the orthorhombic phase CsPbBr3:Ce3+ using first principles[60]. The results show that it is more likely to replace the position of the Pb2+ than the Ce3+ to enter the gap and replace the Cs+,Ce3+. The cell parameters of CsPbBr3 after surface doping by rare earth ions (Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb) to replace part of the cell model of Pb2+ are designed to remain basically unchanged.
Quantum cutting refers to a process in which a material absorbs a high-energy photon and converts it into two or more low-energy photon emissions. Milstein et al. And Li et al. Have proposed a physical model of the doped local structure of Yb3+-VPb-Yb3+ based on the Quantum cutting effect found in CsPbCl3:Yb3+ (Figure 3A)[61][62]. The Yb3+-VPb-Yb3+structure is consistent with a quantum-tailored energy transfer process, in which the CsPbCl3 host absorbs a single high-energy photon, and the photon energy is converted into two emitted photons of 1.25 eV (980 nm) photon energy via energy transfer to two nearby Yb3+ luminescence centers.
图3 (a) CsPbCl3:Yb3+ 的掺杂局部的晶体结构模型[61]; (b) CsPbCl3:Sm3+纳米晶和无掺杂CsPbCl3纳米晶样品的Pb2+的高分辨XPS谱图[67] ;(c) CsPbCl3:2.1%Yb3+纳米晶与(d) CsPbCl3:5.7%Yb3+纳米晶的HRTEM图像,标尺为5 nm[63]

Fig. 3 (a) Crystal structure model of the doped region of CsPbCl3: Yb3+[61]. Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society (b) High-resolution XPS analysis corresponding to Pb4f5/2 and 4f7/2 for undoped and CsPbCl3:Sm3+ NCs[67]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society (c) HRTEM images of CsPbCl3:2.1%Yb3+ and (d) CsPbCl3:5.7%Yb3+ NCs.Scale bar: 5 nm[63]. Copyright 2018, American Chemical Society

Zhou et al. Synthesized CsPbCl3:Yb3+ nanocrystals with actual doping concentrations ranging from 2.1% to 5.7% using the hot injection method by increasing the YbCl3·6H2O charge of the rare earth compound in the precursor[63]. The sample with 5.7% doping concentration has an XRD shift of 0.06 ° on the (100) crystal plane. The interplanar spacing of the sample (100) was measured by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), and it was found that the interplanar spacing decreased from 5.5151 Å to 5.3636 Å with the increase of Yb3+ doping concentration from 2.1% to 5.7% (Figure 3C). In addition, Cao et al. Attempted to locate the doping sites of CsPbBr3:Lu3+ nanosheets by high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission microscopy (HAADF-STEM), and found that the signals of some B-site ions on the (001) crystal plane had intensity differences, indicating that they might be the spatial sites where Lu3+ replaced Pb2+[64].
XPS can be used to analyze the binding energy of each ion in the crystal, so it is often used to analyze the doping sites of rare earth ions in rare earth doped perovskites[65,66]. For example, Sun et al. Used the hot injection method to synthesize CsPbCl3:Sm3+ nanocrystals[67]. The binding energy spectrum peaks of 3d3/2, 3d5/2, 4d3/2, 4d5/2 from Sm3+ were detected under XPS,Where 3d3/2,3d5/2 comes from SmCl3 at the crystal surface and 4d3/2,4d5/2 comes from Sm3+ after entering the lattice. In addition, the XPS binding energy spectrum peaks of 4f5/2 and 4f7/2 of sample Pb2+ obviously move to the low energy direction after doping (Fig. 3 B), while the binding energy of Cs+ and Cl- is weakly affected. This proves that Sm3+ is more likely to replace the site of Pb2+ in the crystal lattice.
Kluherz et al. Used synchrotron radiation fine absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and X-ray total scattering-differential pair distribution function method (dPDF) to systematically study the structural change of CsPbCl3:Yb3+ single crystal prepared by melt method, and the X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (EXAFS) showed that the coordination environment of Yb3+ in the single crystal prepared by melt method was octahedral, which indicated that the Yb3+ ion replaced the position of Pb2+ ion[68]. At the same time, the bond length of Yb-Cl is observed to be 2.5858 Å in the dPDF spectrum, which is different from the bond length of Pb-Cl of 2.8383 Å, which is consistent with the EXAFS result after Fourier transformation. By comparing the experimental data with the simulation results of multiple types of vacancies, the VPb vacancy exists inside the CsPbCl3:Yb3+ single crystal. Therefore, VPb is likely to be the main charge compensation mechanism for the heterovalent doping of CsPbCl3:Yb3+.
Different crystal morphologies may lead to differences in doping results. Roh et al. Synthesized CsPbCl3:Yb3+ single crystals and nanocrystals by melt method and thermal injection method[35]. The photoluminescence spectra at low temperature show that the partial characteristic emission peak of the Yb3+ in the range of 978.5 ~ 982.3 nm is different between the single crystal and the nanocrystal, which indicates that the local electronic structure of the Yb3+ doping may be different between them.
The study of composition distribution shows that the distribution of rare earth ions is related to the crystal morphology and synthesis conditions, which has guiding significance for the realization of homogeneous phase doping and controllable surface doping. A series of studies have explored the doping sites, the introduction of related defects, and the charge compensation mechanism of Yb3+ and Lu3+, which are two rare earth ions with small ionic radii, in perovskite, indicating that trivalent rare earth ions can replace lead ions and produce VPb to achieve charge compensation.

3 Luminescent properties of rare earth doped lead halide perovskite crystals

Rare earth ions doped lead halide perovskite, on the one hand, enhance the photoluminescence peak intensity of lead halide perovskite itself, on the other hand, bring the fluorescence of rare earth ions. The excitation of rare earth luminescence centers can broaden the emission band of perovskite and improve the PLQY of perovskite. The increase of electronic density of States and the surface passivation of the crystal after rare earth doping are the two main reasons for the enhancement of perovskite host emission. A table of the luminescent properties of typical rare earth ion doped lead halide perovskites is listed here for reference (Table 1).
表1 稀土掺杂卤化铅钙钛矿的发光性能

Table 1 Luminescence properties of lead halide perovskite doped with rare earth

Perovskite Rare-earth Ion Form of Crystal Synthesis Mothod Emisson of Rare-earth ion/Excitation Wavelength(nm) Emisson of Perovskite as Host (nm) PLQY (Max) Response under X-ray ref
CsPbCl3 / Nano
Crystal
Hot-Injection / No report ~54.08% No report 88

CsPbCl3
Dy3+ Single Crystal Vertical Bridgman 576.5/455 No report 57% No report 33
CsPbCl3 Er3+ Single Crystal Vertical Bridgman 3500/660
4500,2750,1550/800
No report No report No report 34
CsPbCl3 Yb3+ Single Crystal Vertical Bridgman 982/375 420 No report No report 35
CsPbCl3 Yb3+ Single Crystal Hydrothermal 980/365 450 137% Light yield:
112 000 ph/MeV
Detection limit:
176.5 nGyair/s
89
CsPbCl3 Yb3+ Powder Precipitation 1000/405 406 No report Light yield:
102 000 ph/MeV
24
CsPbCl3 Y3+ Nano
Crystal
Surface Treatment / 404 60% No report 78
CsPbCl3 Ce3+, Sm3+, Eu3+, Tb3+,Dy3+, Er3+, Yb3+ Nano
Crystal
Hot Injection 430 (Ce3+);
560,605,640 (Sm3+);
588,620,696 (Eu3+),
489,550 (Tb3+);
481,572 (Dy3+);
523,548 (Er3+);
982(Yb3+)/365
410 24.3 (Ce3+);
14.1 (Sm3+);
27.2 (Eu3+);
31.2 (Tb3+);
27.6 (Dy3+);
15.1 (Er3+);
142.7(Yb3+)
No report 45
CsPb(Br/Cl)3 Nd3+, Sm3+, Eu3+, Tb3+,Dy3+,Yb3+ Nano
Crystal
Ion Exchange 890, 1058, 1350 (Nd3+);
564, 600, 650, 710 (Sm3+);
590, 616, 700 (Eu3+);
490, 545, 585, 620 (Tb3+);
475, 575, 660, 750 (Dy3+);
980 (Yb3+)/330
410~415 2%~3% No report 47
CsPb(Cl1-xBrx)3 Yb3+ Film Spin Coated 990/375 490 193% No report 90
MAPbBr3 Eu2+ NanoCrystal LARP 440,456/350 522 90% No report 46
MAPbBr3 Er3+ Single Crystal AVC None/420 542 No report No report 39
MAPbI3 Yb3+,Yb3+/Er+ Single Crystal Hydrothermal 980(Yb3+);980,1540(Yb3+/Er3+)/530 830 No report Planar Au/MAPbI3/Au for direct detected model:
1.16×106 μC G y a i r - 1·cm-2
(-3 V bias)
41
NMA2PbBr4 Eu3+ Film Spin Coated 576, 589, 611, 648, 697 /350 389,564 9% No report 70
PEA2PbCl4 Eu3+ Powder Hot Injection 592,613/365 350 83% No report 71
PEA2PbBr4 Yb3+ Micro
Crystal
Hot Injection 997/340 414 No report No report 72
CsPbCl3 La3+ Single Crystal Vertical Bridgman / 420 No report Weaker luminescence
intensity under X-ray
32
CsPbBr3 Ce3+ Nano
Crystal
Hot Injection None/340 525 No report Light yield:
33 000 ph/MeV
spatial resolution :862 nm
91
CsPbI3 La3+ Nano
Crystal
Hot Injection / 687 99.3% No report 73
CsPbI3 Ce3+ Nano
Crystal
Hot Injection None/365 678 99% No report 74
CsPbBr3 Ce3+ Nano
Crystal
Hot Injection None/365 510 89% No report 75
CsPbBr3 Nd3+ Nano
Crystal
LARP None/365 459 90% No report 66

3.1 Introducing rare earth ion luminescent center

Rare earth ions as luminescent centers can provide emission from visible to infrared bands. The excitation of rare earth luminescence centers can be realized by host energy transfer or direct absorption transition of rare earth ions.
Hommerich et al. Obtained CsPbCl3:Dy3+ single crystals using the vertical Bridgman method[33]. The single crystal has a characteristic absorption peak of the 4 f transition of the Dy3+, and can obtain a yellow emission (4F9/24H13/2) near 575 nm by directly exciting the Dy3+(6H15/24I15/2) at 455 nm (Figure 4A). On the other hand, Pan et al. Used a modified hot injection method,Doping rare earth ions (Ce3+, Sm3+.Eu3+ 、Tb3+ 、Dy3+ 、Er3+ 、Yb3+ ),Achieve high PLQY and stable and tunable multicolor emission from the visible to the near-infrared region (Figure 4B)[45]. When the excitation wavelength is longer than the band gap of the rare earth doped perovskite, the absorption cross-section of the perovskite host is much larger than that of the 4f-4f transition of the rare earth ion. Under the excitation of 365 nm light source, the CsPbCl3 as the host absorbed the photon energy, and the emission of rare earth ions was observed, which proved the good energy transfer from the CsPbCl3:RE3+ host to the rare earth luminescence center. Debnath et al. Prepared Nd3+, Sm3+,Eu3+, Tb3+, Dy3+, Yb3+ doped CsPb(Br/Cl)3 nanocrystals[47]. Under the excitation of 330 nm light source, the emission peaks of the doped ions can be observed by emission spectra and Time-gated emission spectra. Based on the theory of Phonon emission, Charge trapping and Charge transfer, the degree of energy transfer of different rare earth ions sensitized by the host is analyzed, and the reason why Sm3+, Dy3+ and Nd3+ are difficult to be observed under conventional emission spectrum is explained.
图4 (a) CsPbCl3:Dy3+单晶在575 nm(Dy3+6H15/24I15/2 )发射波段的激发光谱[33];(b) CsPbCl3:Yb3+/Er3+/Dy3+/Tb3+/Eu3+/Sm3+/Ce3+纳米晶体在365nm激发下的发射光谱[45]; (c) 不同浓度Ce3+ 掺杂CsPbBr3:Ce3+纳米晶体的归一化光致发光光谱; (d) Ce3+掺杂CsPbBr3提出的辐射复合增强模型,灰色虚线代表浅层缺陷能级,绿色虚线代表导带上的额外电子态[76]

Fig. 4 (a) Excitation spectra of CsPbCl3:Dy3+ SC at 575nm (Dy3+6H15/24I15/2 )emission band[33]. Copyright 2020, The Optical Society (b) Emission spectra of CsPbCl3:Yb3+/Er3+/Dy3+/Tb3+/Eu3+/Sm3+/Ce3+ NCs at 365 nm excitation[45]. Copyright 2017, American Chemical Society (c) Normalized PL spectra of CsPbBr3:Ce3+ NCs doping with different concentrations of Ce3+. (d) The luminescence enhancement model of Ce3+ doped CsPbBr3. The gray dotted line represents the shallow defect energy level and the green dotted line represents the additional electronic states in the conduction band[76]. Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society

The CsPbX3:Yb3+ system with the band gap value larger than 2.5 eV has the quantum cutting effect, and the Yb3+ is sensitized by the CsPbX3 matrix.The energy transfer is achieved through the [Yb3+-VPb-Yb3+] structure, and the radiative recombination of the 2F5/22F7/2(1.26 eV) two-photon is finally completed at the Yb3+ luminescence center. The PLQY of 100% ~ 193% can be achieved through the quantum tailoring effect[69]. Roh et al. Synthesized CsPbCl3:Yb3+ single crystals and nanocrystals by melt method and thermal injection method[35]. The quantum cutting effect is observed in both crystals. Time-resolved photoluminescence measurements provide direct evidence of the previously hypothesized intermediate state in the quantum cut-off regime. This intermediate state forms within a few picoseconds at room temperature and has a decay time of only about 7 ns in nanocrystals and single crystals.
Zi et al. Synthesized MAPbI3:Yb3+, MAPbI3:Er3+ and MAPbI3:Yb3+/Er3+ single crystals by solvothermal method[41]. The characteristic emission peak of the MAPbI3:Yb3+ at the wavelength of 980 nm Yb3+(2F5/2-2F7/2),Er3+(4I13/2-4I15/2) was observed under the excitation of 530 nm. MAPbI3:Er3+ could not observe Er3+ emission at 530 nm excitation. However, by co-doping Yb3+ and Er3+ ions, the matrix and Yb3+ play a sensitization role, and the emission of Er3+ at 1540 nm can be achieved. Liu et al. Prepared different concentrations of Eu2+ doped MAPbBr3 QDs[46]. The 4d-5f transition of Eu2+ was observed with an energy level of 5D0-7FJ. It is pointed out that the Eu2+ emission is weak when Eu/Pb < 0.2 in the precursor. When Eu/Pb > 0.2, the ratio of Eu2+ emission intensity increases obviously. The authors suggest that the EuBr2 will coordinate on the surface of the MAPbBr3 at low concentration of doping, while the Eu2+ will enter the lattice at high concentration.
For low-dimensional lead-based perovskites, rare earth doping can also be used to introduce rare earth luminescent centers. Cortecchia et al. Doped Eu3+ ions in naphthylmethylamine (NMA=C11H12N+) perovskite using a spin-coating method[70]. The doping used a complex of Eu3+ with tetraphenylphosphine and thenoyltrifluoroacetone. The ligand selection takes into account the preparation conditions of perovskite, lattice adaptation and spectral matching. The NMA2PbBr4:Eu3+ adopting the ligand emits red light with high color purity. Xu et al. Synthesized PEA2PbCl4:Eu3+(PEA=C8H12N+) perovskite powder by hot injection method[71]. After removal of the water oxygen coordination by thenoyltrifluoroacetone ligand passivation, PEA2PbCl4:Eu3+ exhibits red emission with high color purity from the 5D0→7F2 transition. Mondal et al. Synthesized the PEA2PbBr4:Yb3+ crystal and found the near-infrared emission from Yb3+2F5/22F7/2[72]. It is worth noting that the fluorescence lifetime of Yb3+ measured in the infrared emission band in 3D lead-based perovskites is usually on the order of milliseconds, while the fluorescence lifetime of Yb3+ in 2D PEA2PbBr4:Yb3+ is 14 μs. This may be correlated with the 2D crystal environment in which the Yb3+ luminescence center is located.

3.2 Enhanced perovskite matrix emission

The host emission properties of CsPbX3 nanocrystals can be improved by doping with rare earth elements (La, Ce, Nd, Y, etc.)[54,66,73~75]. The fluorescence lifetime of the doped CsPbX3 is maintained at the same order of magnitude, but the photoluminescence is enhanced, and the emission peak is slightly blue-shifted.
Recent studies have proposed a series of mechanisms and models: Yin et al. Explained the behavior of nanocrystal luminescence enhancement and blue shift of synthesized CsPbBr3:Ce3+ by DFT calculation (Fig. 4C)[76]. The results indicate that Ce3+ ions are able to stabilize the bulk/surface structure of CsPbBr3 nanocrystals. The electron density of States at the conduction band edge increases, which leads to the emission enhancement and a weak blue shift. At the same time, the shallow defect States introduced by doping do not cause non-radiative recombination to reduce the luminescence performance (Figure 4D). He et al. Calculated the 4F and 5d orbitals of a series of rare earths (Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb) by using first-principles calculation, which contributed more density of States to the conduction band due to hybridization[60]. However, the shallow defect States are mainly introduced by the 4F orbital of the rare earth, which improves the luminescent properties of perovskite. Milstein et al. Further studied CsPb(Cl1-xBrx)3(0≤x≤1) doped with a series of rare earth ions (RE3+=Y3+, La3+,Temperature-dependent emission spectra of nanocrystals and thin films of Ce3+, Gd3+, Er3+, Lu3+),Near-band-edge emission (NBE-PL) was found in the doped sample at low temperature, which indicated that the near-band-edge emission was caused by defect levels[77]. Shu et al. Attempted to analyze Ce3+ doped CsPbI3 QDs with femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy[74]. The density of High Energy Excitonic States (HES) of CsPbI3 increases after doping with High Energy Excitonic States, and more excitons are generated after excitation, which leads to the enhancement of PLQY and the blue shift of the emission peak. At the same time, the doping inserts shallow defect States into the energy band of perovskite, so that most excitons can be captured by the shallow defect States and recombine after relaxation, which together with HES promotes the improvement of PLQY.
In addition, rare earth ions can also reduce the non-radiative recombination path by surface passivation. Ahmed et al. Directly added the YCl3 into the synthesized nanocrystal solution containing CsPbCl3, stirred and centrifuged, and the PLQY of the CsPbCl3 increased from 1% to 60% after surface passivation, indicating that the surface causing non-radiative recombination was passivated and the defects were greatly reduced[78].

4 Rare Earth Doped Lead Halide Perovskite Crystals and Their Semiconductor Electrical Properties

Lead halide perovskite is a new type of compound semiconductor material. The band gap, Fermi level, conductivity, carrier and other semiconductor properties of perovskite can be modulated by doping, which is also called electrical doping of perovskite[79,80]. The theoretical calculation and experimental study of rare earth doped perovskite show that the introduction of rare earth ions realizes the electrical doping, thereby improving the device performance[55,81].

4.1 Theoretical Study of Rare Earth Ions Doping Lead Halide Perovskite

The main valence of rare earth ions is trivalent, so the substitution of rare earth ions (RE3+) for lead ions (Pb2+) will produce point defects such as substitution defect REPb and lead vacancy defect VPb(V is vacancy). Point defects introduce defect levels into the band gap, which can be divided into shallow donor levels near the conduction band minimum (CBM), shallow acceptor levels near the valence band maximum (VBM), and deep defect levels far from the valence band maximum and conduction band minimum. Deep defect levels are considered to impair the optoelectronic properties of semiconductors, while shallow levels can better regulate the carrier properties. The theoretical calculation can be used to analyze the chemical potential required for the formation of intrinsic defects and doping defects, and to speculate on the types of defects. By establishing a real space lattice doping model and calculating the energy band structure in the inverse space, the changes of energy levels and electronic density of States caused by doping are analyzed.
Mannodi-Kanakkithodi et al. Established a lattice model for the substitution of Pb in MAPbBr3 by various exogenous metal ions[82]. The DFT calculation shows that the formation energy of the MPb(M) defects corresponding to the five Sc ions is lower than that of the intrinsic vacancy defects (VPb, VMA, VBr), which indicates that the crystal is easy to form MPb defects under the doping of these exogenous metal ions, and the donor level can be introduced into the perovskite band to change the position of the Fermi level. Lyons used hybrid DFT theory to analyze the band structure of CsPbCl3, CsPbBr3, FAPbI3 doped Bi, Ga, Y, Sc ions[81]. Compared with Bi and Ga, the calculation results of rare earth elements Y and Sc show that they can form shallow donor levels in the band gap. Undoped CsPbBr3 is a p-type semiconductor with FAPbI3, so Y and Sc are expected to achieve n-type doping without damaging the optoelectronic properties of the perovskite host.

4.2 Experimental Study on Electrical Doping of Lead Halide Perovskite by Rare Earth Ions

On the one hand, rare earth doping can optimize the crystallization and reduce the number of defects in perovskite, on the other hand, it can optimize the semiconductor properties by modulating its band structure and carrier concentration.

4.2.1 Modulated perovskite host band structure.

The carrier species and the change of Fermi level can be determined by Hall effect measurement, ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS), scanning tunneling microscopy (STS), Kelvin probe microscopy (KPFM) and other techniques.
Lin et al. Studied the surface doping of MAPbI3 perovskite by AgBr, SrI2, CeI3[55]. Undoped MAPbI3 behaves as a p-type semiconductor. After the perovskite thin film is treated by AgBr,SrI2,CeI3, the majority carrier type of the MAPbI3 thin film changes from holes to electrons, that is, from p-type semiconductor to n-type semiconductor. TOF-SIM test shows that the rare earth doping stays on the surface of the crystal, which greatly increases the dark current on the surface of the crystal. It is difficult for impurity ions to enter the perovskite crystal, and the intrinsic p-type semiconductor characteristics are maintained in the crystal. For the rare earth Ce3+ ion, this may be correlated with its ionic hardness that distinguishes it from Pb2+[83]. After the surface of the MAPbI3 film is treated by CeI3, the carrier type of the film is changed from hole to electron, and from p-type semiconductor to n-type semiconductor. The contact potential difference (CPD) was measured by KPFM after partial annealing of MAPbI3 single crystal wafer by CeI3 particle treatment. The annealing treatment leads to a decrease in the work function and a shift of the Fermi level to the conduction band, transforming into an n-type semiconductor. At present, the conventional donor doping ion of lead halide perovskite is Bi3+, which will directly reduce the band gap of perovskite and introduce deep traps, which has a negative impact on the photoelectric properties[84]. However, the surface doping of Ag+, Sr2+ and Ce3+ did not cause the performance degradation and band gap change. The calculation shows that the doping of metal ions increases the electronic States at the conduction band edge of perovskite, and finally presents donor doping.
Liu et al. Fabricated polycrystalline CsPbBr3:Eu3+ solar cells[85]. After doping, the grain size of the CsPbBr3 becomes larger, the grain size is uniform, and the grain boundary is obviously reduced. UPS shows that the Fermi level of CsPbBr3 increases from-3. 71 eV to-3. 65 eV after doping 3%Eu3+. The top of the valence band decreases from -5.92 eV to -6.20 eV, and the bottom of the conduction band decreases from -3.61 eV to -3.64 eV. The change of energy band optimizes the barrier of CsPbBr3:Eu3+ at the interface of carbon electrode, which is beneficial to the transport of carriers, and the final doped device achieves a maximum PCE of 8. 06%. Yang et al. Selected samarium acetylacetonate (Sm(acac)3) as a dopant to prepare CsPbI2Br perovskite thin films by a one-step spin-coating method[86]. The results of XPS and TOF-SIM showed that some Sm3+ replaced the position of Pb2+. The UPS results indicate that the VBM of undoped CsPbI2Br and Sm(acac)3 doped CsPbI2Br are − 6.05 eV and − 6.15 eV, respectively. Combined with the band gap values, the conduction band energies of CsPbI2Br and Sm(acac)3 doped CsPbI2Br are deduced to be − 4.17 eV and − 4.26 eV, respectively. The introduction of samarium acetylacetonate optimized the perovskite film quality and passivated the perovskite solar cell device interface (Figure 5B), resulting in a PCE of 12.86%. Moreover, the doped device shows excellent thermal stability, and can still maintain 90% of the initial PCE after being placed at 85 ℃ for 200 hours. Parveen et al. Doped MAPbBr3 nanosheets with Eu3+ by solvothermal method[87]. Under the feeding of 10%(RE/Pb=10%)EuCl3, the size of MAPbBr3 nanosheets became larger and the thickness became thinner. The band gap of MAPbBr3 increases from 2. 39 eV to 2. 94 eV with the increase of doping concentration, which may be related to the change of nanocrystal size. The Eu-doped MAPbBr3 nanosheets eliminated part of the trap States and promoted the rapid charge transport. The resulting MAPbBr2.7Cl0.3:Eu3+ photodetector exhibits self-bias behavior at 405 nm excitation with an on-off ratio exceeding that of 103. The responsivity reaches 5.29 A/W at 5 V bias, and the detectivity reaches 1.06×1012Jones.
图5 (a) MAPbI3单晶的局部经CeI3颗粒处理后退火后,KPFM下的CPD测量结果[55]; (b) Sm(acac)3掺杂CsPbI2Br太阳能电池的各功能层能带结构图[86]; (c) 无掺杂MAPbBr3单晶与 (d) ErCl3掺杂的MAPbBr3单晶的暗电流电流-电压曲线[39]

Fig. 5 (a) CPD measurement via KPFM of MAPbI3 SC partly treat by CeI3 particles followed by followed by thermal annealing[55]. Copyright 2021, Nature Publishing Group (b) The energy band structure diagram of Sm(acac)3-doped CsPbI2Br solar cell[86]. Copyright 2020, AIP Publishing (c) The dark current-voltage curves of undoped MAPbBr3 SC and (d) ErCl3-doped MAPbBr3 SC[39]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society

4.2.2 Modulating perovskite carrier properties

Carrier properties include carrier concentration, carrier mobility, carrier lifetime. Carrier concentration and mobility can be measured by Hall effect test, and carrier mobility can also be measured by space charge limited current test (SCLC). The carrier lifetime can be obtained by TRPL and transient photovoltage (TPV) characterization.
Rong et al. Fabricated a photodetector based on MAPbBr3:Er3+ single crystal, and the conductivity was improved by a factor of two relative to the undoped one[39]. Doping Er3+ into the MAPbBr3 increases the carrier mobility from 35±2 cm2/V/s to 96.10 cm2/V/s (Fig. 5C, d), and moreover, the trap density is reduced by 37%. The MAPbBr3:Er3+ photodetector with planar interdigital gold electrodes has a self-powered characteristic, that is, it works without external voltage. Moreover, optimizing the crystal quality will also significantly improve the carrier mobility[92,93]. Shen et al. Prepared 2D: 3D mixed PEA2PbI4∶MAPbI3∶Nd3+ thin films using spin coating[94]. Nd3+ was doped with two kinds of lead-based perovskites simultaneously. The doping of Nd3+ greatly changed the morphology of the film, making the 2D and 3D perovskite grains mixed more uniformly, and the grain size also increased. Grazing incidence small angle X-ray scattering (GIWAXS) results show that PEA2PbI4:MAPbI3:Nd3+ has high crystallinity, which helps to improve the charge carrier mobility[94]. The electron/hole mobility ratio of the doped film increases from μeh=0.34 to 0.62, indicating a better equilibrium carrier transport property. The fluorescence lifetime test shows that the doping has no significant effect on the fast component decay of 0. 48 ns, while the slow component decay increases from 8. 9 ns to 10 ns, indicating that the non-radiative recombination of photogenerated carriers is suppressed. The fabricated photodetector has a photoelectric response of more than 700 mA/W and a linear dynamic range of 165 dB. Zhao et al. Selected neodymium trifluoromethanesulfonate as the dopant to prepare solar cells with α-FAPbI:Nd3+ thin film as the absorber layer by spin coating[95]. The fluorescence lifetime of the perovskite layer is prolonged at a very small doping ratio of (0.08%)Nd3+. The device's transient photovoltage (TPV) drop is slowed down as evidence of nonradiative defect reduction. In situ dynamic PL Mapping of the samples under 150 mV/μm bias electric field shows that the photoluminescence intensity of the undoped perovskite decreases sharply under current operation, while the sample doped with trace amount of Nd3+ remains consistent after 10 min. This proves that Nd3+ effectively suppresses the degradation of photoluminescence properties caused by ion migration. The solar cell fabricated by Nd3+ doping with α-FAPbI3 achieved a PCE efficiency of over 20% and retained the original efficiency of 86.4% after 2002 H, which is significantly higher than that of the conventional doping ions (Ca2+ and Na+) used to suppress ion migration.

5 Application of Rare Earth Doped Lead Halide Perovskite in Radiation Detection

Lead halide perovskite is expected to be used as the next generation of advanced X-ray/γ-ray detection materials in the field of radiation detection because of its excellent absorption ability, high carrier mobility and excellent radioluminescence properties, including X-ray array imaging, high-resolution flexible scintillation film, energy-resolved γ-ray detection and so on[96][97][98]. Rare earth doping technology can optimize the radiation detection performance of perovskite host materials while maintaining their band gap and photoelectric properties. Therefore, we will briefly introduce the principle of radiation detection and summarize the recent research progress of rare earth doped lead halide perovskites in the field of radiation detection.

5.1 Introduction to Perovskite Radiation Detection

A semiconductor material, after absorbing an X-ray (100 eV < hν < 100 keV) or a γ-ray (100 keV < hν < 10 MeV), excites a large number of electron-hole pairs as given by Eq.

β = h ν W ±

β is the number of electron-hole pairs, hν is the ray photon energy, W ± is the ionization energy, and for the perovskite material system, W ± = 2 E g + 1.43 , E g is the band gap of the material[99].
Fig. 6a shows the three main radiation absorption mechanisms: ① Compton scattering. That is to say, the incident photon is scattered by the outer electron and excites an electron, which is weak for X-ray scattering. ② photoelectric absorption. For the absorption mechanism dominated by X-rays and low-energy gamma rays, the incident photon is absorbed by the inner orbital electrons (K, L, M) and the photoelectron is emitted outward. ③ Electron pair effect. When the incident photon energy is greater than 1. 022 keV, the incident photon is absorbed by the strong Coulomb electric field near the nucleus and produces a pair of electrons and positrons, and the electron pair effect becomes the main absorption mechanism at hν > 8 MeV.
图6 (a) 固体材料吸收射线的主要作用过程机理;(b) 闪烁探测晶体与半导体探测材料的探测原理示意图;(c) CsPbClxBr3-x: Yb3+ SCs中闪烁体转换机理简图[102]; (d) 基于MAPbI3的p-i-n型光伏器件结构图[103]; (e) CsPbBr3闪烁体基射线探测器[104]

Fig. 6 (a) The principal mechanism by which radiation is absorbed by solid materials; (b) Schematic diagram of the detection principle of scintillation detection crystals and semiconductor detection materials; (c) A sketch of the scintillators conversion mechanism in CsPbClxBr3-x: Yb3+ SCs[102]; (d) Schematic of layer stacking of the MAPbI3-based p-i-n photodiode[103]; (e) CsPbBr3 scintillator based ray detector[104]

Lead halide perovskite ray detectors can be divided into indirect and direct detectors (Fig. 6B). If the material has good radioluminescence properties, it can use its scintillation luminescence properties to design photoelectric sensors at the back end to receive high-energy photons and make indirect response to radiation. The radiation detector made of scintillator material becomes an indirect detector[100]. In a direct-type radiation detector, a semiconductor detection crystal generates free carriers. The signal is derived as a photocurrent by separating electrons and holes by applying an electric field[101].
Fig. 6C is a schematic diagram of a rare earth perovskite, taking Yb3+/CsPbBr3 as an example to illustrate the scintillation process of CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+Scs excited with X-rays, including three stages of conversion, transmission, and luminescence. The incident X-ray radiation interacts with the lattice atoms of CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+Scs to generate hot electrons and holes, which then thermally relax into the conduction and valence bands or are trapped by the defects of CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+Scs. The defect of CsPbClxB r 3 - x :Yb3+Scs reduction after RE3+ doping is prone to fill electrons and holes on the conduction/valence band, directly recombine to produce exciton emission, and a part of it is transferred to Yb3+ and emits two near-infrared photons (∼ 980 nm)[102].
Fig. 6 d ~ e shows the device schematic of the halide perovskite detector. Fig. 6d is a diagram of a direct detector (MAPbI3 photovoltaic device)[103]. CH3NH3PbI3 produces electron-hole pairs under illumination (visible light, X-rays, γ-rays, etc.). ITO and PCBM act as electron and hole transport layers to improve electron and hole collection efficiency. Finally, the electrons and holes are led out through the ITO electrode and the Ag/ZnO electrode, respectively, to form a photocurrent. The direct detector can detect low dose light, with high detection sensitivity and low detection line. For example, X-ray and γ-ray telescopes in the universe are direct detectors. Fig. 6e is a schematic diagram of an indirect type detector (CsPbBr3 scintillator-based radiation detector), which is characterized by a fast response speed[104]. X-ray photons are converted into visible light at the direct band gap of perovskite nanomaterials, and the light is converted into a point signal by a photomultiplier tube (PMT). The detector sensitivity can be improved by increasing the electron-hole recombination probability of perovskite nanocrystals. Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) layer as the device substrate.

5.2 Rare-earth doped lead halide perovskite radiation detector

Radiation detectors are mainly divided into direct detectors and indirect detectors. The direct detector is mainly used in radiation detection, imaging applications and energy spectrum measurement. The indirect detector is mainly used in the field of extremely weak detection signals, such as high-energy physics and medical CT. Among them, the direct detector has a faster response speed but is not suitable for the field of extremely weak signal detection. Indirect detectors can detect very weak signal fields, but their structure is more complex than that of direct detectors[104].
For the rare earth doped lead halide perovskite scintillator, the purpose of rare earth doping is to modulate the radioluminescence properties of the perovskite host. At present, there are two strategies for rare earth doping in lead halide perovskite scintillators: one is to introduce Yb3+ luminescence centers to achieve down-conversion emission through quantum cutting effect, and the other is to enhance the intrinsic emission of perovskite host by rare earth ions[24,89][91]. The ultimate goal is to improve the light yield of perovskite materials under irradiation, thereby improving their spatial resolution.
Dagnall et al. Made CsPbCl3:5%Yb3+ powder by evaporation combined with low temperature annealing, and made X-ray imaging devices by tabletting[24]. After doping, the intrinsic emission intensity of CsPbCl3 matrix at 406 nm decreases greatly, while the emission peak at 1 000 nm, which originates from the transition of Yb3+ ion 2F5/22F7/2, increases significantly. This shows that the CsPbCl3:Yb3+ has excellent quantum cutting effect. A light yield of 102 000 ph/MeV was obtained under X-ray excitation, and clear X-ray imaging was achieved. Lu et al. Obtained CsPbCl3:Yb3+, CsPbCl3:Er3+, CsPbCl3:Yb3+/Er3+ and CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+ single crystals by solvothermal method[89]. The CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+ exhibited a PLQY of up to 149%. Its quantum tailoring effect CsPbClxBr3-x:Yb3+ makes and have a large Stokes shift of 550 nm. The single crystal scintillator prepared by CsPbCl3:Yb3+ has a light yield of 1.12×105ph/MeV. Because of the excellent transparency and weak self-absorption of the single crystal, the detection limit of the CsPbCl3:Yb3+ single crystal reaches 176.5 nGyair/s.
Wu et al. Synthesized CsPbBr3∶Ce3+ nanocrystals by hot injection method and prepared transparent thin films for high-resolution X-ray imaging by suction filtration technique (Fig. 7 a – d)[91]. The light yield of nanocrystals doped with 33000 ions is greatly enhanced from 16 000 ph/MeV to 33 000 ph/MeV. Perovskite scintillation nanocrystals were combined with polystyrene (PS) layers by suction filtration, and finally an ultrathin transparent scintillation film of 30 μm was obtained. The film exhibits excellent scintillation performance, achieving a high spatial resolution of 580 lp/mm (≈ 862 nm).
图7 (a) CsPbBr3:Ce3+钙钛矿复合薄膜的光学照片;(b) CsPbBr3:Ce3+钙钛矿复合薄膜的横截面SEM照片;(c) CsPbBr3:Ce3+钙钛矿复合薄膜在X射线下的对LOGO的成像效果;(d) 不同浓度稀土掺杂的CsPbBr3:Ce3+的光产额变化[91]

Fig. 7 (a) Optical image of the CsPbBr3:Ce3+scintillator film without protective layer. (b) SEM image of the side of scintillator film. (c) the image effect of CsPbBr3:Ce3+ perovskite composite film on LOGO under X-ray. (d) the light yield changes of rare earth doped CsPbBr3:Ce3+ at different concentrations[91]. Copyright 2022 Wiley-VCH.

Rare earth doping can reduce the defects of lead halide perovskite single crystal, improve the carrier mobility, and ultimately enhance the detection sensitivity of optoelectronic devices. Zi et al. Synthesized MAPbI3:Yb3+, MAPbI3:Er3+, MAPbI3:Yb3+/Er3+ single crystals by solvothermal method[41]. MAPbI3:Yb3+/Er3+ possesses the lowest hole defect concentration (~0.61×1010cm-3 and high carrier mobility (212.12 cm2/V/s) as measured by the SCLC method. While the hole defect concentration and mobility of undoped MAPbI3 are about 2.36×1010cm-3 and 62.12 cm2/V/s. The conductivity after doping is increased by about one order of magnitude. The device fabricated by MAPbI3:Yb3+/Er3+ has multi-mode detection function (visible light, near-infrared light and X-ray detection). When used as an X-ray detector (Fig. 8a~c),MAPbI3:Yb3+/Er3+ single crystal has a photocurrent of 0.71 mA/cm2 (1 V bias) under X-ray irradiation at an intensity of 2.41 mG y a i r s - 1, compared with only 0.23 mA/cm2 for the undoped crystal. The detection sensitivity of MAPbI3∶Yb3+/Er3+ at -3 V/mm (1.16×106μCG y a i r - 1 ·cm-2) is 2.7 times higher than that of the undoped crystal.
图8 (a) 无掺杂MAPbI3和MAPbI3:RE3+的平面电极X射线探测器件结构图; (b) 1V偏压下无掺杂MAPbI3和MAPbI3:RE3+的光电流强度与辐射剂量率关系; (c) 无掺杂 MAPbI3和MAPbI3: RE3+X射线探测器件的在2.41 mGyair/s剂量下不同偏置电压设定下的灵敏度[41]

Fig. 8 (a) Illustration of parallel device structures of undoped MAPbI3 and MAPbI3:RE3+ Single crystals; (b) The relationship between photocurrent intensity and radiation dose rate of undoped MAPbI3 and MAPbI3:RE3+ at 1 V bias; (c) Bias-dependent sensitivity of the detectors at a 2.41 mGyair/s dose rate[41]. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society

5.3 Effect of rare earth doping on radiation stability of lead halide perovskite

The radiation stability of materials is also an important indicator of radiation detection materials. Quinn et al. Prepared CsPbBr3 and CsPbBr3:Eu thin films by spin coating method using EuBr2 as the rare earth source[105]. XPS shows that Eu exists in the form of both Eu2+ and Eu3+. The results of synchrotron X-ray diffraction show that the single CsPbBr3:Eu crystal is actually polycrystalline. It shows that Eu clusters can act as nucleation sites and promote polycrystalline growth. It is worth noting that CsPbBr3:Eu and CsPbBr3 were subjected to continuous 10 keV hard X-ray (≈1.9×1021ph/cm2/s) irradiation,The shift of the diffraction peak of CsPbBr3:Eu at 3.3Å-1 with irradiation time is much lower than that of the undoped crystal, indicating that the lattice structure change of CsPbBr3:Eu due to irradiation is less than that of the undoped crystal.

6 Conclusion and prospect

Rare earth doped lead halide perovskite materials are a new research field in recent years. In this paper, the research progress in recent years is reviewed from the aspects of different rare earth ion doping, rare earth ion doping sites, photoluminescence and photoelectric energy converter. It includes the following aspects:
1) At present, a series of trivalent rare earth ions (La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb, Lu) and divalent rare earth Eu have been reported to dope lead halide perovskites, and the doping concentrations of different lead halide perovskites are quite different. The doping concentration of monocrystalline rare earth can reach 1.7%(Dy3+), the doping concentration of nanocrystalline can reach 5.7%(Yb3+), and the concentration of powder can reach 8.7%(Yb3+).
2) Luminescent rare earth ions introduced into the perovskite lattice can be used as luminescent centers to achieve energy transfer. Some rare earth ions (La3+, Ce3+, Nd3+, Y3+, etc.) can increase the intrinsic emission intensity of perovskite by reducing the non-radiative recombination of perovskite.
3) Rare earth ions can introduce donor levels to reduce trap state density, optimize carrier performance, and further improve the sensitivity, detection limit and other performance indicators of perovskite photoelectric detectors.
Challenges and prospects:
1) Rare earth doped lead halide perovskite, the doping concentration of nanocrystals and powders is higher than that of bulk materials. Considering that the specific surface area of nanocrystals and powder crystals is larger than that of bulk materials, the difference in doping concentration may be due to the fact that most of the rare earth ions are doped through surface adsorption. The study of the composition distribution of rare earth ions in lead halide perovskites has shown that rare earth doping can lead to the enrichment of rare earth ions on the crystal surface. Rare earth ion doping is a difficult problem in the single crystal growth process, because the relationship between the single crystal growth process and the rare earth ion doping process is still unclear. There is a lack of single crystal growth technology to ensure the crystal quality of lead halide perovskite single crystal and high concentration of rare earth doping at the same time. The effect of the change of rare earth concentration in the process of rare earth doping on the properties of materials needs to be explored.
2) The radius of rare earth ions is similar to that of lead ions, so the doping of rare earth ions may not produce obvious changes in cell size, and it is difficult to observe the shift of diffraction peaks in X-ray diffraction spectra. For low rare earth doping concentration, various composition testing methods also have their limitations. Controlling the spatial distribution of rare earth doping and achieving spatially resolved structural and compositional characterization of rare earth doping is a great challenge.
3) Rare earth ion doping realizes the modulation of semiconductor properties, fluorescence properties and optoelectronic device properties of perovskite. Rare earth ions may play a more important role in the application of perovskite in photovoltaic and optoelectronic devices.
[1]
Tailor N K, Kar S, Mishra P, These A, Kupfer C, Hu H L, Awais M, Saidaminov M, Dar M I, Brabec C, Satapathi S. ACS Mater. Lett., 2021, 3(7): 1025.

[2]
Lin H R, Zhou C K, Tian Y, Siegrist T, Ma B W. ACS Energy Lett., 2018, 3(1): 54.

[3]
Yuan Z, Zhou C K, Tian Y, Shu Y, Messier J, Wang J C, van de Burgt L J, Kountouriotis K, Xin Y, Holt E, Schanze K, Clark R, Siegrist T, Ma B W. Nat. Commun., 2017, 8: 14051.

[4]
Li X T, Hoffman J M, Kanatzidis M G. Chem. Rev., 2021, 121(4): 2230.

[5]
DuanD W, Ge C Y, Rahaman M Z, Lin C, Shi Y M, Lin H R, Hu H L, Wu T. NPG Asia Mater., 2023, 15: 1.

[6]
Sun S Q, Lu M, Gao X P, Shi Z F, Bai X E, Yu W W, Zhang Y. Adv. Sci., 2021, 8(24): 2102689.

[7]
MitziD B. J. Chem. Soc.,Dalton Trans., 2001(1): 1.

[8]
Kojima A, Teshima K, Shirai Y, Miyasaka T. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2009, 131(17): 6050.

[9]
Im J H, Lee C R, Lee J W, Park S W, Park N G. Nanoscale, 2011, 3(10): 4088.

[10]
Ling Y C, Yuan Z, Tian Y, Wang X, Wang J C, Xin Y, Hanson K, Ma B W, Gao H W. Adv. Mater., 2016, 28(2): 305.

[11]
Xing G C, Mathews N, Lim S S, Yantara N, Liu X F, SabbaD, Grätzel M, Mhaisalkar S, Sum T C. Nat. Mater., 2014, 13(5): 476.

[12]
Chen Q S, Wu J, Ou X Y, Huang B L, Almutlaq J, Zhumekenov A A, Guan X W, Han S Y, Liang L L, Yi Z G, Li J A, Xie X J, Wang Y, Li Y, FanD Y, TehD B L, All A H, Mohammed O F, Bakr O M, Wu T, Bettinelli M, Yang H H, Huang W, Liu X G. Nature, 2018, 561(7721): 88.

[13]
Heo J H, ShinD H, Park J K, KimD H, Lee S J, Im S H. Adv. Mater., 2018, 30(40): 1801743.

[14]
Zhang S Y. Spectroscopy of Rare Earth Ions:Spectral Properties And Spectral Theory. Beijing: Science Press, 2008.

(张思远. 稀土离子的光谱学:光谱性质和光谱理论. 北京: 科学出版社, 2008.).

[15]
Zhang Y. Rare Earth Functional Materials. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 2015.

(张胤. 稀土功能材料. 北京: 化学工业出版社, 2015.).

[16]
Yan Y L, Cao J M, Meng F N, Wang N, Gao L G, Ma T L. Prog. Chem., 2019, 31(07): 1031.

(闫业玲, 曹俊媚, 孟凡宁, 王宁, 高立国, 马廷丽. 化学进展, 2019, 31(07): 1031.).

[17]
Duan J L, Zhao Y Y, Yang X Y, Wang YD, He B L, Tang Q W. Adv. Energy Mater., 2018, 8(31): 1802346.

[18]
Zeng Z C, Xu Y S, Zhang Z S, Gao Z S, Luo M, Yin Z Y, Zhang C, Xu J, Huang B L, Luo F, Du Y P, Yan C H. Chem. Soc. Rev., 2020, 49(4): 1109.

[19]
Crane M J, KroupaD M, Roh J Y, Anderson R T, Smith MD, GamelinD R. ACS Appl. Energy Mater., 2019, 2(6): 4560.

[20]
Jiang F. Research on optic property in the ions-doped all inorganic perovskite. Master’s Thesis,Hunan University,China, 2020.

(姜峰. 基于离子掺杂全无机钙钛矿的发光特性研究. 硕士学位论文,湖南大学, 2020.).

[21]
Leupold N, Panzer F. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2021, 31(14): 2007350.

[22]
Aleksanyan E, Aprahamian A, Mukasyan A S, Harutyunyan V, Manukyan K V. J. Mater. Sci., 2020, 55(20): 8665.

[23]
Stefanski M, Ptak M, Sieradzki A, Strek W. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 408: 127347.

[24]
Dagnall K A, Conley A M, Yoon L U, Rajeev H S, Lee S H, Choi J J. ACS Omega, 2022, 7(24): 20968.

[25]
Jurisch M, Eichler S, Bruder M. Vertical bridgman growth of binary compound semiconductors. In: Rudolph P (ed) Handbook of Crystal Growth (Second Edition). Boston: Elsevier, 2015. 331.

[26]
JuD X, Zheng X P, Yin J, Qiu Z W, Türedi B, Liu X L, Dang Y Y, Cao B Q, Mohammed O F, Bakr O M, Tao X T. ACS Energy Lett., 2019, 4(1): 228.

[27]
Saidaminov M I, Abdelhady A L, Murali B, Alarousu E, Burlakov V M, Peng W, Dursun I, Wang L F, He Y, Maculan G, Goriely A, Wu T, Mohammed O F, Bakr O M. Nat. Commun., 2015, 6: 7586.

[28]
ShiD, Adinolfi V, Comin R, Yuan M, Alarousu E, Buin A, Chen Y, Hoogland S, Rothenberger A, Katsiev K, Losovyj Y, Zhang X, Dowben P A, Mohammed O F, Sargent E H, Bakr O M. Science, 2015, 347(6221): 519.

[29]
Bari M, Wu H A, Bokov A A, Ali R F, Tailor H N, Gates BD, Ye Z G. CrystEngComm, 2021, 23(18): 3326.

[30]
Stoumpos C C, Malliakas CD, Peters J A, Liu Z F, Sebastian M, Im J, Chasapis T C, Wibowo A C, ChungD Y, Freeman A J, Wessels B W, Kanatzidis M G. Cryst. GrowthDes., 2013, 13(7): 2722.

[31]
Zhang P, Sun Q H, Xu YD, Li X A, Liu L, Zhang GD, Tao X T. Cryst. GrowthDes., 2020, 20(4): 2424.

[32]
Watanabe K, Koshimizu M, Yanagida T, Fujimoto Y, Asai K. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 2016, 55(2S): 02BC20.

[33]
Hommerich U, Uba S, Kabir A, Trivedi S B, Yang C, Brown E E. Opt. Mater. Express, 2020, 10(8): 2011.

[34]
Brown E E, Fleischman ZD, McKay J, Hommerich U, Kabir A A, Riggins J, Trivedi S, Dubinskii M. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 2022, 40(1): A1.

[35]
Roh J YD, Smith MD, Crane M J, BinerD, Milstein T J, Krämer K W, GamelinD R. Phys. Rev. Mate., 2020, 4(10): 105405.

[36]
Velázquez M, Ferrier A, PÉchev S, Gravereau P, Chaminade J P, Portier X, MoncorgÉ R. J. Cryst. Growth, 2008, 310(24): 5458.

[37]
Ma L, Yan Z G, Zhou X Y, Pi Y Q, Du Y P, Huang J E, Wang K W, Wu K, Zhuang C Q, Han XD. Nat. Commun., 2021, 12: 2023.

[38]
Wang S, Chen Y A, Yao J J, Zhao G X, Li L Z, Zou G F. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2021, 9(20): 6498.

[39]
Rong S S, Xiao Y Q, Jiang J X, Zeng Q G, Li Y B. J. Phys. Chem. C, 2020, 124(16): 8992.

[40]
Nandihalli N, GregoryD H, Mori T K. Adv. Sci., 2022, 9(25): 2106052.

[41]
Zi L, Xu W, Sun R, Li Z M, Zhang J W, Liu L, Wang N, Wang Y E, Ding N, Hu J H, Lu S Y, Zhu H C, Song H W. Chem. Mater., 2022, 34(16): 7412.

[42]
Chen X Y, Xu J, Xu Y S, Luo F, Du Y P. Inorg. Chem. Front., 2019, 6: 2226.

[43]
Protesescu L, Yakunin S, Bodnarchuk M I, Krieg F, Caputo R, Hendon C H, Yang R X, Walsh A, Kovalenko M V. Nano Lett., 2015, 15(6): 3692.

[44]
Zhang F, Zhong H Z, Chen C, Wu X G, Hu X M, Huang H L, Han J B, Zou B S, Dong Y P. ACS Nano, 2015, 9(4): 4533.

[45]
Pan G C, Bai X E, YangD W, Chen X, Jing P T, Qu S N, Zhang L J, ZhouD L, Zhu J Y, Xu W, Dong B A, Song H W. Nano Lett., 2017, 17(12): 8005.

[46]
Liu L J, Li J T, McLeod J A. Nanoscale, 2018, 10(24): 11452.

[47]
Debnath G H, Bloom B P, Tan S S, WaldeckD H. Nanoscale, 2022, 14(16): 6037.

[48]
Sun R. Doctor’sDissertation of Jilin University,China, 2023.

(孙蕊. 吉林大学博士学位论文, 2023.).

[49]
Dong Y R, Zeng P, Yu Y, Xie Y J, Yang B L, Liang R Q, Ou Q R, Zhang S Y. Adv. Electron. Mater., 2020, 6(3): 1901162.

[50]
Wang L, Zhou H, Hu J, Huang B, Sun M, Dong B, Zheng G, Huang Y, Chen Y, Li L, Xu Z, Li N, Liu Z, Chen Q, Sun LD, Yan C H. Science. 2019, 363(6424): 265.

[51]
Yang Y Q, Wu J H, Wang X B, Guo Q Y, Liu X P, Sun W H, Wei Y L, Huang Y F, Lan Z, Huang M L, Lin J M, Chen H W, Wei Z H. Adv. Mater., 2020, 32(7): 1904347.

[52]
Wu X F, Sun J, Shao H, Zhai Y, Li L F, Chen WD, Zhu J Y, Dong B, Xu L, ZhouD L, Xu W, Song H W, Bai X. Chem. Eng. J., 2021, 426: 131310.

[53]
Lei J, Chang L Y, Dong Z H, Liu L J. Mater. Res. Bull., 2021, 137: 111191.

[54]
Wang Q, Wang X M, Yang Z, Zhou N H, Deng Y H, Zhao J J, Xiao X, Rudd P, Moran A, Yan Y F, Huang J S. Nat. Commun., 2019, 10: 5633.

[55]
Lin Y Z, Shao Y C, Dai J, Li T, Liu Y, Dai X Z, Xiao X, Deng Y H, Gruverman A, Zeng X C, Huang J S. Nat. Commun., 2021, 12: 7.

[56]
Ma J P, Chen Y M, Zhang L M, Guo S Q, Liu JD, Li H, Ye B J, Li Z Y, Zhou Y, Zhang B B, Bakr O M, Zhang J Y, Sun H T. J. Mater. Chem. C, 2019, 7(10): 3037.

[57]
Stefanski M, Boiko V, Ptak M, Strek W. J. Alloys Compd., 2022, 905: 164216.

[58]
Song Z L, Xu W, Wu Y J, Liu S N, Bi W B, Chen X F, Song H W. Small, 2020, 16(40): 2001770.

[59]
Liu Y N, Pan G C, Wang R, Shao H, Wang H, Xu W, Cui H N, Song H W. Nanoscale, 2018, 10(29): 14067.

[60]
He L J, Meng J L, Feng J, Liu X J, Zhang H J. Inorg. Chem. Front., 2020, 7(23): 4669.

[61]
Milstein T J, KroupaD M, GamelinD R. Nano Lett., 2018, 18(6): 3792.

[62]
Li X Y, Duan S, Liu H C, Chen G Y, Luo Y, Ågren H. J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 2019, 10(3): 487.

[63]
Zhou L, Liu T R, Zheng J, Yu K, Yang F, Wang N, Zuo Y H, Liu Z, Xue C L, Li C B, Cheng B W, Wang Q M. J. Phys. Chem. C, 2018, 122(47): 26825.

[64]
Cao Q X, Ilyas A, Zhang S A, Ju Z J, Sun F L, Liu T Y, Yang Y, Lu Y H, Liu X F, Deng R R. Nanoscale, 2021, 13(26): 11552.

[65]
Wang K, Zheng L Y, Zhu T, Yao X, Yi C, Zhang X T, Cao Y, Liu L, Hu W P, Gong X. Nano Energy, 2019, 61: 352.

[66]
Xie Y J, Peng B, Bravić I, Yu Y, Dong Y R, Liang R Q, Ou Q R, Monserrat B, Zhang S Y. Adv. Sci., 2020, 7(20): 2001698.

[67]
Sun R, Lu P, ZhouD L, Xu W, Ding N, Shao H, Zhang Y, LiD Y, Wang N, Zhuang X M, Dong B A, Bai X E, Song H W. ACS Energy Lett., 2020, 5(7): 2131.

[68]
Kluherz K T, Mergelsberg S T, SommerD E, Roh J YD, Saslow S A, BinerD, Krämer K W, Dunham S T, de Yoreo J J, GamelinD R. Phys. Rev. Mate., 2022, 6(7): 074601.

[69]
Ferro S M, Wobben M, Ehrler B. Mater. Horiz., 2021, 8(4): 1072.

[70]
CortecchiaD, MrÓz W, Folpini G, Borzda T, Leoncino L, Alvarado-Leaños A L, Speller E M, Petrozza A. Chem. Mater., 2021, 33(7): 2289.

[71]
XuD, Sun C, Han J C, Zhang H, Tao J Q, Wei T, Fan C, Zhang Z H, Bi W G. J. Alloys Compd., 2022, 902: 163841.

[72]
Mondal B, Poovathan A, Sheikh T, Nag A. ChemNanoMat, 2022, 8(8): e202200104.

[73]
Xia W L, Ren Z W, Zheng Z S, Luo C Z, Li J E, Ma W C, Zhou X, Chen Y. Nanoscale, 2023, 15(3): 1109.

[74]
Shu B W, Chang Y J, Zhang J H, Cheng X P, YuD B. Nano Res., 2021, 14(10): 3352.

[75]
Yao J S, Ge J, Han B N, Wang K H, Yao H B, Yu H L, Li J H, Zhu B S, Song J Z, Chen C, Zhang Q, Zeng H B, Luo Y, Yu S H. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2018, 140(10): 3626.

[76]
Yin J, Ahmed G H, Bakr O M, BrÉdas J L, Mohammed O F. ACS Energy Lett., 2019, 4(3): 789.

[77]
Milstein T J, Roh J YD, Jacoby L M, Crane M J, SommerD E, Dunham S T, GamelinD R. Chem. Mater., 2022, 34(8): 3759.

[78]
Ahmed G H, El-Demellawi J K, Yin J, Pan J, VelusamyD B, Hedhili M N, Alarousu E, Bakr O M, Alshareef H N, Mohammed O F. ACS Energy Lett., 2018, 3(10): 2301.

[79]
Euvrard J, Yan Y F, MitziD B. Nat. Rev. Mater., 2021, 6(6): 531.

[80]
Xu X W, Wang Y Q, Meng H X, Zhu T S, YanD, Zhu W J, Liu S J, Zhao Q A. Matter, 2022, 5(7): 2086.

[81]
Lyons J L. Chem. Mater., 2021, 33(15): 6200.

[82]
Mannodi-Kanakkithodi A, Park J S, Jeon N, CaoD H, GosztolaD J, Martinson A B F, Chan M K Y. Chem. Mater., 2019, 31(10): 3599.

[83]
Marchenko E I, Fateev S A, Eremin N N, Chen Q, Goodilin E A, Tarasov A B. ACS Mater. Lett., 2021, 3(9): 1377.

[84]
Freitas A L M, Tofanello A, Bonadio A, Souza J A. J. Mater. Sci., 2022, 33(23): 18327.

[85]
Liu J L, Wang S Y, Chen M Y, Jiang P, Cao L X, Li W H, Ran H B, Hu Y E, Han H W, Tang Y W. Sol. RRL, 2022, 6(9): 2200361.

[86]
Yang Y, HanD W, Yang Y, Yi S W, Yuan Q A, ZhouD Y, Feng L. APL Mater., 2020, 8(7): 071102.

[87]
Parveen S, Das M, Ghosh S, Giri P K. Nanoscale, 2022, 14(17): 6402.

[88]
Zhang Y Q, Cheng X Y, TuD T, Gong Z L, Li R F, Yang Y J, Zheng W, Xu J, Deng S Q, Chen X Y. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2021, 60(17): 9693.

[89]
Zi L, Song J A, Wang N, Wang T Y, Li W, Zhu H C, Xu W, Song H W. Laser Photonics Rev., 2023, 17(5): 2200852.

[90]
KroupaD M, Roh J Y, Milstein T J, Creutz S E, GamelinD R. ACS Energy Lett., 2018, 3(10): 2390.

[91]
Wu X C, Guo Z, Zhu S A, Zhang B B, Guo S M, Dong X H, Mei L Q, Liu R X, Su C J, Gu Z J. Adv. Sci., 2022, 9(17): 2200831.

[92]
Wang M, Deng K M, Meng L X, Li L A. Small Meth., 2020, 4(2): 1900652.

[93]
Wu X W, Li H W, Wang K, Sun X W, Wang LD. RSC Adv., 2018, 8(20): 11095.

[94]
Shen L N, Chen R, ZhangD, Yilmazoglu U C, Gu K, Sarmiento J S, Zhu T, Zheng L Y, Zheng J E, Wang H, Liu C M, Gong X. Adv. Funct. Mater., 2022, 32(47): 2207911.

[95]
Zhao Y P, Yavuz I, Wang M H, Weber M H, Xu M J, Lee J H, Tan S, Huang T Y, MengD, Wang R, Xue J J, Lee S J, Bae S H, Zhang A N, Choi S G, Yin Y F, Liu J, Han T H, Shi Y T, Ma H R, Yang W X, Xing Q Y, Zhou Y F, Shi P J, Wang S S, Zhang E, Bian J M, Pan X Q, Park N G, Lee J W, Yang Y. Nat. Mater., 2022, 21(12): 1396.

[96]
Jin P, Tang Y J, LiD W, Wang Y, Ran P, Zhou C Y, Yuan Y, Zhu W J, Liu T Y, Liang K, Kuang C F, Liu X, Zhu B W, Yang Y. Nat. Commun., 2023, 14: 626.

[97]
Sun R J, Wang Z F, Wang H Q, Chen Z H, Yao Y G, Zhang H P, Gao Y N, Hao X T, Liu H Q, Zhang Y H. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2022, 14(32): 36801.

[98]
He Y H, Petryk M, Liu Z F, ChicaD G, Hadar I, Leak C, Ke W J, Spanopoulos I, Lin W W, ChungD Y, Wessels B W, He Z, Kanatzidis M G. Nat. Photonics, 2021, 15(1): 36.

[99]
Devanathan R, Corrales L R, Gao F, Weber W J. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. Sect. A, 2006, 565(2): 637.

[100]
Zhou F G, Li Z Z, Lan W, Wang Q A, Ding L M, Jin Z W. Small Meth., 2020, 4(10): 2000506.

[101]
Xu X, Qian W, Xiao S, Wang J, Zheng S, Yang S. EcoMat., 2020, 2(4): 12064.

[102]
Zi L, Song J A, Wang N, Wang T Y, Li W, Zhu H C, Xu W, Song H W. Laser Photonics Rev., 2023, 17(5): 2200852.

[103]
Hu G J, Chen Q, Wei W, Sun Z C, Yao M N, Shen L. Chin. J. Lumin., 2023, 44(5): 771.

(胡刚舰, 陈琦, 魏薇, 孙仔成, 姚梦楠, 沈亮. 发光学报, 2023, 44(5): 771.).

[104]
Meng G, Ye Y Q, Fan L M, Wang S M, Volodymyr G, Fang XD. J. Inorg. Mater., 2020, 35(11): 1203.

(孟钢, 叶雨琪, 范黎明, 王时茂, Gnatyuk Volodymyr, 方晓东. 无机材料学报, 2020, 35(11): 1203.).

[105]
Quinn X L, Kumar R E, Kodur M, CakanD N, Cai Z H, Zhou T, Holt M V, FenningD P. Adv. Opt. Mater., 2021, 9(18): 2002221.

Outlines

/